3 ms·
Not sure what your beef is, your quotes etc. exactly match what the Guardian wrote about S.W.: 1. He disagrees with Piketty's conclusion 2. He finds the FT's
by mpweiher 12y ago
Not sure what your beef is, your quotes etc. exactly match what the Guardian wrote about S.W.:
1. He disagrees with Piketty's conclusion
2. He finds the FT's criticisms insignificant wrt. Piketty's conclusion.
So: he also thinks Piketty is wrong, but not for the reasons the FT claims, and he thinks that what the FT claims is inconsequential to whether Piketty is wrong or right.
- QuantumChaos 12y agoReposting my reply to your other comment in this thread (feel free to continue discussion on either thread). According to Winship, Piketty's results are wrong/irrelevant for other, independent reasons. But not everyone shares this view, so Winship is clarifying that, for people who were initially convinced by Piketty's analysis, the FT criticism is important. But it is not important for Winship because even without the FT criticism, he has independent reasons to discounting Piketty's analysis. I hope this explains my "beef" with the use of Winship's quotes.