10 ms·
Fitness Crazed
- quickpost 12y agoGoogle referral link (to avoid subscription block): https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0CCkQqQIwAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.nytimes.com%2F2014%2F05%2F25%2Fopinion%2Fsunday%2Ffitness-crazed.html%3Fhp%26rref%3Dopinion&ei=hkCCU4zGKMuPyASgr4KIBA&usg=AFQjCNEsc5r8nidRqZkjJroh9Tf0XS2Arw&bvm=bv.67720277,d.aWw https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&c...
- jds375 12y agoHere's a link to Starting Strength[1]. I highly recommend it for people looking to bulk, tone, and put on some real muscle. It did wonders for me and I'm sure it will for you too. I also recommend doing these powerlifting exercises (such as squats, bench, and deadlift) with a focus on FORM first instead of weight. It'll prevent you from getting injured and payoff when you start lifting real heavy weight. I highly recommend these videos to teach you powerlifting form[2][3][4]. Also, the nice people on r/fitness over at reddit won't mind giving you a form check if you post a video of you lifting. Seriously, start now. It'll change your life. [1] http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0982522738?pc_redir=1400896569&robot_redir=1 http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/0982522738?pc_redir=1400896569... [2] http://youtube.com/watch?v=2ME8gEN54Ao&feature=kp http://youtube.com/watch?v=2ME8gEN54Ao&feature=kp [3] http://youtube.com/watch?v=EHx1gYTA-Rw http://youtube.com/watch?v=EHx1gYTA-Rw [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xS2wLZSdeDg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xS2wLZSdeDg
- bretthopper 12y agoThere's also a great Starting Strength Wiki: http://startingstrength.wikia.com/wiki/Starting_Strength_Wiki http://startingstrength.wikia.com/wiki/Starting_Strength_Wik...
- cjf4 12y agoUnless your rail thin and a teenager, I'd avoid Rip's diet advice. It will undoubtedly get you fat. Lyle McDonald's bodyrecomposition.com is, as far as I'm concerned, the best nutrition resource on the internet. Lyle does a great job of taking clinical research and boiling it down to practical applications for people who train.
- avn2109 12y agoAgreed. Mark Rippetoe's diet will make you gain body fat. In his defense, he mentions this several times in the book, writing things approximately like, "People are in love with their visible abs. This diet will break your affair off."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jds375 12y agoThat's true. I really needed to bulk so it worked for me (gained 30 pounds in about half a year). That being said, for those looking to control weight and do something more manageable I would definitely recommend McDonald's guide.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoI also think the focus on squatting and dead lifting does not produce very aesthetic results for a lot of guys. Some people have twiggy legs and benefit from putting on some lower body mass. But a lot more guys who progress to intermediate squat and deadlift numbers wind up with over sized thighs and glutes and frankly it doesn't look good. Nor is it very "functional" outside of the lifts. That kind of bulk definitely slows you down on the court/track/field. People get caught up in stuff like the deadlift because you build up to what seem like big numbers. But the fact is, it's not very impressive. Most guys can get there. And it's not very useful, athletically speaking. I think Rippetoe's original schtick was built around bulking kids up for certain positions on high school football teams. Having an extra 20# to throw around at age 17 is going to really help a lineman. I'm a bit skeptical about the wider reverence the Rippetoe approach gets these days.
- zacharycohn 12y ago"the deadlift [...] is not very impressive, [...] and it's not very useful, athletically speaking." That is probably the most false statement I've ever read on the internet. Which is saying something. Athletically speaking, there is no single exercise better than the deadlift. With the squat coming in at #2.
- avn2109 12y agoMark Rippetoe changed my life. I second this recommendation. And I've only learned to squat and bench properly so far. Looking forward to (if you'll forgive the pun) picking up the other lifts.
- ldonley 12y agoAnother similar workout plan is Stronglifts 5x5[1]. I have never done starting strength but I am a fan of stronglifts and it has a free app that does wonders at the gym for tracking your progress. [1]http://stronglifts.com/ http://stronglifts.com/
- sliverstorm 12y agoI figure Stronglifts is more accessible because of the rows instead of powercleans (which are hard to do right), and as you as the app is great.
- jdbernard 12y agoSame here. Rippetoe's book was fantastic for me, especially in helping to to have good form, but the Starting Strength 5x5 was the workout that actually stuck with me. IMO they compliment each other extremely well.
- VLM 12y agoRippetoe's workout is not as simple as the article portrays "built around five old-fashioned lifts" and all that. The rumors people may have heard are true, he really does write sixty pages on how to squat properly without hurting yourself, and other exercises. The article also has a strong style over substance aspect wrt "photographs were so poorly shot". No they're actually pretty awesome if you're trying to learn how to do this safely. Its like complaining that an engineering blueprint of a perfect engine camshaft doesn't capture the fluffy marketing message of the car, well, yeah, that's kinda not the point... Its interesting how SS has taken over the field. I've been lifting on and off (mostly off) for about 30 years and will certainly start back up again sooner or later, and its interesting watching how the field has almost universally crystallized on SS for the noobs. In like, the 80s, there was a lot more variety and a lifter might start on machines or freeweights fairly randomly.
- SwellJoe 12y agoI have the same sort of, and similar length, history with weight training. I believe that's because it's pretty widely accepted now that free weights are more effective than machines. And, the difference is large enough that even people outside of weight lifting circles have a vague awareness of this. In the 80s, it was still really popular to use machines because they were "safer" (which is not necessarily true), they isolated specific muscles for training (mostly true, but not actually optimal), and they seemed easier than learning proper form for lifting free weights (it's still pretty easy to do it wrong with a machine). That said, my first exposure to weight training was via a Gold's Gym book that I got at a garage sale, which also focused solely on free weights. I think the gym rats have always known iron was superior to rubber bands and elaborate systems of ropes and pulleys.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y ago> it's pretty widely accepted now that free weights are more effective than machines. I don't buy that. The people who say that stuff are the same ones who go on about stabilizer muscles, when there's no such thing. Machines are safer than barbells. For overhead and pull-down stuff the good machines minimize dangerous shoulder stress. Barbell squats and deadlifts quite simply are somewhat dangerous and even very experienced people manage to tweak their backs.
- x0x0 12y agoI don't want to rain on anybody's parade, but before starting a serious deadlifting / squat / snatch / jerk routine, please please go to a trainer. You need instruction for correct form. The aforementioned exercises will work very well for you, but if performed incorrectly they can permanently injure your back. If money is a concern, there are often private trainers (I can give references in sf) not associated with a gym that are very affordable -- eg $65/hour in sf, much less expensive elsewhere. NB: a good trainer can, at minimum, perform those exercises for reps with more than bodyweight. Many gyms -- 24 hour fitness and crunch come to mind -- employ "trainers" who appear to hopefully have read a book but are wildly unprepared to train others in exercises that can destroy body parts if performed incorrectly.
- crazygringo 12y agoAs someone who started with Starting Strength about a year ago, and who goes to a gym in Manhattan with lots of trainers around... Nope. The book is far superior to any of the trainers I've encountered. The book has so much detail on each exercise, it will take you weeks to absorb it, but if you read relevant parts before/after each workout, to make sure you're doing everything right, you'll probably wind up with much better form and technique than a random trainer's personal opinions. And if you don't already know the correct form/technique, then how on earth are you going to evaluate which trainer you can trust? Answer: you can't. The book is the way to go, if you can be conscientious about reading it thoroughly, constantly reviewing it, and following what it says.
- x0x0 12y agoAs someone who started lifting a year ago: you don't know what you're talking about, but don't let that stop you from giving others advice that could hurt them. For the rest of people interested in getting strong: get a competent trainer (one easy evaluation metric is, as I mentioned, their deadlift maxes; greater than 500 pounds makes avoiding injury w/o good form very unlikely; or participation in powerlifting events; etc).
- grannyg00se 12y ago
- JAFTEM 12y agoI have many friends that in the past wanted to get more fit and healthy and they've always felt the need to do a lot of research or look for some sort of crazy program that they think is necessary to shed off the weight or gain muscle. I always try to just push them in the direction of starting out with the "big four" that this article mentioned: the bench press, the squat, the dead lift, and the clean and press. All you need to do is look for videos online that demonstrate the motion and proper form and try to mimic this with a light weight [1]. As your form gets better, you can naturally add more weight. From there as you gain more experience, you can start working on exercises that isolate different body parts and of course incorporating cardio. In my humble opinion, it's best to just jump right in, create a routine, and start learning from experience. Refer back to videos online for proper form in trying new exercises, and from first-hand experience you will see what works and what doesn't. [1] http://www.bodybuilding.com/exercises/ http://www.bodybuilding.com/exercises/
- Someone 12y ago"wanted to get more fit and healthy [...] to shed off the weight or gain muscle" Those are two, three, maybe four different things. The typical marathon runner, for instance, is fit, not fat, but also not muscular, and may or may not be healthy; a sumo wrestler is surprisingly fit and muscular, but also fat, and a body builder is muscular, but need not even be strong (world champion weight lifters look quite different from body builders) The optimal training program depends on what you want to achieve. That's also what this NY Times reporter seems to be confused about. Training programs focussing on getting fit (especially those focusing on endurance fitness) may have a side effect of looking better in the mirror, but if that is your goal, there are better/faster ways to get there.
- dublinben 12y agoI'm aware of the differences between "functional" muscle and otherwise, but you can't be an elite level bodybuilder without being strong. Ronnie Coleman (8x Mr Olympia) is stronger than more than 99% of the human race.
- cjf4 12y agoKind of surprising that this article didn't use the word "periodization", because that's really what it's advocating.
- nasmorn 12y agoNo he describing a training void of periodization. He does the same routine for a year just increasing weight. In a per iodized regime he would maybe start with low weight high reps then move to 8-12 reps the doing maximum strength training with 5 reps. This is usually only necessary if you start plateauing on your current regime.
- enraged_camel 12y agoStarting Strength works because it's easy to understand, follow, and see results from. By far the primary challenge newer folks face is establishing the discipline and consistency, and that's a lot easier to do when you're motivated by increasing the weight on the bar regularly. My favorite quote from the book is from the very first page (which is probably very relevant to the HN crowd): A weak man is not as happy as that same man would be if he were strong. This reality is offensive to some people who would like the intellectual or the spiritual to take precedence. It is instructive to see what happens to these people as their squat strength goes up.
- Technophobe 12y agoI'm much happier since I've stopped lifting. I did Starting Strength until I could squat 1.5x my body weight, but I never enjoyed going to the gym, and realized I didn't really care much for the muscle I put on. If anything, it was annoying having such big thighs. I haven't been to the gym for a couple of years now and couldn't be happier. I do quite a bit of cardio (competitive table tennis), and that's it.
- enraged_camel 12y agoThank you for the bug report. We'll make sure to fix you in the next version. ;)
- tormeh 12y agoDefinitely. In my opinion, you shouldn't do something you don't like, and I don't like going to gyms, so after multiple years I've now quit and it feels pretty good. I think it's important to find another sport you like though. Now I do climbing and experiment with other things. Much more enjoyable than grinding three days a week.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- arasmussen 12y agoLifting is something I'm pretty passionate about. I go 5 days a week and don't follow any specific program, just do my own thing. Honestly, if you're in the gym 5 days a week, you're going to see results. Plain and simple, no matter what you're doing. I've always felt the programs were basically saying "do these things in the gym this much then you'll see these results" and it's like yeah I can do almost anything in the gym for that amount of time and I'll see those results... I feel like supplements are similar to personal trainers in terms of that "client confusion". I've taken a lot of different supplements and doing research online versus talking to someone at GNC will return offensively differing results in what you should take for which reasons.
- gonzo 12y agoyou might consider dropping a day. 2 on / 1 off / 2 on / 2 off I found that 5x/week led to an overtrained state.
- mewks 12y agoIt strongly depends on the person. If you get enough sleep and you have high testosterone, you can pretty much train every day. Your advice does hold true for most of the population though.
- dylanz 12y agoI've been following Wendlers 5/3/1 for the last 3 months, and have noticed a ton of improvement. My personal goal is to get strong and not big. The foundation of 5/3/1 is to improve strength, and there are supplemental routines to get big, get lean, etc etc. So far so good! Would love to hear others opinions if they've tried 5/3/1.
- jds375 12y agoRight now I'm doing 5/3/1. It works great once your linear gains start to fade. That being said, I feel beginners should do more of a starting strength or strong lifts program since there is so much room for growth and high reps help develope good form.
- dylanz 12y agoGreat feedback, and that's what I've read other places as well. I started 5/3/1 with absolutely no background or experience in lifting, but I've spent a lot of time focusing on making sure my form is good. That said, you "do" start pushing a lot of weight pretty quickly once you calculate your 1RM. I do admit it was a bit intense at first, but I've actually really liked the process. I really like Week 4 and how it makes you take it easy (finally get a bit of a rest!), and the slow addition of weight to your monthly iterations.
- michokest 12y agoMy story with fitness echoes this post closely. Gyms have long had the motivation to push the latest machines or fitness fads, because that's how they retain customers with the promise of a new program that'll change everything. After a ton of research, the only thing that worked for me was bodyweight workouts and barbell training. To drop my weight I followed bodyweight programs at home. 20 minute short sessions with squats, push ups, etc. Far more challenging than it sounds! You can see pics of how I dropped 20 lbs in this post: http://micho.biz/post/74209049445/leaving-teambox-back-to-square-one http://micho.biz/post/74209049445/leaving-teambox-back-to-sq... Then I jumped onto barbell training, complemented with bodyweight sessions. Starting Strength has been the best resource I've followed so far. For a small time investment a week, I've been progressing in technique and strength steadily over the last months. The fitness field has been a huge motivation personally for me, which ultimately made me leave my previous startup and found http://8fit.com http://8fit.com to help people like me follow that learning path.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoI've done a lot of olympic lift training over the years and am competent at it. I am very much pro machine. The modern machines are excellent at preventing injury while providing an ideal strength training movement. The barbell stuff is these days fetishized for no good reason. People get hurt using barbells all the time. It is easy to mess up and tweak something and then be a bit injured for a few weeks, even if you know what you're doing. It is much harder to mess up with the good machines. The barbell doesn't have any special advantages. In fact, loading up the plates is a nuisance.
- wbhart 12y agoI found that strength training really pushes your nervous system hard. The training worked ok, and I could lift 220kg at the end. But I also developed anxiety issues. Nowadays I do much higher repetitions at lower weight, pushing muscle endurance much more, not one repetition maximum lifts which increase the load on your nervous system. I also, without fail, include 30 minutes of cardio in every session. This appears to be critical if you are like me and prone to anxiety attacks. I'm still progressively overloading, but if I can't do 3-5 sets of 20 repetitions at a given weight, I don't do it at all. And I've seen others in my gym who have unbelievable physiques doing the same. So it does work, so long as you keep increasing the weight as your body adapts.
- gonzo 12y agoRip is great. I even got him to admit that a valsava isn't recommended for me. (ascending aortic dissection survivor, and yes, I lift.)
- logn 12y agoA related article (2010) "Everything you know about fitness is a lie" -- http://www.mensjournal.com/magazine/print-view/everything-you-know-about-fitness-is-a-lie-20120504 http://www.mensjournal.com/magazine/print-view/everything-yo...
- hackaflocka 12y agoEveryone is different. No two people respond the same to the same exercise. No two people respond the same to the same diet. Period.
- Swizec 12y agoFinally a fitness article that says "Just do it". There really isn't a silver bullet to this stuff. If you keep working out, you will become stronger and eventually if you also eat reasonably well you will start looking better as well. It's as simple as that. No miracles required, just a bit of patience. Personally the solution I've found works best for me follows two simple rules: 1. Never be hungry and never be stuffed. 2. Do a simple 15 minute bodyweight routine 3 to 4 times a day. Do nothing every 4th day. When conditions are right (I'm living in Ljubljana) I will also add boxing training 3 to 5 times a week and I've been running every day lately because I can't do boxing. It works really well. I look bloody amazing naked. edit: The only problem I have with this much working out is that when I can't do boxing for an extended period of time I have too much energy and become edgy. Like, things just make me angrier than they should and I have trouble sitting still. The running helps, but isn't quite strenuous enough. edit2: The BEST part of working out this much is all the food you get to eat. And with much greater delight than if you're not working out.
- jqm 12y ago"I look bloody amazing naked." I'm afraid we are going to need to see some pictures to verify that.... (kidding, please don't post pictures:) Seconded on edgy when not enough exercise. The same thing happens to me. I notice this goes away if I ignore it and just don't exercise for a long time though. But then I don't feel as good and start having a much more negative attitude on life.
- ramblerman 12y agoCould you elaborate on your 15 minute bodyweight routines? Would it be mostly interval type stuff like (1 minute burpees, 10 second break, 1 minute pushups) etc.. ? or what do you do? I'm only asking out of scientific curiosity to "looking bloody amazing naked" of course ;)
- Swizec 12y agoI'm too lazy for interval and interval only works if you have someone else doing the timing. I've tried doing it on my own but it doesn't work well because of fiddling with the timer. I started with this: http://imgur.com/gallery/v49W4 http://imgur.com/gallery/v49W4 Now I just continue with the same -> 100 pushups (4 different types), 130 situps, 200 crunches (4 different types), then either 100 side-to-side, 70 leg-lifts, or an alphabet (spelling out the alphabet with extended legs), 2 minute plank (2 different types), and 60 squats. If I am pressed for time I can squeeze that into some 13 minutes. If I don't stop chatting on whatsapp/skype/fb it takes about 20 to 25.
- Shivetya 12y agothe nice thing about fitness is you need no tools more than your own body, though shoes do help. Really. Only your body and the space to use it.
- ahmett 12y agoI do not have a NYTimes subscription, please consider not posting from this website.
- asselinpaul 12y agoUse Incognito mode to read the Articles (on Chrome).
- tormeh 12y agoSet your cookies settings to not block but delete on exit all cookies from NYT.
- jqm 12y agoThe fitness regime I got more out of than anything else has been interval training. I worked out with weights for years and occasionally would do some cardio. I think the logic was... cardio doesn't make you look good in a swimsuit like lifting weights does, and at the time impressing ladies and intimidating other guys was priority (lets don't lie to ourselves about motive here!). Then, I got a little older and impressing ladies became less important and general health and a sense of well being more important. I read an article that made me realize many of the same principals of weight training can be applied to inner muscles as well. A knowledgeable person wouldn't go to the gym and lift 5 pound 300 times and expect to get stronger. Instead they would lift 80% of what they could 5 times in sets. This is what builds strength. The same principal applies to interval training for heart and lungs. Rather than getting on a treadmill for 45 minutes at a slow slog you push yourself to a percent of max heart rate for like 3 minutes in sets (the same as weight training). The workouts don't take that long and I found they greatly improved my feeling of health and general vigor. There are a number of studies on the benefits of improved heart stroke volume etc. from interval training which I can't find at the moment.
- Dewie 12y agoHIIT is a good form of interval training for people who want to do cardio but are also afraid that cardio will detract from their "look good in a swimsuit"-look. > , and at the time impressing ladies and intimidating other guys was priority (lets don't lie to ourselves about motive here!). Let's not project, either.
- jqm 12y ago"Let's not project, either." hehehe Well, I was just speaking from what I remember as a 20 something... I doubt I'm unique in this regard but probably it doesn't apply to everyone.
- Spearchucker 12y ago14 years ago I snowboarded off a cliff into the top of a pine tree, and pulled my arm from its socket. In 2009 I fell ~20ft into the sea whilst kitesurfing, badly dislocating the same shoulder. It resulted in a pretty crazy shoulder operation that needed a lot of work to get back range of motion and strength. I started with physiotherapy and once the range of motion was back I slowly moved onto weights (using Starting Strength). It went well, but I can't claim to have loved it like I do snowboarding. A friend suggested going to a Krav Maga[1] class he attends. I haven't looked back since, and do between 2 and three sessions a week. I dropped the weights and Rip's diet advice, and went back to eating like I always do (pretty healthy, good mix of red meat and pasta and potatoes, vegetables). I've put on weight (always been slim), strength is back to what it was, and I've not been this fit since I was conscripted in 1988. Whilst I'm sure weights would do more for how I look (secondary for me, I've always been good with girls anyway), Krav Maga does more for how I feel. I guess there's no silver bullet that works for everybody. You try a few things on, and keep what suits. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krav_Maga http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krav_Maga, and https://www.wittenburg.co.uk/Entry.aspx?id=ce9c6cf4-6b3e-4194-8739-ad9165e37d26 https://www.wittenburg.co.uk/Entry.aspx?id=ce9c6cf4-6b3e-419...
- socrates1998 12y agoI agree that you don't need any new fancy techniques and equipment to get in shape. However, doing the same week every week just isn't very fun. Most of the problem with being and staying in shape is the lack of interest in it. The author enjoyed weightlifting because he had never done it before and he saw himself getting stronger, which is very fun the first time you do it. The most important part of a fitness program is interest and motivation. A close second should be safety, but generally you can get into decent shape doing almost any sport or activity. For me, this article's fitness program, Starting Strength, sounds insanely boring, but that is because I have been doing these lifts off and on since I was 15 years old. And I did them a lot in college for football, so, it no longer appeals to me. I say, find something that is interesting to you and do that thing. It can be yoga, martial arts, soccer, basketball, walking, whatever, as long as you really enjoy it you will do it hard enough to get in shape and improve your health.
- zacharycohn 12y agoIt is called STARTING strength for a reason. :) In my experience (which is not universal), the workouts aren't boring though. Running on an eliptical for an hour is boring. Getting into the gym, warming up, doing my workout, cooling down, taking a shower, changing my clothes, and walking out of the gym in 45 minutes isn't boring - it's awesome.
- socrates1998 12y agoI am glad that you found something you enjoy that keeps you in shape. But, boring is very subjective and I think weightlifting is boring because I did it for so long and I have done all I can do with it. My point isn't that this particular program is boring or not, I just think interest trumps content in regards to fitness. So, if you like it, then do it.
- makeset 12y agoYou might not realize this if you have never trained for strength, but strength is very obviously measurable, especially with barbells, and when you get that feedback often enough with a program like this, it quickly becomes addictive. You know how many reps you got with what weight the last time, you shoot for one more rep or 5 lbs. heavier, and you get it! And you know you didn't have it a week ago. You just got stronger! So you start chasing your own progress in that "boring" lift, and it becomes far more exhilarating than any wobbleboard kettlebell juggle variation-of-the-day a personal trainer pulled out of her ass.
- marincounty 12y agoI walk/run every night in order to feel better mentally. I wish I didn't need too, but without exercise everyday I don't feel well mentally. It's been the Only medicine that has ever worked on my brain. My body still looks like chit, but I don't care anymore.
- hollerith 12y agoYour blood cortisol levels might be too high. Contact info in my profile if you want to hear more.
- egypturnash 12y agoMy fitness regime: Dance class a couple times a week. Yoga a couple times a week as well. Live in a city I can walk around, don't have a car. Right now the dance is pole dance. Which you will probably laugh at - but think how much strength and flexibility you need to climb up a pole, invert yourself, and do splits while slowly twirling back down to the ground. And yeah, just keep doing the same thing on a regular basis. I have a chin-up bar in my bathroom door. Almost every time I pass that way, I try a few times. I've gone from "can't get off to the ground" to "can easily lift and lower myself". Now I'm trying to work on more reps.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoI have trouble understanding the basis for articles like these. As far as it goes, asking which exercises might provide the best real-world gains is a sensible question, but the question of why a 40 yr old man wants to be able to push 235 lbs away from his chest when lying reclined is never even asked. Does he know why he wants this? From a biological perspective, a specimen might want to be able to do this to signal to potential mates that he is worthy of reproduction (the reason why we do alot of the things we do that no one ever quite explains). But at age 40, this is a suspect answer... without knowing any details of his personal life it seems unlikely that he's finally looking to settle down and start a family. Besides, if he is a late bloomer, the success of his career and his paycheck matter much more than body fat percentage. A male's ability to provide benefit to a female just doesn't lean much towards the "fighting off sabertooth tigers" anymore, nor even in the western world towards "fighting off other males". I'm continually surprised how much time, effort, and money people will waste on these activities that seem devised to attract mates when they want few or no children, when they already have mates, and at times even when they have mates superior to any they're likely to acquire in the future. It's almost as if even as the desire to reproduce erodes, their desire to attract reproductive mates increases.
- mqsoh 12y agoI started Starting Strength because I didn't want to be sedentary anymore. I thought I would maintain my weights after a few months, but I soon realized that it feels good to move weight and then more weight. The satisfying part is the challenge. You should try and get a 150lb bench press and then see if you would want a 200lb bench press and then a 235lb bench press. You might be a "male specimen" that sees no logic to strength, but neither should you be dismissive of people that like to be strong. (Some are women, by the way.)
- morgante 12y agoSeconded. I genuinely don't understand the (seemingly recent) obsession with "getting big." There are very strong reasons for wanting to lose weight and get fit, based on health reasons. I see absolutely no reason for a person working at a desk job to develop massive muscles which are literally only used in the gym.
- schmoofer 12y agoI've done Strong Lifts before in the past before and had good results (mainly with legs, squats went from just the bar to 225 lbs in 3 months), and I've tracked it all in a spreadsheet. I've always thought it would be a good idea if we can all publicly aggregate our tracked progress (for just squats, benchpress, deadlift, etc.) and see a collective chart of it so we can visualize how we compare to the average (and if we're doing something wrong). Of course, different body types and diets are factors, so filters may be applied (i.e. mesomorph body type, >3000 calories, etc.). Would anybody be interested in using something like that, in mobile/browser form?
- KyleBrandt 12y agoThe first few chapters Rippetoe's "Practical Programming for Strength Training" explain a lot of the theory behind strength training. One of the first things it does it clarify the difference between exercise vs training. Exercise is just "working out", whereas "training" is a long term plan to improve certain aspects of the body's ability. Unless you are specific about what your goals of changing your body and your body's abilities are, then it will be hard to get "results" since "results" is not well defined. Some example results: * Get bigger chest and arm muscles * Be able to run long distances * Be able to perform certain feats of strength: Lift heavy things, do certain gymnastics poses * Have certain muscles or muscle groups be defined * Any sport specific activity: climbing, rowing, golf, basketball, etc Muscle composition and neurological response develop differently to different training. Endurance, balance, speed, range of motion, and lifting heaving things are all different. And you can develop those abilities in different muscles and movements. Applying this context to any fitness article I read has clarified a lot for me.
- smegel 12y ago> outdated barbell movements I stopped reading about here.
- fhars 12y agoThen your reading comprehension is probably lacking. You do realize that the article is a strong defence of classical barbell excercises?
- smegel 12y agoDefence from what? His own faulty preconceptions?
- zacharycohn 12y agoSociety's faulty preconceptions, yes.
- jwallaceparker 12y agoThis new workout book from Joe Manganiello (actor from True Blood) is pretty incredible. http://www.amazon.com/Evolution-Cutting-Breaking-Mental-Building/dp/1476716706/ http://www.amazon.com/Evolution-Cutting-Breaking-Mental-Buil... He details the workout he used to transform his body for his role of Alcide (a werewolf) on True Blood. There are also a few chapters dedicated to motivation and mental approach. They're well-written and he doesn't pull any punches. Highly recommended.
- davidcbc 12y agoGood article, however the author overlooks the most important factor of any "exercise", "training", "diet", "strength/size building" program. Diet. Starting Strength is a great strength program, however if you are eating garbage you are still going to look like garbage. Someone doing a fad exercise routine and eating right is going to have better results than someone doing an optimal training routine with a poor diet.
- yodsanklai 12y agoTo each his own but I find it easier to get fit as a side effect from practicing a "regular" sport, like swimming, climbing, running, boxing etc... I feel it's less artificial and much more entertaining. However, not many sports can give you those huge muscles people get from a proper strength training with high protein diet.
- thisrod 12y agoI agree with that in principle. The problem is that you have to do those sports a lot in order to stay fit, and people start companies, write books and do other things that leave them with too little time for it. Climbing over a lifetime beats weightlifting, but weightlifting beats sitting in a chair for two years. Also, olympic lifting might look like brute force, but it's actually as tricky and interesting as swimming or gymnastics.
- davycro 12y agoI followed the Starting Strength regime for about 7 months and had great results where I added about 15 lbs of muscle to my frame. Its a fantastic method for building a foundation of strength and muscle. My biggest complaint during the process was that it was difficult to track my progress. To my surprise none of the iPhone applications out there were very good for tracking lifts and I ended up tracking with the Notes application. Recently, I stumbled upon the StrongLifts app, which is tailored for a different lifting regime, but one that is somewhat similar to Starting Strength. StrongLifts is executed perfectly, in my opinion. If I wasn't in school, I'd try and build a StrongLifts clone retooled for Starting Strength. I think there would be a huge market for that app. I would like to see an iPhone application that tracks your progress in the Starting Strength routine. The app StrongLifts would be a great starting place. StrongLifts has a fitness regime that is similar to Starting Strength, and is executed beautifully. I love the idea of combining a fitness program with a smartphone application.
- zacharycohn 12y agoSince this article didn't elaborate on Rip's suggested diet, and I haven't seen another post here that did... here it is: ff GOMAD, or Gallon Of Milk A Day, is the diet that commonly is combined with Starting Strength (SS). The general idea is that, in addition to eating a lot of food, you drink a gallon of milk a day. It is not for the protein in the milk. It is not for the added calcium. It is a straight up calorie per dollar play. A gallon of whole milk is 2400 calories, and costs about $3. It's basically the best dollar to calorie ratio that exists at the grocery store. Why do you need the extra 2400 calories? For recovery. SS operates on a linear progression. Every other day, you lift a few more pounds than you did the day before. In order to achieve that (safely, and sustainably), you need to be fully recovered by your next workout. There are many aspects to recovery, but the primary bottleneck is fuel. Which is calories. So the rationale behind GOMAD is to remove the bottleneck. Give the body more fuel than it could possibly use in a day to spend on recovery. If your typical diet is 3000 calories from food (not unusual when on an aggressive exercise plan), GOMAD will up that to 5400. The exact upper bound on calories your body can actually burn in a day on recovery is variable - depends on the person, the day, the workout, etc etc etc. But the usage ceiling is definitely lower than 5400 calories. So we give the body more fuel than it could POSSIBLY burn, to give it the ability to recover as much as it is humanly possible between workouts. You do have to do something with those extra calories. It DOES turn into fat. You do gain a little fat when doing SS+GOMAD. But you have to chose one - lose weight or build muscle. It’s incredibly difficult to do both, while also demanding gains in a reasonable amount of time. So typically once someone finishes a SS cycle, they switch to IF (Intermittent Fasting) or something to cut the extra weight. Then you end up much stronger, and leaner. Hope that was helpful in clearing up the GOMAD diet, and the rationale behind it.
- _august 12y agoWhen I started my research, I did eventually land on Starting Strength, however I lacked access to a proper gym. Eventually I started looking into bodyweight fitness. I found some routines online and and created an interactive version with videos [1] so I could make it easier to get started. If you're looking to get started at home and don't have barbells accessible, I highly recommend bodyweight fitness. It's working well for me, and it's actually quite fun. As an added benefit, you gain new skills with your body (such as handstands). [1] https://fitloop.co https://fitloop.co