6 ms·
Don’t follow your dreams: A commencement speech for the mediocre
- eabraham 12y agoWhenever I read articles like this I am surprised how people without a technical background balance work and fulfillment. I am so happy that I can find a developer position where I can be involved with such creative, fulfilling work and not have to compromise for money. I'm amazed and humbled by pieces like this and acknowledge the difficulty non-developers face when building a career and life.
- acqq 12y agoHave you ever tried to speak to people who aren't software developers? For them, if you're a software developer, you're just a boring guy spending all his wake time doing the most boring thing imaginable, sitting in front of the computer, looking at the screen, typing something completely and utterly uninteresting. If they imagine doing this for their whole life, they'd say "I'd rather die." And they certainly don't see any trace of possibility of what they consider "creativity" in your job (my other comment here elaborates this claim). (I work as a software developer myself, but I'm also aware of my biased view of the world. And I've spent enough years doing that that I'm also at the point of "I'd rather do something else... maybe becoming a lion tamer" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMOmB1q8W4Y http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMOmB1q8W4Y)
- lukasm 12y agoFor those who have wrong mental model based on excel or something similar.
- acqq 12y agoBut I can be extremely creative in Excel! It can be programmed from the inside and from the outside in more complex programming languages. But that's my biased view where finding a way to implement something is perceived as creative. For non-programmers, I'm implementing something boring in fundamentally the only possible and utterly boring way: the program will get some boring input and produce even more boring output. Whatever you do, you're just making the connection between the two, which everybody can explain in a few sentences, in general. Duh! Everything else are boring details needed because the boring computers need them. And I, they observe, am earning my salary because I'm stupid enough to spend my time on that. Somebody has to do that too. And don't think the people who claim that are stupid. A quote from Richard Feynman himself, describing events in 1940-ties: "Well, Mr. Frankel, who started this program, began to suffer from the computer disease that anybody who works with computers now knows about. It's a very serious disease and it interferes completely with the work. The trouble with computers is you play with them. They are so wonderful. You have these switches - if it's an even number you do this, if it's an odd number you do that - and pretty soon you can do more and more elaborate things if you are clever enough, on one machine. After a while the whole system broke down. Frankel wasn't paying any attention; he wasn't supervising anybody. The system was going very, very slowly - while he was sitting in a room figuring out how to make one tabulator automatically print arc-tangent X, and then it would start and it would print columns and then bitsi, bitsi, bitsi, and calculate the arc-tangent automatically by integrating as it went along and make a whole table in one operation. Absolutely useless. We had tables of arc-tangents. But if you've ever worked with computers, you understand the disease - the delight in being able to see how much you can do. But he got the disease for the first time, the poor fellow who invented the thing." http://benjaminjcousins.wordpress.com/2014/04/01/richard-feynmans-computer-disease/ http://benjaminjcousins.wordpress.com/2014/04/01/richard-fey... (Of course, finding a best way to calculate arc-tangent on a given platform is a serious task. We know that. Somebody has to do that too. Naive approach will get a lot of errors, and also be to slow compared to the good investigated approach. That, it can be said, is an engineering problem, not a problem for a "developer." But still, we're just moving towards the "only" effective and correct way. But if we consider it "fun", well, poor we).
- jacquesm 12y agoBut the playing is essential! Without the playing you'd never get past first base. If I wouldn't actually enjoy this stuff I would have stopped doing it long ago.
- jacquesm 12y agoI've seen spreadsheets that would put your average application programmer to shame. Don't knock excel, it's one of the pillars propping up MS. I can see windows die but excel will be around for a long long time to come.
- eabraham 12y agoI have spoke with non-developers, they often find their fulfillment in other outside activities. I do get comments like "How do you sit in front of a computer for hours?". They may see it as boring or not interesting but they recognize the value in the skill.
- _random_ 12y agoWho is working in the office and not sitting in front of a computer for hours these days?
- kimdouglasmason 12y ago<sarc>Yeah, writing code all day is so much more fulfilling than being a doctor or a teacher or a plumber or any number of things without which society would fall apart. And people who don't to technical work all have drudge jobs with no variety or intellectual challenge. </sarc> I'm not at all surprised at how non-technical people balance work and fulfilment. I am sometimes curious as to how they balance their checkbook considering the decline in real incomes for many critical professions. In my experience, many programmers grossly over-estimate the actual real impact of their work, especially in echo-chambers like the SF Bay Area where their hubris is reinforced by high wages. In general I don't like the anti-tech sentiment that is developing, but as time goes on I understand more and more where it comes from.
- jacquesm 12y agoI guess I dodged a bullet there. Not graduating meant not having a graduation speech which meant I had nobody to discourage me about what I would/could not achieve. Sure I got lucky, and timing is everything. Even so, I think that it isn't quite as bleak as this speech makes it out to be. There is a very large number of solutions for the 'success' question, and it all starts off with how you personally define it. By all means, follow your dreams, but keep a balanced view and don't let your dreams mess up your life. At the same time, don't let your life kill your dreams.
- tzakrajs 12y agoSchools without graduation would be a better model for encouraging a life of learning. The culture around graduation seems to be that of, "just get it over with so you can get on with your life."
- ryukafalz 12y agoReading things like this makes me kind of sad, because I feel like it really shouldn't be this way. Hopefully, with the advent of more sophisticated automation, many of our more tedious jobs won't need humans to do them. I tend to be of the opinion that creating jobs for the sake of creating jobs is a bad thing. If we get to the point where society can persist without everyone having a job, why make people work to survive? There's an interesting article along these lines here: https://medium.com/career-pathing/463ff6dfec1b https://medium.com/career-pathing/463ff6dfec1b The point here is that this would enable people to follow their dreams if they chose to, and not die of starvation in the process. If you still wanted to work, that's not a problem, and you'd make more money that way - but you wouldn't die if you chose not to do so. For that matter, we might be able to achieve this now with a basic income system. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income Discussion at http://www.reddit.com/r/BasicIncome/ http://www.reddit.com/r/BasicIncome/
- plg 12y ago"many of our more tedious jobs won't need humans to do them" We live in such a warped society here in North America. Whatever happened to pride in craftsmanship, pride in an honest day's work, pride in contributing to the community? I bet there will be (perhaps google will lead with this) driverless taxis soon, because after all "who wants to drive a taxi around all day?". Go to Japan. Get in a Japanese taxi. You will see someone who takes the utmost pride in their appearance, their interaction with the customer, the state of the car, the ride, etc etc. It is an experience, to say the least. I believe there is value in that... both to the community and to the individual. Somehow in North America we have convinced ourselves that some jobs are "beneath us" (and I'm not just talking about taxi driving here). It's puzzling to me and it doesn't have to be that way.
- rosser 12y agoSomehow in North America we have convinced ourselves that some jobs are "beneath us"... I'm sorry, but there are kinds of labor that are "beneath" human beings. We don't yet live in a world where people don't have to do those things, but that doesn't change one whit the fact that some basic, minimum level of human dignity, and some of the kinds of work humans have to do are fundamentally incompatible.
- restless 12y agoI worked as bartender,eventecnician, MTB Guide, Skiing Instructor and a lot of other part time jpns. Before I started study with 27 and finished something like a year a ago. Working in software industry is a DREAM, you get a safe job, good money and good working time. Yes good working time compared to eventec it is insanly good. I financed my studys also with part time jobs in the beginning and soon (2 semester) could start programming for a local company, I needed to learn C# which just heard of in a GUI course and boy I was working hard, everything I couldn't do in the company I did at home, this brought me in the got position I am in today and that't what I would suggest to students. Learn, work, learn harder, work harder. Learn what 1 dollar or euro is worth. My role model Henry Rollins http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbnFJVgBcw0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbnFJVgBcw0
- gambiting 12y agoI have finished my BSc degree in Software Engineering and then did postgrad MSc in Games Engineering from one of the best universities in the country for such courses(literally 99% of people on the course get into the games industry afterwards), as it has always been my dream job to work in games. Since I started programming(vb at the age of 12) I always wanted to work as a games programmer - that was my passion and my dream job. So I studied really hard at school, obtained all certificates needed to study abroad, got really good grades at uni,and got my dream job on the first try. It's exactly like you are saying - safe job, good working time, nice benefits - there's only one problem. The pay is literally half of what I could be getting in any other computer science related industry with an MSc title here in the UK. My girlfriend didn't do an MSc but went straight to work after her BSc in Computer Science and she makes 12k more per year than I do. But hey, I absolutely love what I am doing,and I always wanted to do it. So should I just shut up and not complain about the money? Probably. But I am just saying this here,that even with a software engineering degree, fantastic grades and full portfolio, if you follow your passion you might end up making less than you would like to.
- Aloha 12y agoI've always told the soon to enter the job force something - "Pick two things, one is your passion, you should always follow it, the other is a practical skill you can always use to pay the bills - so yeah, go to school for game design, but pay close attention to those IT classes too, and you'll always have a job."
- jt2190 12y agoThe article wastes a lot of time on "stay curious" (not very useful advice either!) and skips over the most important tidbit: > [My girlfriend] made me accountable. Accountability is absolutely the key difference between "going through the motions" and "making progress". It is the way you put "deliberate" into your 10,000 hours of deliberate practice. It's the thing that tells you if you're actually making any progress toward your goal.
- Tycho 12y agoA few thoughts: - good point about the selection bias of graduation speakers and now they probably downplay the role of luck - what makes people even think they know what their dream job is? After working for an interesting company for a few years their perception might change dramatically - is it the job that is the dream, or is it the fame, esteem and wealth? Jobs like being an author or a musician or an artist are probably less pleasant than working in a nice office with a team you like - most of your heroes... Did they learn to be great in their field by studying it in college? - on the other hand, advice to follow your dream might be good as long as you give yourself a healthy dose of optionality/convexity - my advice to people would be don't settle for a job that bores or distresses you, but prepare to be surprised just how fulfilling certain jobs can be
- agorabinary 12y agoThere's going to be a lot of developers on here who went the traditional high school -> CS degree route and think that this alternative life anecdote offers some real insights about the Other world of "passion-seekers", but it really doesn't. The take-away is to stay curious and keep learning even if, most likely, you will never find excitement in your life of corporate monotony, which is of course how many people view paths like CS. From the article, "Most people will have to choose between 'doing what they love,' and pursuing the more mundane promise of a stable paycheck and a promising career path." I think this is a false dichotomy common to a lot of college aged students. I was like this for a while, working in restaurants and the sort before going back to school, and in these jobs you find a lot of people who are afraid to place a bet on a career so they can focus on some wholly non-unique set of "interests". I noticed that few of these people actually pursue these supposed passions to any real extent, and most of these interests were strictly of the creative, non-pragmatic category. I figured that such jobs offered flexibility from the rigid 9-5, and would allow one to pursue these "interests" more freely. This is not the case. Working a developer job you have mental stimulation from learning new things and getting things done. This is normalized of course, and so it's important to remind that working odd jobs while you "write your novel" is entirely devoid of such stimulation, and I believe, actually and actively kills brain cells. And this is the path the author suggests many of our "undecided" college graduates will go? Say it ain't so! If you want to write a novel or learn to paint, and if these are genuine passions, you will make time after work and on the weekends. It's less about "finding your passion" than it is developing a discipline to work on big projects that is completely absent from high school and non-STEM college education. Take your average "undecided" and finance them for a year to follow their passion. A few will make something of their time. Harper Lee did, writing To Kill a Mockingbird uninterrupted for a year thanks to donations from friends. But most will not for the same reason many of us developers (mundane corporate drones) struggle with our own interests and side projects--- because we all lack the discipline. Bukowski summarizes this "myth of creativity" well: http://www.brainpickings.org/index.php/2013/10/04/charles-bukowski-air-and-light-and-time-and-space/ http://www.brainpickings.org/index.php/2013/10/04/charles-bu... It feels good to solve hard problems and challenge yourself. Doing so at work acts as a momentum towards your other goals and interests, and with persistence, lead to a discipline of continued creativity. In case you have not read PG's high school graduation talk, I highly recommend it. Very relevant: http://paulgraham.com/hs.html http://paulgraham.com/hs.html
- thothamon 12y agoI'd say if you feel you can be happy in typical or standard career path, then by all means save yourself a lot of trouble and do that. Some people really are happier that way. If you're one of those who can't be happy in that lifestyle, you probably know who you are. If you're one of those people, then I think you have to keep trying for what you really want. Nothing else will ultimately satisfy.
- grifpete 12y agoIf it is your dream to be truly exceptionally good at something then - if at first you don't succeed, give up.
- mercer 12y agoSam Spurlin wrote an interesting article that really resonated with me, and this article reminded me of it. In particular this bit: > I think there is an underlying metaphor that we can examine between values and passion. I'm not sure I can go a day without hearing or reading the advice about "finding a passion." I used to be a purveyor of this piece of advice as well. Until I figured out it's basically pointless. The belief that everybody has a particular passion waiting for them somewhere in the world and it just needs to be uncovered like a treasure under a rock is not helpful. Therefore, the dominant activity when trying to uncover or find this passion seems to be flitting from activity to activity, from rock to rock, looking for that elusive passion that will fix all your ills. There's a driving force that if you don't like your situation then you just haven't found your passion yet. I've since decided that this line of thinking is mostly fallacious and that "finding" is the wrong verb to use when describing passion. Instead, we should talk about "developing" passion. The focus is on action and practice. I feel the same way about values. The traditional way of thinking about value places little emphasis on actual action, just like the quest for finding a specific passion. Values shouldn't be discovered but developed over time, like passion. Both of these constructs need a radical overhaul. It's worth a read: http://samspurlin.com/blog/2012/2/12/values-dont-make-your-life-better.html http://samspurlin.com/blog/2012/2/12/values-dont-make-your-l...