9 ms·
I've seen lots of this brought up before as well. One things the ST shows really spend lots of time on is not exploring the society the show occurs in. And when
by bane 12y ago
I've seen lots of this brought up before as well. One things the ST shows really spend lots of time on is not exploring the society the show occurs in. And when it does it's internally inconsistent. Lots of questions are answered in the deep nerd lore about the universe, but you shouldn't need to buy canon reference books about some show to find out things like "replicators have trouble replicating heavier elements" so monetary instruments have to be produced out of non-replicable materials.
I think part of this is the need to have character driven stories. Which I'm basically fine with, but I really want to see more exploration of the universe the characters are in. Defining the rules of that universe helps establish the environment the characters have to operate in. With clever writing this can add extra flavor to the story.
This might be one of the reasons I like DS9 the best, they do a little bit of both, exploring the setting a bit (establishing internal and external politics, trade, war, alliances, factions, economics etc.) while having quite good character driven stories in this setting.
For example, the principle planet in the story, Bajor, needs to rebuild. The Federation offers to help by providing industrial replicators. There's an entire story about how the fairly few industrial replicators the Federation can provide drives a political story involving the remnants of the Bajoran freedom fighter/terrorists. It's not the best Sci-Fi ever written, but it's a pretty strong story and helps really define this corner of the universe with better granularity than 4 other series and better than a dozen moves did over hundreds of hours. Some questions are left unanswered, but you can make some assumptions like, why doesn't the Federation provide more replicators? Is there something about the technology that makes them hard to manufacture? Why can't replicators replicate other replicators? Perhaps there's some component that prevents that? etc.
It sets limits on the Federation's powers and logistics without using the typical plot device of introducing a more powerful alien or enemy or whatever.
Star Trek is Starfleet. There's such pitifully little information on the life of non-Starfleet folks...heck there's almost nothing produced on non-officers in Starfleet outside of Chief O'Brien. And he seems virtually indistinguishable from his officer colleagues except being a bit more badass than the normal space pajama wearing explorer.
Every once in a while the series touches on economics: transporter credits, or replicator limitations when buying a gift for a friend. But by and large it throws those glimpses away as soon as it shows them.
It's a huge missed opportunity for the shows; the life of civilians in the Federation. How do they get goods and services? What motivates them to work other than pure self-actualization. What about menial jobs? There's so much territory to explore, and it's never explored at all and instead we end up with more fan-service throw away romance episodes.