3 ms·
There is some history of countries, especially China, trying to reverse engineer airplanes. It isn't easy in practice, and not just secrets like the stealth pai
by Zigurd 12y ago
There is some history of countries, especially China, trying to reverse engineer airplanes. It isn't easy in practice, and not just secrets like the stealth paint. Iran's industry probably can't manufacture an RQ-170.
That said, it's pretty tragic to lose a modern drone intact. There is a lot to be learned even if the learning can't be directly translated into a clone.
- trhway 12y ago>Iran's industry probably can't manufacture an RQ-170 ... >There is a lot to be learned even if the learning can't be directly translated into a clone. yes, it isn't only about cloning. It reminds me about the MiG-25 flown to Japan from USSR. US didn't clone it, yet it was a huge win for US and a big loss for USSR.
- dsl 12y agoWe didn't "clone" it, but did reverse engineer it to the extent that we could manufacture a reliable supply of replacement parts and spares for the 4477th Test and Evaluation squadron.
- beloch 12y agoChina is actually doing pretty good. Not too long ago photos were leaked of China's F-35 clone. Interestingly enough, they dropped the V/STOL fan and slimmed down the fuselage. The result is a copy that will likely out-perform the original in the majority of applications. Yes, the Chinese copy has no V/STOL capability, but neither do the majority of F-35's. The non-V/STOL F-35's retain the fat, slow fuselage of the the V/STOL versions, ostensibly for interchangeability of parts, even though the percentage of parts that are actually interchangeable keeps going down further and further.
- lloeki 12y ago> the percentage of parts that are actually interchangeable keeps going down further and further It's sad to see so much people at every scale and in every field buy on OSFA / WORA when it's been empirically demonstrated so many times that it just doesn't work. This is why I'm sad to see the A10 decommissioned: it's a testament to Unix'y "do one thing and do it well, and possibly be so awesome that it may cover a few more unexpected bases along the way".