4 ms·
Why does it matter who sends who how many bits? It seems like that would only matter if one peer is sending traffic over another peer's network that's has yet a
by eridius 12y ago
Why does it matter who sends who how many bits? It seems like that would only matter if one peer is sending traffic over another peer's network that's has yet a third peer as the real destination. But if e.g. Level3 is sending bits to Comcast because they're going to Comcast customers, then that seems entirely ok. These aren't bits that Level3 is forcing on Comcast. Comcast asked for these bits. Or rather, Comcast's customers did, but that's the same thing as far as I'm concerned.
If Comcast is asking Level3 for massive amounts of traffic, it makes no sense at all for Comcast to then turn around and accuse Level3 of sending them too much traffic. I suspect the real problem is that Comcast simply didn't expects its customers to actually use all the bandwidth Comcast promised them. They can't very well accuse their own customers of using too much traffic (for legitimate purposes, I'm ignoring BitTorrent here).
Comcast just needs to admit their equipment simply isn't up to the task of servicing their own customers, and they need to upgrade. Trying to charge Netflix for all the traffic is just pure greed.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago>Why does it matter who sends who how many bits? Because that's what peering is. No one gets to connect to a network, any network, for free. But if you have your own network, the company that owns another network might decide to hook up to yours for free, and you to his for free. Supposing, of course, that your networks are roughly equal. Why bill each other, if your bill to him will be about as much as his bill to you? Doing all that accounting costs money, so it's easier to just connect to each other for free. But this only works if both your networks are roughly equal. If some jackass walks up to you and says "I'm selling crap to your customers, let me hook up to your network for free!" you aren't going to agree to that. It'd be dumb. I really, really have trouble making sense of why so many people are ignorant of peering. It's going to be a really big problem too, because ignorant people are screaming for politicians to fix it, and neither the people nor the politicians have any clue at all. > If Comcast is asking Level3 for massive amounts of traffic Comcast is a network. It doesn't ask for traffic. It lets people who are connected to their network communicate with each other. If only one party connects to their network, it is impossible in a practical sense to facilitate communication between the two. Comcast doesn't guarantee connectivity to any specific host. It is a best effort service. > Comcast just needs to admit their equipment simply isn't up to the task of servicing their own customers, A kernel of truth in a turd of mistruths. Yes, I suspect this too. But it's not their equipment... that stuff gets switched out every few years. It's their network itself. HFC isn't sufficient for a modern network. Also, there's no point in them admitting this. That helps them not at all. And, since they're familiar with all the numbers, I also suspect that they know they can't afford to build a modern network.
- nsxwolf 12y ago> If some jackass walks up to you and says "I'm selling crap to your customers, let me hook up to your network for free!" you aren't going to agree to that. It'd be dumb. But as the ISP, aren't you billing your customers for that usage? Does it matter where the bits are coming from?
- backprojection 12y agoI'm not sure you've addressed eridius'a comments. I understand what you're saying about peering, but I think his/her point is that ISP customers pay ISPs not to care about peering. I think that's generally the point that neutrality activists make, that in large par the internet works because users have equal access to any network, regardless of the asymmetry inherent to that access, and that users are willing to pay for the cost of that asymmetry. If Comcast needs more money to properly connect it's users to Netflix, then that's fine, charge me more money. I'll gladly pay directly for real infrastructure upgrades. But forcing that revenue to go through Netflix first, you're fundamentally changing a key feature of the Internet. The fact that these issues go away if there is no asymmetry (peering) doesn't seem so relevant.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago> I understand what you're saying about peering, but I think his/her point is that ISP customers pay ISPs not to care about peering. Nothing in their contract with Comcast suggests that they've somehow bought "the right not to care about or understand peering". So if they think they've bought that, then the problem really is one of "stupid customers". Do you know that I absolutely loathe Comcast? I hate coming off like I'm defending them. I want the company abolished, its assets sold off at auction, its shareholders prohibited from ever investing in shares again, its executives sent to prison to rot for the rest of their lives. There are many bad things about Comcast. We don't need to make up lies about them. > If Comcast needs more money to properly connect it's users to Netflix, then that's fine, charge me more money. Then they're hit with accusations of violating network neutrality (if they only charge Netflix users), or of price-gouging if they charge everyone. This was already taken off the table by the same people who are rabble-rousing everyone. > But forcing that revenue to go through Netflix first, you're fundamentally changing a key feature of the Internet. By not forcing it, you're changing a key feature of the internet: settlement-free peering. This is why my original, top comment explains how things have changed and peering may not work anymore. It's impossible to come to a resolution where all parties feel as if they've been treated fairly. And that's a much bigger problem than anything anyone else is talking about. It's a problem that won't go away if we ignore it.