3 ms·
Actually, this statement of PG’s about Darwin’s contemporaries is pretty oversimplified. Evolution-like ideas had been “in the air” for several decades when Dar
by jacobolus 17y ago
Actually, this statement of PG’s about Darwin’s contemporaries is pretty oversimplified. Evolution-like ideas had been “in the air” for several decades when Darwin published, and at the time, many regarded them as heresy (by default), while others had bought into them. Natural selection was indeed a new idea, but while it strengthened the argument for evolution tremendously by providing a plausible mechanism, and while the giant pile of evidence in Darwin’s book was extremely important, the debates at the time weren’t all that different in tone from the ones that happen today (except that today all of the legitimate scientists are on one side these days).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_evolutionary_thought http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_evolutionary_thought
Lamark’s main works were from the turn of the 19th century, as was Cuvier’s work on extinction, and Darwin’s uncle Erasmus’s descriptions of “metamorphoses”. Paley’s Natural Theology, which originated the famous “watchmaker” analogy for God, was from 1802. The Vestiges, published anonymously in 1844, sparked massive controversy that was the talk of “educated” people throughout the world. Indeed, when Darwin finally published the Origin in 1859, the scientific/religious debate had been widespread for 50 years, and in the general public consciousness for at least a decade or two; Darwin himself had been well aware of it as a young man.