7 ms·
Google Search Results: Dictator Not Found
- jrockway 13y agohttp://www.bonkersworld.net/forgetting/ http://www.bonkersworld.net/forgetting/
- lightyrs 13y agoGodwin Edit: There is a huge gulf between Hitler and a juvenile crime or since-paid debt.
- Crito 13y agoSince you are adverse to references to the 1940s, suppose we were talking about ex-Google engineer David Barksdale instead. Does he have the "right to be forgotten"?
- lightyrs 13y agoWhere did you get the implication that I'm adverse to references to the 1940s? As for who has the right to be forgotten, that's for the EU courts to determine (as far as EU citizens go).
- r12e 13y agoClear public interest, request denied. The EU ruling works.
- whoismua 13y agoResorting to Hitler right away? How about a person who cannot a job because of a certain stupid act from 30 years ago that keeps showing up on Google search? Even credit reports are barred from reporting older than x years acts.
- axanoeychron 13y agoFor the EU requirement to check if information is in the public interest, we have to have guards against the system being abused, such as wealthy people removing information about themselves. This implies some sort of public record - to provide transparency of the requests and check for abuse. This could not be indexed either because it would reveal the information that people were trying to stop being revealed. Dilemma.
- Crito 13y agoAre these guards against abuse anything like the "guards against abuse" that the English presumably have to prevent abuse of super-injunctions by multi-millionare footballers?
- axanoeychron 13y agoIt would seem that applying a law in spirit is incompatible with human nature. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_and_spirit_of_the_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_and_spirit_of_the_law
- turbohz 13y agoThe proper way to handle such mess would be a "right to be forgiven", not a "right no be forgotten". But then, some things are easier to forget than to forgive.
- Tombone5 13y agoThe NSA doesn't want to know everything you do because they suspect you of anything, but because they can't be sure the will never suspect you.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoThe only connection with "such a mess" and the EU court ruling are the word "forgotten" and a Spaniard. The rest of the article is just manipulative association that would make Godwin blush. The EU court does not disagree with you, no matter how hard the anti-privacy lobby tries to make it look that way.
- smsm42 13y agoI'm pretty sure if the government had a way to force people to forgive, they'd try to. But so far they can only find way to control the information, not thought. I guess something is better than nothing for them.
- axanoeychron 13y agoThis is a strawman argument. It's blatantly obvious that a historically significant event such as a dictator needs to be kept as part of the history books because of the impact it had on many different people. At the end - the argument that anything that is published and is true as a reason why we should not allow people to delete things about themselves is deeply disturbing and sets a dangerous precedent. Just because something is true does not mean it should be broadcast for everyone to hear and see. If you go to the toilet and leave a big dump - not everyone needs to know this, when you did it, its mass. Lossless public record is something that people do not understand the full implications. I am predicting a collision course with the precedence from this case with anonymous gossip sharing applications like Secret. No good comes from allowing people to publish things about others with the intention to harm and no recourse for victims. What the forgetting laws is for is to help a young person delete embarrassing content from the modern day equivalent of Geocities or Bebo. People are screened for employment online - why should a child whose transgressions in a previous generation would have been transient be stored for eternity? What utility does that provide? EDIT: If you disagree - use the reply button.
- smsm42 13y agoIt's blatantly obvious to you. It may not be blatantly obvious to a nationalistic charismatic leader who thinks Franco wasn't too bad and actually needs only a bit of better PR and some long tongues silenced, and it would be for the best of public interest to do this. Look at what's going on in Russia. You think it can't happen in Spain or Germany? It already happened before and very well can happen again. Anytime and anywhere. The layer protecting the rights of people from oppression - including popular and widely supported oppression - is very thin. EU rule made it even thinner. Now anybody can memory-hole any information they don't like - and this would especially true for powerful and connected people who want to suppress information about their wrongdoings. You worry about teenage shenanigans - but this can - and will - be used to hide very adult shenanigans with very important consequences too. And you will have no say in if it's "public interest" or not.
- ritchiea 13y agoDid you read the entire article? The author uses Spain's legal treatment of those accused of torture in the Spanish civil war to make a very cogent argument that laws mandating we censor the past can have effects as broad as lossless public record. To say this is a strawman argument you would have to provide some evidence the author is ignoring/hiding the fact that the EU has clear criteria for scrubbing search.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoBaseless scaremongering by the New Yorker. That's really a new low in American anti-privacy propaganda. The first paragraph alone reads like the kind of paranoia I would expect from the Tea Party. "Google has to scrub any material that a user wants taken down, as long as removing it doesn’t hurt the public interest." It's a lot, a lot more nuanced than that. Also, the EJC is nowhere near the equivalent of the US Supreme Court. The EU is not a federal state. The rest of the article basically goes into a Godwinesque directions, only for this occasion we're using Franco's fascists instead of Hitler's Nazi's.
- YokoZar 13y agoThe Spanish high court deferred to the European Court of Justice, and there's no one for them to defer to after that. That makes the Supreme Court analogy pretty apt as far as judicial rulings are concerned in this matter. If you read the entire article, you'll note that the post-Franco era discussion is mostly backstory for how the whole issue of public forgetting is particularly relevant in Spain, and in fact why this test case came from Spain. The article itself then goes on to mention how no fascists have (yet) asked for a Google scrub, however it does imply that someone might eventually try. And it's a good point to raise, as all this "nuance" will require some sort of system of rules and arbitration to decide what is "in the public interest" on a case by case basis. Such a system could be quite burdensome, or prone to abuse. In contrast, countries with strong free speech protections have a rather simple set of rules for when you're allowed to force others to remove true statements from the internet: you dont.
- hencq 13y ago> Also, the EJC is nowhere near the equivalent of the US Supreme Court. The EU is not a federal state. Even though the EU is not a federal state, the decisions of the ECJ still overrule these of member states. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costa_v_ENEL http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Costa_v_ENEL
- lightyrs 13y agoJust wait until the first Facebook-generation presidential candidate — the right to be forgotten will be considered a 'human right'.
- dublinben 13y agoUnfortunately, this likely won't be the case. Millennials I know who harbor desires to run for president some day are so boring, that they have nothing incriminating on their social media accounts to even be worried about. They will just use this kind of information against their potential and actual competitors. I suspect that it will take at least another generation before we are willing to accept a candidate whose colorful youth comes to light before they're elected.
- smsm42 13y agoObama was a member of the "choom gang" and had various other shenanigans well-documented in his youth. Didn't prevent him from becoming the senator and then the president. I think you overestimating the interest of the public to Facebook. Of course if there were something more serious that a bunch of embarrassing selfies, that'd be different business, but that what we want to happen, don't we?
- happyscrappy 13y agoIt is bewildering that Europeans think this is a good idea or even remotely workable. Maybe some EU company would like to take a stab at operating under these kind of capricious rulings.
- vacri 13y agoIt is bewildering that Europeans think this is a good idea or even remotely workable. It is bewildering that you can't see why Europeans might think that personal privacy might be a significant issue.
- koepked 13y agoI think personal privacy is a significant issue, but I also think this is a bad idea, and not even remotely workable.
- vacri 13y agoI'm not saying I agree with it as an idea, but Google has a history of doing hard things (indeed, was founded on a hard thing), and what about the American 'can-do' attitude when it comes to hard things? As for personal privacy, new-world Anglo countries (where I am, and where most of the people on this site are) don't hold a candle to the history of pogroms that old-world countries have had, with the exception of treatment of first peoples. It's not just the Nazis and the Holocaust here, but a long history of terrorism and vigilantism. Europe still has wars (and similar) based on ethnicity - for example the Balkan states in the 90s, or eastern Ukraine going on right now. The last significant internal conflict in the new-world Anglosphere was 150 years ago. Europe has had a significantly different experience, which should be taken into context when understanding their decisions around privacy.
- kghose 13y agoWhat about internet archive, then?
- axanoeychron 13y agoGood question. While the right to forget is socially beneficial for society, there are technical problems that make it inconvenient. There is the problem of whether it is censorship to force a neutral party whose mandate is merely to store historical copies of data to remove it. Or is it Google's responsibility to just 'forget' that the copy exists in the web archive? Do defaced websites get indexed by the internet archive? Does illegal information get removed from the internet archive?
- abruzzi 13y agoWhat exactly is "illegal information"? In the US for the most part, we have a distinction between the information and how it was obtained. Daniel Ellsberg may have done something illegal when he released the Pentagon Papers, but once it was in the hands of journalists, the US could not stop its publication. I also disagree that the "right to forget" is socially beneficial. It may benefit individuals who have negative thing about them that they want expunged, but for society as a whole, we are the worse off because if everyone can have their image cleaned of their past, predators and destructive people will have an easier time hiding and preying on others.
- happyscrappy 13y agoBlocked for Europeans. They sure as hell can't afford to do backflips through hoops for this.
- dllthomas 13y agoI think there's a subtle difference as well between a search engine (which mostly turns up recent and relevant) and an archive, in terms of the expectations that searchers have. I don't know that this difference is significant enough to change anything here, but...
- smsm42 13y ago
- shiift 13y agoI feel like this could be abused to remove competitors' content from Google results. Couldn't this be a problem?