5 ms·
This article ignores the fact that student visas are a ridiculously expensive way to recruit foreign talent. A PhD student costs $20-50k/year ($20k stipend, tr
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
This article ignores the fact that student visas are a ridiculously expensive way to recruit foreign talent.
A PhD student costs $20-50k/year ($20k stipend, training costs which vary by field, even private universities are heavily subsidized by the govt), so figure costs of $100-250k/student. If 50% of student visas become citizens, that's a cost of $200k-500k per new skilled citizen.
Visas for skilled workers are a much more cost effective way of recruiting high skill talent. Auctioning off citizenship/visas would also be more effective.
Student visas are nothing but a subsidy to the college industry.
- ardit33 17y agohuh? Foreign students have to pay tuition just as everybody else, even worse, they don't get 'in-state' breaks, or federal loans, or any other help american students get. All scholarships they get are merit based, (either academic, or sports), otherwise they will have to pay their own schooling.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoPhD students (the ones I was referring to) don't pay tuition and get stipends of about $20k/year. The real cost is about $30-50k/year. Even students who pay tuition are not paying the full cost of their education in most cases. College is highly subsidized and 'in-state' tuition breaks comprise only a portion of that subsidy. It's bad enough that we subsidize college. It's even more wasteful to funnel money to colleges as an alleged way to recruit high skill workers. It's simply not necessary; if we want high skill workers, all we need to do is pick a number and issue that many visas. We can probably even make it revenue positive by issuing visas by auction, rather than by queuing.
- artaak 17y ago"costs $20-50k/year" - pardon, but where did you learn it from? Even if PhD students get tuition waivers, the waivers are given along with Teaching or Research Assistant positions. In other words, the PhD students are paid for some assistance, they are not just given the money. And Teaching Assistance at the university (especially, public school) might not be so much fun as it might seem. Not surprisingly, the percentage of Americans in graduate science programs is small.