9 ms·
>One, that it is at all possible to pick a result (even if it was defined) like innovation in manufacturing and relate it back to policies which can be then imp
by pessimizer 12y ago
>One, that it is at all possible to pick a result (even if it was defined) like innovation in manufacturing and relate it back to policies which can be then implemented somewhere else to achieve the same result.
I must be reading this wrong, but it seems like you're denying the effects of policy on outcomes, and denying that similar policies tend to result in similar outcomes. That would be an argument against having policies altogether.
- Tuna-Fish 12y agoThe way I'm reading it, he's denying that policies are the only determining factor in outcomes. By his words, it's possible that they contribute to outcomes, but as they are not the sole determining factor, it's impossible to look at outcomes and assign them to the corresponding policies.
- afarrell 12y agoThat is also the way I'm reading it, with a dash more "these things are terrifyingly complex, so unless your article shows some real thoughtful work, it isn't worth much."
- jboy55 12y agoCan you find specific policies that produced a specific result, like innovation? Then, are those policies transferable to different cultural/political climates to produce the same result? If you stick to results like innovation, I think you'll be hard pressed to find the former, and its pretty much the latter. Look at hack days at companies. A really innovative company holds a really successful hack day. Are innovative companies doing hack days to drive their innovation? Or are hack days the result of other factors that drove innovation? Should leadership of a company with innovation stagnation hold hack days? Or, is that just following the cargo-cult antipattern?
- netcan 12y agoNo. I am not denying (or if we can cool back down to a friendlier tone^, disputing) the effect of policies on outcomes. But, they are one factor which can be substantial or not. I am disputing that (apart from some relatively uncommon cases) they are predictive or determining, especially if the thing we are trying to determine is what kind of effects on employment future innovations will have. The implication that one could take the best of an economy and expecting that this is achievable elsewhere by copying policies or a policy approach is nonsensical. Germany's industrial engineering is superb (as is California's software) and that is the result of a lot of history and organic development. Policy played a role, but probably a small one. Even if the role is bigger than I think, it is still a complicated role that was played by interacting with time and place sensitive uncopiable factors. California's software is part of an ecology (Universities, VCs, Angels) and it is part of a culture. You can't copy RMS & a history of hippies in Berkley. The extent to which 'innovation' they can be encouraged at all and how is fairly disputed. It's certainly harder than encouraging (for example) investment. Innovation is inherently unpredictable. Trying to direct the eventual impact of innovation "innovates in order to empower workers" is snake oil. And, I don't think it's even true that Germany's innovation has these characteristics. The whole article is layered nonsense from a Professor. grrrr ^My apologies. Reading back, I don't like the tone I wrote in.