6 ms·
From the article: "The current CARTs kill not just cancer cells but any B-cell, the type of white blood cell that goes wrong in leukemia." So this really isn't
by wvenable 12y ago
From the article: "The current CARTs kill not just cancer cells but any B-cell, the type of white blood cell that goes wrong in leukemia."
So this really isn't an cancer cure at all; it is B-cell cure. I'm surprised this isn't a more significant detail in the article. It's really the cell-equivalent of cutting off a cancerous limb.
- protomyth 12y agocontinuing that quote "The current CARTs kill not just cancer cells but any B-cell, the type of white blood cell that goes wrong in leukemia. Patients are likely to get injections of a protein that B-cells make, called gamma globulin, for the rest of their lives; if the treatment becomes popular there may not be enough gamma globulin to go around." So, not scalable?
- quasque 12y agoYes, it lacks scalability because the source of the replacement immunoglobulin (antibodies) is blood donors, of which there are a limited amount.
- suby 12y agoI know nothing about this so forgive my ignorance, but could synthetic blood provide what's needed? From what I understand we're making progress with synthesizing blood. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/10765132/Artificial-blood-will-be-manufactured-in-factories.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/10765132/Artifi...
- ghkbrew 12y agoPretty much no. Most synthetic blood efforts are focused on replacing the oxygen-carrying components of blood i.e. red blood cells and the hemoglobin they contain. That is what's needed in emergency settings and surgery where lack of blood flow can kill tissues in minutes. Immunoglobulins (aka antibodies) are important for preventing infection and thus long term health but they would be difficult to impossible to produce synthetically.
- asdkl234890 12y ago* Immunoglobulins (aka antibodies) are important for preventing infection and thus long term health but they would be difficult to impossible to produce synthetically.* Even with hybridomas?
- ghkbrew 12y agoYes, there are ways of producing antibodies outside the body. One could argue whether hybridomas (essentially immortalized b-cells used to produce a specific antibody) constitute truly synthetic production. I considered mentioning them, but decided it was probably more in depth answer than the GP's question really needed. Since you asked though, I don't think hybridomas really solve the difficulty of reconstituting a persons antibodies ex vivo. A healthy human has somewhere around a trillion different antibodies circulating. I would conservatively estimate that the research community has produced a few thousand different hybridomas since they were first described in 1975. The problem of scaling that or any other in vitro technique to the trillions seems unlikely to be solved. Now, I get into the domain of wild speculation. What you'd really need is a single system capable of producing a nearly unlimited variety of different antibodies. The most viable option to my mind would be a transgenic mammal (let's say a goat since it's easy to get antibodies from milk) which would produce humanized antibodies. However, given the relatively small demand for such treatments, I think any such efforts are unlikely.
- asdkl234890 12y agoCan't we use hybridoma to make immunoglobulin?
- gte910h 12y agoFriend of mine had to get gammaglobulin shots for a few years (8 or so years ago): The stuff supposedly cost about 10k a vial, because it was filtered out of the plasma of many of people per vial and put through several complicated processes to isolate and sterilize it. So...if we had considerably larger plasma donations, maybe?
- quasque 12y agoThat would help up to a point, but there also ongoing research to manufacture it using recombinant techniques - that is, genetically engineering bacteria to produce the required protein product and then purifying it out. Then your limiting factor is a reproducible manufacturing process rather than availability of human sources. This is akin to how, for example, insulin and human growth hormone are now produced; previously they also lacked scalability due to having to be sourced from cadavers. So yes right now it's not scalable, but in the future this limitation will hopefully be corrected.
- revelation 12y agoThere is no cancer cure. Cancer is what we call cells that have mutated to evade last years cancer cure.
- pak 12y agoYou're getting downvoted probably because people do not understand the raw truth that lies behind what you said. I detest articles that use the word "cure" and "cancer" in the title. They are without fail so breathless about the clichéd achievement that they are exploiting in the headline that they either fail to acknowledge the real magnitude of the problem or gloss over it with practiced sleaze (not sure which happened to the writers here). We've had a "cure" for cancer since the times when barbers also performed surgery on the side (Egyptian civilization, at least), and that is surgical excision. It's still the best treatment we have for many cancers, e.g. melanoma and lung cancer, both of which are much more common than the cancer in the article. It doesn't work for every cancer, but for some cancers it works good enough, and even better when combined with chemotherapy (which ham-handedly slows replication in every cell in your body). The point of any cure is to remove the cancer cells from your body and for some cancers they fortunately stay within one excisable area. Like the GP comment pointed out, this is essentially a much more targeted version of the same thing. Obviously it would be better for the patient to retain B cells, without which they will have no adaptive immunity--just like a patient with melanoma would prefer to keep the hunk of their nose that the surgeon had to remove. This is an incremental, very fancy and very expensive improvement on the same old strategy of killing the organ to save the body. It will never work on non-blood cancers (which are the vast majority of cancers, BTW). People do not understand that cancer is a disease that combines the trickiest parts of fighting aging with the trickiest parts of fighting infectious disease. Cell replication is one of the hardest things your body has to do, and it does it several trillions of times per day in your body, essentially copying about 1 billion TB worth of data while automatically detecting and fixing every dangerous error that could possibly result. It is natural that this process will screw up catastrophically at some point--on an infinite timescale, assuming we fix all other health issues, everybody will still get cancer just as surely as they age every year. And once they do, you have a cell that your immune system has carefully trained for decades not to engage, invading and hogging every resource it can, with mutations that allow it to adapt to selective pressures, including any drugs you might throw at it. Essentially, it's an infectious parasite, except it looks 99% like your own cells to your immune system, and is already perfectly suited to your body's style of metabolism. Let's keep in mind that this can arise from any cell in your body that replicates, and just about every organ system has a good number of those to replenish malfunctioning or old cells and fix injuries. The possibilities are staggering and so are the number of known cancers. There is no "magic bullet" that cures every single cancer, just like there is no "magic antibiotic" that kills every infectious bacterium. Even the smartest, most generalizable ideas right now, like cancer vaccines, depend on your immune system to make the final push, and the immune system is just as fallible as any other organ system. At the point where somebody can make the claim that all cancer is cured, we will as a matter of course have gained control over every replication event that occurs in our body (trillions upon trillions of nanoscale events per day). That will be a truly remarkable feat, but is in no way within reach of any foreseeable technology. When we cure cancer, we will have by necessity cured aging and all infectious disease will have become a relatively trivial problem. That should put the claim of "curing cancer" into perspective.
- grifpete 12y agoWithout wanting to get into parsing the word 'cure' imho this is a cancer cure. The reason the treatment kills the B-cells as well is because that is how it identifies the cancer cells. It is the marker that enables the T cells to recognize the cancer cells. But the fact that it kills the B cells does not mean that it does not successfully treat the cancer cells. It appears that it does. And hence it seems fair to call it a cure.