3 ms·
You said you wouldn't repeat yourself yet you can't seem to help it, eh? Let's say I choose to believe in the Great Pumpkin. I mean I really believe in him. I'
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
You said you wouldn't repeat yourself yet you can't seem to help it, eh?
Let's say I choose to believe in the Great Pumpkin. I mean I really believe in him. I've got the wall stickers, posters, the book of the great pumpkin -- everything. Now -- aside from your predilection for belittling people who don't live up to your intellectual expectations, do you think it's right for you to take over my FaceBook account and start a long diatribe about how the Great Pumpkin sucks?
Don't you see how that's worse than just being an asshole? You're taking over somebody's persona on the net and making them trash their own value system.
That's not civil conversation. That's not even mocking people you think are stupid. It's a whole other level of nastiness altogether.
- mquander 17y agoI think that the point is that believing in the Great Pumpkin that hard is inherently absurd, and if you're going to carry on shaping your life around your belief in it, you should understand that some other people will think it's absurd, and steel yourself for some ridicule. I think breaking into people's stuff to mock them is being a pretty big asshole, but I don't think it's worse than being an asshole.
- pyre 17y agoThe problem is that when people get into things that hard they tend to only 'stick to their own kind.' It's really easy to be sucked into things really hard like that when you're only around other people that believe in it that hard. Why do you think that most cults have compounds, and that in some cults you're not allowed to talk to outsiders?
- sho 17y ago"do you think it's right for you to take over my FaceBook account and start a long diatribe about how the Great Pumpkin sucks?" I can't believe I'm hearing this. Yes? Of course? I mean, I don't condone people hacking FB accounts, of course. But why do you think a belief as ridiculous as that deserves any protection whatsoever? I'm not really singling out Christianity, either. If someone hacked a known homophobe's Facebook account and posted photoshopped pictures of them sucking cock, or got into a racist's account and started talking about their black girlfriend, I'd applaud, and couldn't give a damn about "making them trash their own value system". And the funny thing is, if the opposite occurred and, say, a right wing nutcase hacked my FB account and could say whatever they wanted - they couldn't really do any damage, because my entire self-image isn't founded on maintaining some ridiculous social façade. It would be an embarrassing security lapse, possibly provoke some mild teasing from friends and family, and life would go on. ======= UPDATE: Man, I am a really bad debater. I'm coming across pro-vandalism and anti-peaceful-tolerance here. Despite my views on religion that's not what I wanted to say; my argumentative position is drifting towards the extreme to oppose Mr. Markham. If I were a better debater, I'd be able to resist that - we're well into "devil's advocate" territory for me by now. I do not condone these attacks. I wanted to make the point that I don't consider these attacks to be particularly hurtful or serious, and that anyone who is seriously upset "when somebody takes their identity and has them say things they never would" should lighten up. I got a little too far into "asshole mode" above too. I won't change it now but actually, I wouldn't support defacement of this Great Pumpkin believer's page. Why? Because my whole actable complaint against religion is that it's intolerant. I strongly oppose religious superstition, of course, but that's not a legitimate reason to take action against them. Simply being stupid is not evil, in and of itself. Intolerance, however, is the actable offence and that's what legitimises attacks upon religion. Now if the Followers of the Great Pumpkin had a political agenda against other segments of the worlds' population, that would be a casus belli. I would like to say, though, that if you hold beliefs that seem to make you a favourite "lulz target" then you should probably re-examine them.
- kaa2102 17y ago"I would like to say, though, that if you hold beliefs that seem to make you a favourite "lulz target" then you should probably re-examine them" The only way to not be a target is to believe in "nothing". He who stands for nothing will fall for anything. That's not a good way to live.
- sho 17y agoHm, I don't think so. For example, if someone strongly believe in freedom of speech, I can't see how that would be an easy target for the kind of mockery seen in today's pranks. The whole idea of (today's) "lulz" is to make people who are defensive about something react in a completely over the top manner. Rational people are rarely defensive and don't tend to overreact, so they are rarely targeted, and it would be a failure if they were. Hence, if you have a belief that tends to make you overreact defensively when teased about it, it is probably flawed. That was my point.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- uninverted 17y agoI agree, but at the last part: heliocentrism before it was cool.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoNice catch. We can agree that identity theft is bad, that identity theft that trashes somebody's reputation is worse. We can also agree to disagree on mocking people. As you pointed out, the entire problem with religion is that it is intolerant. Once you become intolerant yourself in opposition, you lose the basis for your argument. I'd like to see everybody re-examine their beliefs on a regular basis, no matter what they believe. In fact, it's the ones that don't do this that I worry about. BTW -- don't cut your debating skills short. I wrote three replies to you before I came up with the last one. All the others had me going over the deep end and taking positions that were far afield of what I wanted. Perhaps today you're just a lousy re-writer.
- shiranaihito 17y agoYou're taking over somebody's persona on the net and making them trash their own value system. Well, the victims still have their own value systems, I wouldn't say this stunt trashed it for anyone. But.. That's not civil conversation. That's not even mocking people you think are stupid. It's a whole other level of nastiness altogether. This I agree with completely. I feel sorry for religious people just as much as the next sensible guy, but what the 4chan people did is not funny, it's not commendable, it's just world-class douchebaggery.