4 ms·
> Remember that the majority of publishers just recently colluded with Apple to essentially fuck over Amazon. Well, that's certainly how the Justice Department
by eridius 12y ago
> Remember that the majority of publishers just recently colluded with Apple to essentially fuck over Amazon.
Well, that's certainly how the Justice Department chose to see it. That doesn't make that statement the objective truth.
I still don't see how anyone can say with a straight face that the new entrant in a market is "fuck[ing] over" the dominant player. Especially when countless economists have weighed in saying that the kind of corrective measures employed by Apple and the publishers are not (and should not be) illegal and that the Justice Department basically got everything wrong.
(Google is failing me here for finding these economist opinions that I've seen in the past, but amusingly, my search is chock full of articles from before the ruling saying that economists think the DOJ is going to lose the case)
- chrismcb 12y ago"corrective measures employed by Apple" what were the measures and what were they correcting? And how did the Justice Department get it wrong. Apple colluded with the publishers to set the price, and forced Amazon to sell for the same price. With mainly the people being screwed (well in some cases the publishers actually lost money too) Unfortunately the corrective measures taken SINCE the ruling having really made much of a change.
- eridius 12y ago> Apple colluded with the publishers to set the price, and forced Amazon to sell for the same price Apple gave the publishers leverage to use with Amazon, which is a wee bit different. But I'll give you "colluded", because it doesn't really matter. I wish Google would actually find the various articles I've read in the past about this, but my recollection is that various economists have explained that this sort of "corrective measure" is actually legal and the right course of action under certain circumstances, and the ebook market (with Amazon's near-total dominance) qualifies. You say "mainly the people being screwed", but that's not true. Amazon tried to claim that prices were lower before Apple came along, but that's actually only true for some (admittedly popular) books. Prices on other books were higher before Apple. Not only that, but the low prices that Amazon was talking about was not actually a sustainable market, but instead was Amazon engaging in predatory pricing. And predatory pricing is not something that the DOJ is supposed to be in the business of defending. Basically, many people have looked at the overall book market both before and Apple entered it, and found that, when looking at the entire market instead of just e.g. the NYT bestsellers list, prices were not higher after Apple showed up. It's also worth pointing out that Apple was being accused of violating antitrust laws, which are essentially laws designed to prevent unfair monopolistic practices. It seems rather ridiculous to claim that a minority player in a market could be guilty of monopolistic practices, since that generally requires being a monopoly. It's even more absurd when one of the main goals of antitrust is to promote fair competition, and yet it was used to punish the only real competition that Amazon had in the market. Basically, the DOJ used fair competition laws to hand a government-sanctioned monopoly to a single company. --- I did a bit more digging, and what Apple was found guilty of was a "per se" violation of a horizontal price-fixing conspiracy using a series of vertical agreements. I've found a MacObserver article[1] that talks about a 30-page amici curiae brief filed by two economists explaining why Judge Cote's ruling was wrong. [1]: http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/economists-on-apple-ebook-antitrust-case-judge-cote-got-it-wrong http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/economists-on-apple-e... There's a 3-paragraph summary at that article, which should give you a good idea of what was wrong with the ruling. I've seen a number of other articles since the ruling where other economists weigh in and say essentially the same thing, but Google is still being difficult. --- Edit: One comment about this brief says that the DOJ didn't make these considerations because it found Apple to be per se liable, which is to say, the DOJ considered the actions to be illegal regardless of any possible motivation. Some of the other economists I've referred to argued specifically against this point, saying that these kinds of vertical agreements are not a violation of the per se rule and that Judge Cote royally screwed up in applying it. Of course, Judge Cote's ruling also said she would consider Apple to have been guilty under a rule of reason as well, but I find it hard to believe given how much evidence there is that Apple's actions were indeed in its own independent business interest, and that these kinds of vertical agreements and the provisions they contained are not in fact illegal under these circumstances (my understanding is basically that they can be illegal when used by a dominant player in a market, because it's anti-competitive, but when used by a new entrant in a market with an existing dominant player, they are ok, but IANAL).
- Oletros 12y ago> Basically, many people have looked at the overall book market both before and Apple entered it, and found that, when looking at the entire market instead of just e.g. the NYT bestsellers list, prices were not higher after Apple showed up. Basically, many people have looked at the 5 publishers accused of collusion and have seen that prices were higher AFTER the collusion
- eridius 12y agoAre you trying to claim that somehow this whole affair affected book prices for the smaller publishers that didn't have agreements with Apple? Because for both of us to be right, all the smaller publishers must have dropped their prices precipitously to offset this supposed increase across the board in the prices of the 5 big publishers.
- Oletros 12y agoI'm trying to say that ebook prices from publishers other than the 5 accused are irrelevant. The fact is that the ebook average price from the accused publishers went up, it is irrelevant for that case that the total market average prices were down.
- eridius 12y agoOk, so you are saying that the price of the other publishers went down, and apparently dropped enough to offset the fact that they're, well, smaller publishers, and therefore a smaller part of the book market. I don't think that's true. I have never heard that the smaller publishers kept dropping their prices.
- Oletros 12y agohttp://www.justice.gov/atr/cases/f298700/298794.pdf#page=1 http://www.justice.gov/atr/cases/f298700/298794.pdf#page=1
- chongli 12y agoI still don't see how anyone can say with a straight face that the new entrant in a market is "fuck[ing] over" the dominant player. Because Apple leveraged an existing market where they were the dominant player (iOS). You could've said the same thing about Internet Explorer being a new entrant to the browser market, back when they fucked over Netscape.
- eridius 12y agoiOS is not a market in of itself. It certainly wasn't the dominant way to read eBooks (the Kindle was, to the best of my knowledge). You're trying to narrowly define a market purely for the purposes of claiming Apple was the dominant player, but you aren't explaining how Apple could leverage iOS in any fashion. And even if you do purely concern yourself with reading eBooks on smartphones and tablets (and ignore the fact that iBooks doesn't even exist on Android devices, and consider the Kindle to not count because it's not a general-purpose tablet), the Kindle iOS app still was the dominant player there. Apple could not leverage their ownership of iOS to give an unfair advantage to iBooks. The only advantage it had was that visiting the App Store for the first time would suggest you download iBooks, but the Kindle app had plenty of promotion within the App Store as well. I also find your attempt to claim this is analogous to Internet Explorer to be preposterous for multiple reasons. Not only did Microsoft literally bundle it with Windows, it was a free competitor to the then-paid Netscape Navigator, and there wasn't an established market for web browsers at that point anyway. Microsoft also enjoyed an overwhelming monopoly in the desktop OS market with Windows, whereas Apple has never had a monopoly in the smartphone market with iOS.
- chongli 12y agoI didn't say iOS was a market. It's the player, the market is mobile operating systems. It's no longer the dominant player now, however.
- eridius 12y agoIt never was. Despite what various pundits keep claiming over and over again, iOS never had a majority share of the smartphone market.