3 ms·
> I should add that a quick perusal of their comment history finds them engaged in many, many Go threads, always dismissive of Go. Again, to be active in Rust s
by pcwalton 12y ago
> I should add that a quick perusal of their comment history finds them engaged in many, many Go threads, always dismissive of Go. Again, to be active in Rust seems to be some sort of call-to-arms against Go.
I certainly don't see it that way. I comment in Go threads occasionally because I have experience in the areas people are discussing (for example, garbage collection). Again, I think Go is a really practical language for the kinds of things people are doing with it, like Docker and Camlistore.
> In many other domains it needs to be analyzed, and there are no hard and fast rules.
Sure, I agree with that. The question is what you do when it becomes a problem. That's where having precise control can help.
- enneff 12y agoI know the Rust team doesn't have any animosity toward Go, at least not those that I have talked to. And the Go team certainly doesn't have anything against Rust. But I must say that I do notice you being overwhelmingly negative about Go a lot on HN and I wonder why you do that. Technically, yes, you are adding to the discussion in some ways but to me it seems unnecessary.
- kibwen 12y agoCan you cite some overwhelmingly negative comments that pcwalton has made towards Go? I always cringe whenever I see him comment in a Go-related thread, because I know how people will interpret any criticism of Go that comes directly from a Rust dev, whether or not the criticism itself mentions Rust. That said, pcwalton has seemed even-keeled every time that I've seen him comment. I ask because I'm the moderator of the Rust subreddit, and I have a strict rule against bashing other languages there. Not even Rust devs are exempt, though thankfully this has never been a problem. I'd like to encourage a culture of respect, rather than letting us get bogged down in holy wars. The constant comparisons of Go and Rust that I see on HN and the like are quite dismaying in my eyes.
- pcwalton 12y agoI'd rather just drop this. I don't see any point in escalating the discussion when we're all on the same page regarding relations between the two projects. Sharing my thoughts on language design as it relates to other languages seems to be doing more harm than good, so I'll stop.