4 ms·
My prices can be whatever I want, I can price them under or over the market as I wish. I might not stay in business, but there are valid reasons for doing eithe
by bane 12y ago
My prices can be whatever I want, I can price them under or over the market as I wish. I might not stay in business, but there are valid reasons for doing either.
For example, I want to beat my competitor. So why I don't I dump diamonds on the market at some ridiculous price and eliminate De Beers virtually overnight? Once I've cornered the market and have a monopoly, I can start to jack up the price again saying whatever I feel like (there's a new diamond shortage) and charge whatever people are willing to pay, which would hopefully be eventually close to what the market was paying before or even higher.
Or I might sell my diamonds at a price higher than De Beers and make some marketing claim that my Diamonds are only of the highest and rarest quality for <insert reason> and if I do a good job and am lucky get people to move up to my price. Or I might certify my Diamonds with a 100% money back guarantee within 1 year of purchase or some nonsense (betting that most people won't sell back their Diamonds that soon after purchase, but using that guarantee to justify the higher price) or whatever.
I can keep my prices at De Beers' high price or do whatever I want. The Market merely informs me of what will sell, defining the envelope of how I can manage my business to stay in business.
- acchow 12y agoA challenger can't undercut an incumbent and drive them out of business. Who would finance such a move? And why wouldn't that financier back the incumbent instead? In reality, it's this opposite case that occurs. This practice is generally considered anti-competitive and illegal.
- bane 12y agoIt's done all the time, and it's on the front page of HN probably multiple times per week.
- bluedevil2k 12y agoIt's done by companies with small barriers to entry - if you wanted to be a startup in the rough diamond world, you'd need billions of dollars in start up capital, and access to a mine that's producing diamonds, which aren't just lying around. Figure billions more to buy a mine. Even then, you might get 3% market share, not enough to meet demand or alter prices in any way.
- bane 12y ago> you'd need billions of dollars in start up capital Two more points: a) Considering a chat app pulled in billions of capital, it's not like there isn't billions of capital available. Now that I have such capital in hand, it sounds like I'm pretty well situated to make this a practical idea. b) Why mine? Why not just grow? The diamonds are of better quality. Why can't I be the SpaceX of diamonds, start from first principles and build my own diamond growing tools, start mass producing 1-2 carat diamonds and dump them on the market. Set up regional diamond growing facilities each turning out thousands of diamonds a day, 24 hours a day. They'll be virtually indistinguishable from data centers, just huge warehouse like buildings next to readily available power substations. Since I have billions of startup capital, this is pretty feasible. Not only will I be mass producing diamonds, I'll be mass producing the diamond growing equipment, driving my per unit price down significantly. Better yet, my diamonds will be of a higher quality than anything De Beers can dig out of the ground.
- jljljl 12y agoA chat app was acquired for billions of dollars, but as far as I can see they only raised ~$58M in capital. http://www.crunchbase.com/organization/whatsapp http://www.crunchbase.com/organization/whatsapp EDIT: number was slightly off
- bane 12y agoAnd now the investors have billions of dollars. There's also plenty of companies outside of the internet app space that raise staggering amounts of money comparatively. Mining is no different. Unless I'm independently wealthy, I'll likely need investors to execute on just about any business idea. Ultimately any real goods business requires capital to get off the ground. I'm not going to just start digging a hole in my garage and bootstrap a diamond mine that will disrupt De Beers. Are you just being purposely obtuse?
- jljljl 12y agoThere is really no need for the rudeness. I don't really see how your first point follows at all. The capital required to fund the first 1.5 years of WhatsApp's existence was a mere 250K. Getting it to a $14B company took only $58M in outside investment. Do you really think investing in a diamond mining company would resemble that profile at all? If you really can't see the difference between the investment risk in a mining operation to challenge a 90% marketshare conglomerate, vs an investment risk in a 50 person internet startup, I don't think there's a point in debating any further.
- jljljl 12y agoTo have the supply and resources to do this would take years. You can't just code up a diamond business overnight. Since the fixed costs and barriers to entry are so high, you would take on a ton of debt or issue shares just to get to this point. Your creditors and investors would demand that you start turning a profit. So you would have to sell at market price or higher. Then you need to look at other barriers to dumping your product: Do any of the buyers have contracts with DeBeers that lock them in for the near term? Are there legal restrictions or trade agreements to prohibit you from dumping? Does DeBeers offer additional services or terms that keep merchants locked in beyond the price? etc... Then, of course, you need to sustain the low prices long enough to drive DeBeers out of business, all while assuming DeBeers doesn't just match your prices and drive you out first. Things like this are not done on the front page of HN very often, if ever.
- bane 12y agoI don't even have to sell them below my cost, assuming De Beers sells at a highly inflated price, I can just sell somewhere in between. Pricing myself into the market doesn't mean I have to lose money. It just means I have to undercut my competitors. There's lots of reasons not to do this but I'm starting to think that there's a lot of people on HN who don't know how pricing strategies work.
- jljljl 12y agoThe point is that there are significant barriers that prevent someone from just coming in and executing a "undercut the leader" pricing strategy. Especially if you are trying to "eliminate De Beers overnight", like you said in your previous post.
- bane 12y agoThere's a barrier to entry in just about everything. If I wanted to start an electric car company, or a rocket ship business I'd be facing the same. Overcome that barrier to execute on your chosen business strategy is how the world works. If you can't overcome the barrier then you can't execute. Simple as that. Either you can raise capital and build up an inventory of diamonds or not. This isn't rocket surgery.