4 ms·
I have an eBay account, but I haven't used it in years, and I doubt I remember the password. How worried about this should I be? Are there plaintext passwords
by ForHackernews 12y ago
I have an eBay account, but I haven't used it in years, and I doubt I remember the password.
How worried about this should I be? Are there plaintext passwords exposed, or do they just have a lot of properly salted hashes that aren't much use to an attacker?
- andrewmunsell 12y agoThere aren't any plain text passwords, but there are email addresses, physical addresses, phone numbers, and DOBs.
- rwmj 12y agoIt's the DoB which is the giveaway (that this is fake). eBay doesn't collect date of birth, but does collect lots of other authentication information. EDIT: I stand corrected, see the reply by sp332 below.
- sp332 12y agoeBay says the data includes DoB. https://blog.ebay.com/ebay-inc-ask-ebay-users-change-passwords/ https://blog.ebay.com/ebay-inc-ask-ebay-users-change-passwor... [edit: better link] Maybe they only collect it for certain customers?
- crest 12y agoIn that case ebay users should probably change their date of birth too ;-).
- mikeash 12y agoAnd physical address and phone number.
- ForHackernews 12y agoFake your own death and run away to Argentina.
- iaskwhy 12y agoAs with any other hacked company, assume the worst: everything was leaked as plaintext.
- aetherson 12y agoReports indicated that the passwords were encrypted, but I do not believe they've mentioned what the encryption scheme is. Plaintext uniquely identifying information like Date of Birth was included, however.
- thefreeman 12y agoJudging by the prefix to one of the link pasted hashes, looks like PBKDF2 with sha256?
- cauterize 12y agoI've had an eBay account for 10+ years. I thought a "hey, we screwed up, please change your password" type email would be nice.
- seabee 12y agoThey did force a password reset on everyone trying to log in yesterday; even if they already reset their password when they first heard the news, effectively locking them out for the evening because their password reset system was understandably overwhelmed with requests. Thanks eBay!
- nkozyra 12y agoMy guess would be this is less about passwords (which - wild guess here - are probably fairly well-secured) and more about ancillary user meta data.
- bsimpson 12y agoI guess I'm going to have to change my birthdate.
- sp332 12y agoeBay didn't say what kind of encryption they had, only that they were encrypted. Personally I'm more concerned about the personal information in the leaked data that wasn't protected at all! So sure, change your password, but it won't change the fact that someone got your name, email address, physical address, phone number, and date of birth.
- nkozyra 12y agoOn the plus side, think of how nice it will be to get a happy birthday phone call from a hacker.
- hellbreakslose 12y agosp332 to be honest here, I am pretty sure if you search your real life name on the internet you will definitely find somewhere that you can buy the information you just mentioned. I am not trying to be mean here, I am just trying to let you know in case you didn't know. Plus you already have your email publicly displayed here ... and i found some weird stuff about amateur ... xxx movies when i googled you T_T
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pabb 12y agoHe took down his reply, but he shares a name with a fairly famous actor. Gonna take a stab that the "amateur ... xxx" was related to that guy. Also, you're an idiot.
- sp332 12y agoIt's not just the actor, it's a pretty common name. People mistype my email address into all kinds of things, judging by the random emails I get for pets in Texas and real estate in the UK etc.
- Mithaldu 12y agoThe passwords look like this: pbkdf2_sha256$12000$zhMKabMgayvK$iniviUCcX9y2PYJcm0AoB3MhybRA1z2Cec1DZnLWxWc= I do not know how much time it would take to bruteforce these. Can any experienced HNers weigh in?
- seefoma 12y agoThis is actually about as good as it gets for password hashes, so kudos to eBay. Since these are salted and require 12000 iterations, cracking individual passwords will be quite time consuming. The preferred method in this case, though, is to go after low hanging fruit. The way one would do this is to try something like the 500 most common passwords against all entries in the table. This won't take very long (compared to trying to brute force a bunch of individual passwords), and will probably yield a ton of passwords.
- thefreeman 12y agoI am not an expert by any means, but I believe pbkdf2 is a recommended key stretching function for a hashing method (which looks to be sha256). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PBKDF2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PBKDF2 I think cracking difficulty depends on how many "iterations" they use though.
- tmorgan 12y agoI assume 12000 iterations by the looks of that $ delimited string, I assume they're storing the parameters as, hash_func$iterations$salt$derived_key
- bfish510 12y agoThe iterations are listed as 12000. This value is supposed to double every two years and is around 128k I believe currently.
- peterwwillis 12y agoThis is probably to try to offset Moore's law, by keeping the hash cracking difficulty in line with technology progrss. But it's funny how this works. If you think about Moore's law, it's basically describing the number of transistors on an IC, those doubling every two years. But it doesn't address expansion in the ways we use our technology. If new machines come out which allow us to stack even more GPUs into a single machine, performance capacity per cracking host will rise even farther than double per year. One person estimated an 8-GPU cracking machine two years ago at about 539 billion hashes per minute. At 128k hashes for one password, you could make about 70,182 attempts per second. But here[1] is a five-machine cluster from a year and a half ago with 25 GPUs. Its speed? 63 billion per second against SHA1. This results in 492,187 attempts per second. Assuming SHA256 is about 50% slower, this would be around 246,093 per second. Some password dictionaries contain millions of words. But if your password is '0Password', it'll probably be cracked in a couple of seconds on modern hardware. [1] http://arstechnica.com/security/2012/12/25-gpu-cluster-cracks-every-standard-windows-password-in-6-hours/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2012/12/25-gpu-cluster-crack...
- kej 12y agoFrom the linked sample data, passwords are pbkdf2-sha256 while name/address/phone/birth date are clear text.
- rmc 12y agoproperly salted hashs can still harm many peple. You could still run a brute force on the top 10k most common passwords and with ~150m averge computer users, you're going to get a few. And you have their email address. There's a good chance they're using the same password for email. Now you have their email.
- mischanix 12y agoWith user-individual salts and assuming 100ms for a password trial, 100ms * 150e6 * 10e3 is approximately 4750 years, and while this can be done in parallel, it's not exactly a small amount of resources you'd have to devote to get these relatively simple passwords.
- ForHackernews 12y agoYeah, that's true. Due respect, but I'm not really worried about those other users, only me. Because I'm a human and I'm selfish.