3 ms·
One strange possibility this may imply is that some people still untouched by the modern world are really not conscious and introspective. What a weird proposit
by noobermin 12y ago
One strange possibility this may imply is that some people still untouched by the modern world are really not conscious and introspective. What a weird proposition.
Also, those of us who do not share direct ancestry with modern cultures (I am a pacific islander), our cultures would possibly not have had consciousness until our contact with outsiders...for my culture, that would be around the late 1700s.
Our oral history does talk about gods, demigods and such. Looking back at most of the oral legends, they tend to be about the gods and mythical events that teach us morals. I think there was one story that might show introspection (a god child who was found in the woods and was raised by human parents) although something like true higher order thinking? I'm not sure, I'd have to think a bit.
Still, it's such an interesting idea. Perhaps that is one way to test the hypothesis, comparing notes with first contacts with indigenous, uncontacted peoples.
- mantrax5 12y agoI wish we'd stop confusing what we can prove with what is. Chances are not only all people are conscious and introspective, but most animals are to some degree (it's not an on/off switch, it's an emergent property, the sum of all your reasoning skills). As for bicameralism, it's just a demonstration of the lengths at which our wrong assumptions can reach when the subject we're creating conjecture about (ancient people) are no longer around, or otherwise unable to explain themselves. There are plenty of people in the modern day, which claim to have heard the voice of god (or the devil, or aliens, or what have you), which might be a mental disturbance, or quite often is a simple confusion (a dream taken for reality, and so on). It's just how the mind works to this present day. Sometimes we misinterpret input and make up reasons. Heck, the theory of bicameralism seems like an example of making up reasons.