3 ms·
You're still way off base. The only thing that matters is effective tax rate. a) Income Taxes -- Here's the comparison of taxes on $100k in income: http://i.im
by mikeyouse 12y ago
You're still way off base. The only thing that matters is effective tax rate.
a) Income Taxes -- Here's the comparison of taxes on $100k in income: http://i.imgur.com/GR9czuF.png http://i.imgur.com/GR9czuF.png - USA has the 53rd highest effective rate. $100k too low? We actually move down to 55th if you look at the same chart for $300k in income: http://i.imgur.com/2hb7iuB.jpg http://i.imgur.com/2hb7iuB.jpg
b) Corporate Taxes -- Some of the lowest effective rates in the OECD: http://i.imgur.com/ZdPCL9C.jpg http://i.imgur.com/ZdPCL9C.jpg
c) Estate Taxes -- "We pay 50%" -- No 'we' don't. The tax doesn't apply at all if you leave your money to a spouse, farms and other small businesses are exempt as assets, only assets over $5.3 million have any tax applied at all, and the rate is 40%. $5M estate when you die? Tax rate = 0%. $6M estate? Tax rate = 4.7%.
d) Tax enforcement is strict? Come on. The vast majority of tax cases ended up with the 'guilty' party settling and paying back taxes. A few end up with penalties on top (most penalties are negotiated away for prompt payment). The only people imprisoned are those willfully engaging in tax fraud.
2. High earner tax rates -- This is so wrong. High earner rates are at the same level they were in the 80's and 90's: http://i.imgur.com/fklDml0.png http://i.imgur.com/fklDml0.png --- But most importantly, the '1%er' incomes have risen dramatically. If we were in a truly progressive tax system, shouldn't tax rates increase as incomes do?
3. Make sure you're comparing apples to apples.. the OECD and Heritage (who are no fan of taxes and would have every incentive to make the US look worse) show a completely different story than the one you're providing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenue_as_percentage_of_GDP http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenu...
They show the US at 26.9% of GDP for 2012, Canada at 32.2%, the UK at 39.0%, and France at 44.6%. If you've ever spent time in any of those countries, you'd surely see how absurd it sounds to indicate that we're taxed more than they are.
As for 'We're only 5 points lower than the UK'. Even if that was true, only 5 points would mean almost a trillion dollars in additional tax.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoa) We're talking about people with annual incomes in the tens and hundreds of millions. Their effective rate in a state like CA will be in the 40s or 50s. b) The low effective rates published by the GAO and others are well known to be utterly false. Here's a primer: http://tax.org/TAXCOM/TAXBLOG.NSF/PERMALINK/MSUN-99DKXS?OPENDOCUMENT http://tax.org/TAXCOM/TAXBLOG.NSF/PERMALINK/MSUN-99DKXS?OPEN... c) Again, we're talking about estates worth billions. 50% effective. d) Talk to some tax accountants in other nations to get a feel for how strict US tax enforcement is. The differences are glaring and obvious. It'll also dispel any notions you had about the US tax rates being lower in practice. 2. Effective rates are higher due to closed loopholes and tighter enforcement and the inability to leave the US with ones assets. 3. I've lived in several different nations. You may be interested to know that, for example, the US government spends more on public healthcare per person than does the UK.