3 ms·
(In case it gets changed the current title is: Burning sand as renewable power supply) Where to even start, sigh. You are not burning sand. And it's not in th
by ars 13y ago
(In case it gets changed the current title is: Burning sand as renewable power supply)
Where to even start, sigh.
You are not burning sand. And it's not in the slightest renewable. Or CO2 neutral or any of the other nonsense in the article.
At best silicon can be used as a battery of sorts if you burn the silicon.
It's not an energy source, and it has no impact whatsoever on CO2.
Flagged. I think it should be killed, but if it stays at least change the title to "Using silicon as an energy carrier by burning it and then reducing it".
- 3am 13y agoI didn't even catch that bit about burning "sand" in the title. It's the precise _opposite_ of burning sand. Oxidation, reduction... details.
- jqm 13y agoHow is it not CO2 neutral? It isn't using carbon as an energy carrier like fossil fuels so no CO2 should be released unless I'm missing something. It is renewable to some extent although it sound like on subsequent uses the media would become less effective. I agree with you on the title. Not accurate.
- ars 13y ago> How is it not CO2 neutral? It's not CO2 neutral, positive or negative. It has nothing whatsoever to do with CO2. It's an energy carrier not a source. The amount of CO2 released depends on the energy source. Hydrocarbon fuels can also be CO2 irrelevant if you make the hydrocarbon from some other energy source (you can make gasoline from air + energy). But usually you get the hydrocarbon from the ground and then it's not just a carrier, it's also a source. > It is renewable to some extent although it sound like on subsequent uses the media would become less effective. "Renewable" is not a concept that applies here because it's not an energy source. The media can be used as much as you like, it doesn't get used up, it just changes and changes back. Rechargeable is probably the better word here, but it starts as already full discharged (sand) so you have to charge it with something.
- jqm 13y ago"It's not CO2 neutral, positive or negative. It has nothing whatsoever to do with CO2." If it doesn't involve CO2, it is, by definition, CO2 neutral. As in, it doesn't produce CO2 (unlike fossil fuels). Yes, I realize it is an energy carrier (in concept). The media is less useful on subsequent uses. The sun is the source of the energy. Which I suppose makes you technically correct. As far as I know, the sun isn't "renewable".
- ars 13y ago> If it doesn't involve CO2, it is, by definition, CO2 neutral. No, CO2 neutral is an energy source that does not release any extra CO2 into the air (like growing a plant and burning it). (CO2 negative removes CO2 from the air.) This is not an energy source, the CO2 measure of this depends only on the source. The silicon is completely irrelevant to that. > The media is less useful on subsequent uses. And that's the 3rd time you've said that, and I still have no idea where you are getting this erroneous concept. > The sun is the source of the energy. Which I suppose makes you technically correct. As far as I know, the sun isn't "renewable". No, the sun is not the source of the energy. This proposal does not include an energy source. I keep telling you that, but you don't seem to get it. This is an energy carrier. There is no energy source involved here. (And you can ignore the words "solar panel" in the article. You can use a solar panel for anything, it has absolutely nothing to do with this.)
- dred_blue 13y agoYes, the sun is absolutely the energy source. The silicon/sand is the carrier. Why did I mention recycling the media? It's mentioned in the article. Twice in fact. Read the article.
- ars 13y ago> Yes, the sun is absolutely the energy source. The sun can also be an energy source to make syn-gas (to make synthetic gasoline for cars), or charge a battery, or make hydrogen, or pump water uphill. What does that have to do with silicon as a carrier? Absolutely nothing. You can also make silicon if you burn some coal. The sun is completely irrelevant. > Why did I mention recycling the media? It's mentioned in the article. Twice in fact. Just because it's in an article doesn't make it correct. This article is really bad. It has just enough truth to make it seem plausible. The crust of this entire planet is made of silicon, it's not something that needs recycling anyway.