3 ms·
Isn't a use of the word "technicality" in a legal context an indicator of bias? Are you saying that the precedent set is weak?
by rhizome 12y ago
Isn't a use of the word "technicality" in a legal context an indicator of bias? Are you saying that the precedent set is weak?
- wmf 12y agoWhat I'm saying is that trolls can easily work around these "crushing blows" and continue their trolling. What happens when Malibu has perfected their trolling technique? Will they actually start winning lawsuits?
- JoshTriplett 12y agoThat's exactly what it means. Most courts tend to make the narrowest possible ruling rather than setting broad precedent: if they can throw out a case on a technicality, they'll do that rather than rule on the merits of the case itself. When that doesn't happen, people start throwing around phrases like "activist judges". So, in the areas of copyright and patent trolls, it's nice to see victories, but it's nicer to see victories on the merits of the case rather than on the details a particular troll got wrong.
- rayiner 12y agoBut in this case, the procedural stuff is what makes AF is a troll, isn't it? What useful precedent would come out of getting to the merits?
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> But in this case, the procedural stuff is what makes AF is a troll, isn't it? Only in part. Sure, procedural stuff like hostile choices of venue and settlement-seeking behavior seems common to trolls, but there's also the more general environment that makes trolling possible: the general expectation that going to court is an expensive gamble and you might not even get your costs back. That's leaving aside the fundamental IP issues supporting patent trolling to begin with, but I don't expect to see a precedent on those anytime soon. > What useful precedent would come out of getting to the merits? Precdents that would completely change the expected outcome of taking a troll to court: universal expectation of covering attorney fees, criminal penalties for broad-scale carpet-bombing with just-less-than-court-cost settlements ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry_%28common_law%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry_%28common_law%29 ), and piercing the corporate veil on troll shell companies to stop them at the source.