4 ms·
My grandpa didn't talk much about the war. I'll never know what he went through. He went all the way to Berlin with the Soviet Army, that's the only thing I kno
by rdtsc 12y ago
My grandpa didn't talk much about the war. I'll never know what he went through. He went all the way to Berlin with the Soviet Army, that's the only thing I know.
The other one was sent to China, Canton (not sure how accurate this is, as that is in the South, not North or West, as I would have imagined). It was to "help fight off the Japanese". He also never wanted to talk about the war.
- dba7dba 12y agoIt seems many people who experienced the full brunt of war (like having killed people up close or witness close friends get knocked out again and again) don't even want to remember or talk about it because the it's just too painful.
- jonmrodriguez 12y agoMost likely there was a huge difference in that regard in navy vs army...
- jonmrodriguez 12y agoI'm guessing that the reason this was downvoted was that I communicated poorly. Here is a better wording of what I was trying to say: In the Navy you sink a ship from far away. It's more abstract; you don't see the enemy up close. In the Army you fight battles face to face with the enemy, and it must be correspondingly more horrible. So I would guess that Navy people (like my grandpa) had a generally more positive memory of the war than Army people.
- arethuza 12y agoI don't know - naval warfare in WW2 could be pretty grim. I can recommend Nicholas Monsarrat's "Three Corvettes" on his wartime naval experiences - I happened to buy this without knowing much about the book in Heathrow before a flight over the North Atlantic to the US. One of the relatively small number of books that has moved me to tears. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Monsarrat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicholas_Monsarrat He also wrote the novel "The Cruel Sea" which was made into one of the best naval war movies of WW2.
- luckyno13 12y agoIt could be because pretty much all branches have ground deploy-able forces so it isn't necessarily true that they aren't exposed to the horrors of war on a person to person level.
- classicsnoot 12y agoI know this outs me as a cloistered american, but my mental narrative of WWII is woefully bereft of accounts outside of the US Britain, and Germany. The thought of your Pop Pop slogging through the countryside towards Berlin gave me goosebumps. Where is that movie, i ask you. Thanks.
- hordac 12y agoThere's a movie released in 2001, called Enemy at the Gates, but it's kind of cheesy. But since you asked, it qualifies as the ever-so-rare Hollywood movie about a WWII scenario, involving a Russian protagonist, as told from a Soviet perspective. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0215750/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0215750/ It's the only English-language movie I can think of that fits those criteria.
- classicsnoot 12y agoIn no way did i imply that english language only was a parameter, bro.
- jacquesm 12y agoWay to thank someone for doing work on your behalf.
- brudgers 12y agoThe scale of the War in the Soviet Union was vast. 26,000,000 is the commonly agreed on estimate of USSR deaths from the war. The theatre contained hundreds of divisions - many times those in which the US and Britain fought. A book on Stalingrad I recently enjoyed: http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0140284583/ref=redir_mdp_mobile http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0140284583/ref=redir_mdp_mobil...
- classicsnoot 12y agoUnderstand, I am well aware of the facts and figures of the East's struggle. I have sat and talked with nearly 50 WWII vets at length, and not one of them from anywhere but the US, Britain, and Germany. The road to victory that Mother Russia took is informative when considering the events of the present.
- hkmurakami 12y agoMy maternal grandfather was in the Japanese Army, and while I do not know the details, spent six years in the mines in Russia. I could never get myself to ask what his time was like. Even when he was diagnosed with cancer and I knew that he didn't have much more time to live, I still felt that I could not do him the cruelty of digging up those memories from him. :(
- rdtsc 12y agoThat is very sad. A lot of prisoners of war and internal political prisoners were sent to mine uranium. It was basically a slow death sentence.
- paganel 12y agoMy ex-wife's grandfather fought on the other side (as part of the Romanian Army), and after he came back from the Eastern Front he tried as best as he could to support and tell the story of his "comrades" (he would always call them with that name, even in his 90s). Of course he, like almost all the soldiers involved in that war, had nothing personal against the soldiers they were fighting against, they were just small pawns in a greater, horrible game. He once told the story of a Russian old couple who had received him in their house as the Romanian Army was retreating from outside Stalingrad, in a -30 degrees winter. Without this couple helping him he wouldn't have made it back to his wife. Although he came from a traditional, rural background, the horrors he had seen in the war scarred him for life, turning him into an atheist. Even in his old age he was saying that there could be no God that would allow happening the stuff that he had seen. War is hell.