3 ms·
Everyone is getting really excited because they think this is how it works, but no, not exactly. The shutter sound comes from the same speaker as the anti-shut
by jayd16 12y ago
Everyone is getting really excited because they think this is how it works, but no, not exactly.
The shutter sound comes from the same speaker as the anti-shutter sound. The phone is mixing the tracks together and playing nothing.
It's not like both sounds are played and they neutralize each other as sound waves.
- lovemenot 12y agoSince it would have more general applicability, I am curious how effective could the noise-cancelling-like method could be? What would be the constraints on its effectiveness?
- wyager 12y agoIt's the same process that would happen if you actually played both sounds. The superposition is just happening in software instead of air.
- ANTSANTS 12y agoInverted sound waves can cancel each other in air, I've heard (or not heard) the effect with my own ears.
- TTPrograms 12y agoRight, but for any point source this is effect is going to vary spatially. That's why you can't make one speaker totally cancel out another speaker over a whole room.
- jayd16 12y agoSure, but my point is that there is only one speaker involved so the cancellation happens in the electronics, before any sound is made.
- kordless 12y agoIt's interesting to think of 'cancellation' in different mediums. Waves in physical space. Radio in electromagnetism. And now 'computed' waves cancel each other too.