4 ms·
In order for income inequality to not lead to wealth inequality, we need to believe that poor people save more of their income than wealthy people - which seems
by barrkel 12y ago
In order for income inequality to not lead to wealth inequality, we need to believe that poor people save more of their income than wealthy people - which seems rather difficult.
I think it is clear from other sources that wealth inequality is going up, and the FT is pushing its findings too far.
- bru 12y ago>In order for income inequality to not lead to wealth inequality, we need to believe that poor people save more of their income than wealthy people - which seems rather difficult. Yes, but that's actually what the FT refutes (center of 3rd § of the article): > The newspaper concluded there was little evidence in Piketty's original sources to bear out his theory that the richest were accumulating more wealth
- yummyfajitas 12y agoIn order for income inequality to not lead to wealth inequality, we need to believe that poor people save more of their income than wealthy people - which seems rather difficult. Or that wealthy people achieve diminishing returns on investment as their wealth grows. I.e., my startup might grow 10-fold, but Facebook is unlikely to. Even if you assume Piketty's "r > g" macro-level hypothesis, there are a lot of microeconomic theories completely compatible with it. Not all of them result in increasing inequality. http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/piketty_and_inequality.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/piketty_and_inequalit... (But now we are moving into the topic of Piketty's theoretical weaknesses, which are supposedly irrelevant because his data is so great.) I think it is clear from other sources... [citation needed] And if other sources prove this point, why was Piketty's book such a sensation?
- anon1385 12y ago>I.e., my startup might grow 10-fold, but Facebook is unlikely to. Yes, startups, an investment famous for attracting only small scale investors of small means…
- foobarqux 12y agoWhat is Piketty's theoretical weakness?
- praxeologist 12y agoSee this article, especially toward the end on his understanding of capital: https://mises.org/daily/6736/Thomas-Piketty-on-Inequality-and-Capital https://mises.org/daily/6736/Thomas-Piketty-on-Inequality-an...
- foobarqux 12y agoThe main criticism there is that the concept of return on capital is meaningless. I think that is fringe view and I don't find it compelling.
- praxeologist 12y ago>I think that is fringe view and I don't find it compelling. That's a vacuous non-argument and appeal to popular opinion. Not compelling as well.
- foobarqux 12y agoMany complex systems, hard to describe on a micro level, have straightforward macro statistics. I think return on capital can be described but such statistics even if individual investments are highly variable. Capturing the return is achieved by having a highly diversified portfolio.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoHis lack of a clearly stated theory. Ask yourself this question: in a few equations, what is his fundamental claim? What specific data (irrespective of technical details about collecting it) would prove or disprove his theory? The closest he comes to having a clearly stated theory is that "r > g => growth of inequality". That specific claim is completely wrong. http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/piketty_and_inequality.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/piketty_and_inequalit...