3 ms·
Piketty's numbers appear incorrect Er...some of his numbers appear incorrect. From this you incorrectly assume that this invalidates the conclusion. It may i
by mpweiher 12y ago
Piketty's numbers appear incorrect
Er...some of his numbers appear incorrect. From this you incorrectly assume that this invalidates the conclusion. It may invalidate the conclusion if the errors are significant. However, what little I've seen so far does not seem to be all that significant.
From the fine article:
'Scott Winship, an economist at the right-leaning Manhattan Institute for Policy Research, and notable critic of Piketty's analysis, said the FT's allegations weren't "significant for the fundamental question of whether Piketty's thesis is right or not".'
So there seem to be highly qualified sources that say that the differences are not significant. That's not the same as "he said/she said".
Do you have any evidence that the errors are significant?
You also blatantly mischaracterize Krugman's point: he showed that inequality in capital income is going up, not (just) general income. Capital income has this property that it usually derives from capital (as the name says). So unless there is evidence that the top 1% or so systematically get significantly better returns on the same capital, an increase in capital income let's us include that there is an increase in base capital from which to derive that income.
On the other side of the coin, income leads to wealth, and unless you have evidence that high-income people save less of their income than lower-income people, then wealth will diverge. All the evidence I have seen so far (and common sense) say that it is the other way around: consumption saturates, so people with higher incomes actually save more and spend less, at least in relative terms.
So both sides of this equation quite trivially show the link between income inequality (especially for, but not limited to capital income) that you deny.
So both the FT criticism (= nit-picking in non-substantive details) and your criticism are unfounded, as far as we can tell.
Again, if you have some actual substantive evidence that the errors are significant, I'd love to see it.
- QuantumChaos 12y agoOn Scott Winship, see one of my top level comments (I made two top level comments as I only started investigating this after I posted once). Whatever was printed in the article, he has said on Twitter that he does doubt Piketty's conclusions, and also that the FT allegations are significant.
- mpweiher 12y ago"...and also that the FT allegations are significant" (my emphasis). Original Tweet: "3/But UK--&, I now believe, US--methods need to be explained by #Piketty, else looks pretty bad. Just not CONSEQUENTIAL 4 overall thesis" (again, my emphasis) https://twitter.com/swinshi/status/470880036233699328 https://twitter.com/swinshi/status/470880036233699328 "are significant" vs "not CONSEQUENTIAL" seem like exact opposites to me. EDIT: missing parenthesis
- QuantumChaos 12y agoyou are misreading the context. According to Winship, Piketty's results are wrong/irrelevant for other, independent reasons. But not everyone shares this view, so Winship is clarifying that, for people who were initially convinced by Piketty's analysis, the FT criticism is important. But it is not important for Winship because even without the FT criticism, he has independent reasons to discounting Piketty's analysis.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoWhat the FT showed is that "It is no longer remotely close to clear that wealth inequality is going up...". This is because when they corrected Piketty's errors, and adopted different (but similarly plausible) weighting schemes, Piketty's major claim of inequality being "high, then low, then high" vanished in Europe. If by "significant" you mean something else, please say so. So unless there is evidence that the top 1% or so systematically get significantly better returns on the same capital, an increase in capital income let's us include that there is an increase in base capital from which to derive that income. You are simply wrong on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7795331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7795331 I'm not sure why you describe me as "blatantly mischaracterizeing" Krugman since I explicitly noted it was capital income. ...unless you have evidence that high-income people save less of their income than lower-income people, then wealth will diverge. Again, this is incorrect. They might achieve a lower rate of return (including being more vulnerable to large shocks).