3 ms·
I am another one who fails to see the need or novelty in this product.
by collyw 12y ago
I am another one who fails to see the need or novelty in this product.
- stronglikedan 12y agoThere are some people who loathe eating, and derive zero pleasure from their taste sense. They perceive meals as a chore. Those people are their very small target market for the complete-meal-replacement aspect of their product.
- mscman 12y agoAs the article mentions, there are also people who lack the money or time to eat healthy all the time. College students in particular are pretty famous for their ramen meals because they're cheap and easy. They're also not filled with nutrients you need. Soylent proposes an alternative to cheap $0.50 noodles that is a lot healthier. I know if it was available when I was a college student, it would probably have been in my pantry. I haven't tried Soylent yet, but probably will give it a shot to fill in those meals I can't make due to time constraints.
- stronglikedan 12y agoSince I don't have the cred to edit a comment that's been replied to yet, I'll clarify in a reply: You are absolutely correct, and I should have been more clear about the complete-meal-replacement aspect. I was referring to the small segment of people that would love to replace every meal with something like Soylent. So maybe "complete-food-replacement" would have conveyed my intended meaning a bit better. I too ate lots of Ramen in college, but in order to prevent myself from wanting to slit my wrists, I'd usually seek out at least one meal a day with some nutiritional value, and, more importantly, flavor that wasn't just salt water.
- delecti 12y agoOther than those you've heard about specifically in contrast to Soylent, can you name any alternatives intended for individual (not medical) use? (specifically those intended as meal replacement without ulterior motives, IE not Slim-fast which is intended for weight loss) I certainly can't, and that's the niche Soylent fills. It markets itself to the mass market.
- michaelbuddy 12y agoDon't confuse the product that's popular in hospital that it's for medical use exclusively. Hospitals in the U.S. have Boost and Ensure and those are available in grocery stores and pharmacies, but it's not like they say "For medical use only" Boost's box says "Complete Nutritional Drink" Boost is by Nestle, so of course there's chocolate/vanilla and sugar in it. You get about 12 servings for somewhere around 9-12 dollars. College students could easily buy these. Occasionally I've been known to buy a pack when I'm contracting where lunch options are too fastfoody and a better lunch is a boost and maybe a bag of mixed nuts. My problem with these supplements is the amounts of vitamins for example contained in a product say nothing of absorption, I'm not even sure we have any good information on absorption. I guess you'd have to put people in a lab, control their eating and drinking for a several weeks and weigh and examine their BMs and fluids to know what's being absorbed.
- Hiwot_Tesfaye 12y agoI must agree with you on this one. It's true, the market has an itch: people are health conscious and want to eat well but they are stretched for time (and money in most cases). But is a nutrient extract meal-replacement the answer? After investigating the obstacles people in Toronto face with preparing healthy food, this is what we, at Meal Garden (http://www.mealgarden.com http://www.mealgarden.com), have come to understand: There's almost always a trade-off between TASTE, CONVENIENCE(time/money), and HEALTH. If the meal satisfies two out of three, most people will opt to eat that meal. But one of those three priorities is compromised - and that is the market itch that Soylent has not been able to scratch. But it doesn't have to be a "two-out-out-of-three" trade-off. Food should (and can) be healthy, convenient and taste amazing all at the same time. But people need shortcuts and tools to connect them to food providers in their area. As well as a general health guide on what options are healthier than others. All this can definitely be done given the right amount of time to build these marketplace tools (web and mobile applications to be more specific).