4 ms·

Unfortunately, forums with decent security, forums that are free, and forums that have the features you are looking for are groups that rarely overlap. SMF was

Unfortunately, forums with decent security, forums that are free, and forums that have the features you are looking for are groups that rarely overlap. SMF was the only viable option for a forum I started. My requirements were 1. An events calendar 2. Discussion boards with varying permissions 3. Tiered membership 4. Automatic events newletter 5. Costs less than $10/month to host 6. Takes less than 2 hours/month of technical work to run 7. Can be set up and running in less than 40 hours. 8. Can be run/hosted by someone else if I'm no longer have time to manage the site. I'd write my own but there's only so much time available in a day. I'll be looking into a way to add bcrypt hashing to SMF as a plugin. Not an easy thing to solve. Edit: "newsletter" isn't the same thing as forum reply notifications. Edit2: Added requirement #8.

nwh 12y ago
bitcointalk.org is spending millions on their new forum system that's being written from scratch. Hopefully that will be one to look out for when it's complete.
- epochwolf 12y ago
  It doesn't look like bitcointalk.org is using the calendar feature. :(
  - infogulch 12y ago
    What's wrong with a google calendar? I'm pretty sure you can embed it.
    - epochwolf 12y ago
      Google calendar would require double entry. Right now the calendar links directly to forum posts and can be created, edited, and deleted at the same time. There is also an issue of moderator training if the site gets larger or someone else takes over after me.
infogulch 12y ago
Have you considered Discourse[1]? It can act as a mailing list with reply-able email notifications or daily/weekly/semi-weekly digests. Super easy setup and maintenance. [1]: http://www.discourse.org/ http://www.discourse.org/
- epochwolf 12y ago
  Discourse lacks an integrated calendar. Also, forum notifications aren't sufficient when I want to set a weekly events newletter to people that haven't read the forum recently.
  - infogulch 12y ago
    In Discourse, the word for "newsletter" is "digest". And it can be set up by users to email them weekly. About the integrated calendar, you're right it doesn't have one integrated. I wonder if someone would develop a plugin[1] for it... Edit: Actually, somebody already thought of this and there's already a plugin[2] for it. Here it is in action[3]. [1]: https://meta.discourse.org/category/extensibility/plugin https://meta.discourse.org/category/extensibility/plugin [2]: https://meta.discourse.org/t/discourse-topics-as-google-calendar-events/11794 https://meta.discourse.org/t/discourse-topics-as-google-cale... [3]: http://yhteinen.fi/events?locale=en http://yhteinen.fi/events?locale=en
    - epochwolf 12y ago
      Interesting. This wasn't available back in February. I considered Discourse since I am very familiar with rails but adding the features I required would have taken more time than I had back then.

nwh 12y ago

bitcointalk.org is spending millions on their new forum system that's being written from scratch. Hopefully that will be one to look out for when it's complete.

epochwolf 12y ago
It doesn't look like bitcointalk.org is using the calendar feature. :(
- infogulch 12y ago
  What's wrong with a google calendar? I'm pretty sure you can embed it.
  - epochwolf 12y ago
    Google calendar would require double entry. Right now the calendar links directly to forum posts and can be created, edited, and deleted at the same time. There is also an issue of moderator training if the site gets larger or someone else takes over after me.

infogulch 12y ago

Have you considered Discourse[1]? It can act as a mailing list with reply-able email notifications or daily/weekly/semi-weekly digests. Super easy setup and maintenance. [1]: http://www.discourse.org/ http://www.discourse.org/

epochwolf 12y ago
Discourse lacks an integrated calendar. Also, forum notifications aren't sufficient when I want to set a weekly events newletter to people that haven't read the forum recently.
- infogulch 12y ago
  In Discourse, the word for "newsletter" is "digest". And it can be set up by users to email them weekly. About the integrated calendar, you're right it doesn't have one integrated. I wonder if someone would develop a plugin[1] for it... Edit: Actually, somebody already thought of this and there's already a plugin[2] for it. Here it is in action[3]. [1]: https://meta.discourse.org/category/extensibility/plugin https://meta.discourse.org/category/extensibility/plugin [2]: https://meta.discourse.org/t/discourse-topics-as-google-calendar-events/11794 https://meta.discourse.org/t/discourse-topics-as-google-cale... [3]: http://yhteinen.fi/events?locale=en http://yhteinen.fi/events?locale=en
  - epochwolf 12y ago
    Interesting. This wasn't available back in February. I considered Discourse since I am very familiar with rails but adding the features I required would have taken more time than I had back then.