9 ms·
There is an interesting unbalance because Comcast has so much leverage by owning the last mile, they can push around Tier 1 providers. I'd like to fix that, mos
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
There is an interesting unbalance because Comcast has so much leverage by owning the last mile, they can push around Tier 1 providers. I'd like to fix that, mostly by creating a public policy around municipally owned Layer 1 infrastructure between customers in their cities and a city exchange building. Conceptually it would be no different than the city owning the sewers and outsourcing the water treatment plant to a contractor (or two). Creating a new "ISP" would involve installing equipment in the City Exchange(s), providing compatible customer premises equipment to subscribers, and then patching their 'port' at the City Exchange to the ISP's gear.
Its going to be a long conversation :-)
- seabee 13y agoSounds like the situation in the UK which largely works quite well.
- exelius 13y agoThis is how it should probably be done if we were starting from scratch. A system like the one you describe would cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $300-500 billion; which isn't completely insane as far as national infrastructure projects go. The problem is that we're not starting from scratch. It's a lot harder for the government to justify that expense when there are a number of viable privately-owned alternatives. Or to put it another way: if you had $500 billion to spend and you had to choose between overhauling the nation's education system (which desperately needs it) and providing better Internet access to people, which would you choose? Furthermore, do you trust your city to properly maintain said infrastructure? Because I sure as hell don't. All I have to do is look at the pothole-strewn roads outside my house to know that. Fiber optics are awesome now; but what happens in 10 years when we need a new type of quantum fiber made from carbon nanotubes to go faster? Will the cities be able to make the investments? I have my doubts given the overall poor state of municipal infrastructure around the country for things like water and sewage. The system we have now is far from perfect, but we're going to need to figure out how to make something work within the confines of what we have today: a privately owned and operated physical infrastructure controlled by a small number of companies. How do we craft regulation such that those companies are more profitable when they do what we want them to do?
- alex_doom 13y ago> if you had $500 billion to spend and you had to choose between overhauling the nation's education system (which desperately needs it) and providing better Internet access to people, which would you choose? They'll choose D. Build a new sportsball arena
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- swimfar 13y agoThat would be enough money for 500-1000 large stadiums. Citi Field in New York: $900 million Allianz Arena in Munich: 340€ million
- zokier 13y ago> The problem is that we're not starting from scratch But actually we did have an opportunity to reboot last-mile networks from scratch, because FTTx is essentially all-new network.
- rosser 13y agoAnd FTTx could be done at considerably lower cost, if we simply had the will to do it, and the patience to leverage existing work. For example, last week, they were tearing up the street in front of my building to put in new sewer lines. I don't even want to speculate what that might have cost. But now that the work is done, to lay fibre, they'll have to do it again. If, instead, they'd said, "Well, while we're here, let's just drop some conduit for fibre", and continued to do that going forward, a national FTTx last-mile infrastructure would cost considerably less. It wouldn't be free, of course. It's not merely "[dropping] some conduit", and there are plenty of places where they'd probably have to tear up the streets just for this purpose anyway. But, if every time we tore up the street for unrelated work, we leveraged that to put in place the FTTx-relevant things we'd also need to tear up the street for, we'd be so much closer, and at so much lower a cost...
- 13y ago
- neeravkumar 13y agoSo, like Singapore? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axia_NetMedia#Singapore_-_SingTel_joint_venture_in_OpenNet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axia_NetMedia#Singapore_-_SingT...
- nostrademons 13y agoIIUC that's similar to how the electricity grid works in Texas - the last mile is public, but then there are dozens of power companies that contract and subcontract to supply the actual juice. It is, reportedly, a disaster. You get small new companies popping up all the time and dying through mergers and acquisitions. Some own just a single power plant, some own nothing physical at all and are just a reseller to handle billing & arbitrage or broker cost differences. If there's a problem theres's nobody to call and nobody whose responsibility is fixing it. Consumers are left in the lurch whenever there's a merger or acquisition, and the company they pay their bills to usually bears little resemblance to who they initially signed up with. (Come to think of it, before the wave of banking consolidation in the mid-2000s, this also described the banking situation in New England. My college bank account went from Bank of the West to BankNorth to TD BankNorth in the time it took me to graduate, and my credit card went from BankNorth to TD BankNorth to FIA Card Services to Bank of America in the 3 years I stayed in Massachusetts after graduation.) IMHO the root problem is that consumers have no leverage because there are millions of them and none own any of the means of production, and so I'm more bullish on new technologies like mesh networking as a way of solving the problem.
- aggronn 13y agoLocal utility companies and cable companies typically have terrible reputations across the board. I'd rather have competition and bad customer service/experience than no competition and bad customer service/experience.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- unexpected 13y agoA lot of this is not true. I live in Texas, and electricity is not a disaster. You can choose from a variety of rates and providers (you can visit powertochoose.org to see the site), but the local electric utility provider (the company that used to have the monopoly) is the guy you call when electricity goes out. In the D/FW area, that's Oncor (and is for most of Texas).
- mobiplayer 13y agoI think that is exactly what it was done in Viladecans, Barcelona: http://www.diba.cat/web/ri/newsletter_bcn_int_reg/-/butlletidigital/detallIndex/TERRP_ENG/4/27655?controlPanelCategory=portlet_BoletinPrensa_WAR_BoletinPrensaportlet http://www.diba.cat/web/ri/newsletter_bcn_int_reg/-/butlleti... But the telcos aren't going to like it: http://www.telecompaper.com/news/telefonica-urges-viladecans-ftth-deployment-suspension--789285 http://www.telecompaper.com/news/telefonica-urges-viladecans...
- jamescun 13y agoThis is similar to what we have in the UK. The organisation responsible for last mile connections is Openreach, and for all its failings, we in the UK are served rather well by the setup. I have the option of six ISPs, 4 national and 2 local. The issue with Openreach is the odd situation it has found itself in after several government reshuffles and countless legislation; leaving it under BT Group's umbrella but accountable to the government regulator Ofcom. As such the network has waned and become difficult to upgrade.
- Alphasite_ 13y agoI'd hardly say it's difficult to upgrade, they've been rolling out network upgrades for the last decade, starting with the 21cn network, then fttc and persumably ftth as an eventual goal.
- jamescun 13y agoThey are rolling out FTTC, however slowly, and there was a lot of fighting, bureaucracy and political bargaining to do so; in addition to ruling out widespread FTTH rollout (only available to new-builds and selected rural areas).
- ctz 13y ago> The organisation responsible for last mile connections is Openreach About 30% of UK homes are also served by ex-Telewest/NTL/Virgin Media cable. The last mile arrangements for that are almost identical to how AIUI things work in the US: the whole line from your door to the internet is owned and operated by one company, and there is no LLU-like competition.
- josephlord 13y agoYes but the key difference is the word "also". Those 30% have an additional choice over the services using OpenReach final mile connections. In the US many people only have the one service that owns the cable and the service.
- sadris 13y agoMunicipal governments should threaten to regulate last-mile ISPs like power companies unless they agree to let competitors use their cables. Virginia requires that competing power companies be allowed to use power lines, why not fiber as well?
- edraferi 13y agoAbsolutely. Isn't this what the FCC's Title II / common carrier provisions are for? my understanding is that's what happened to make long distance affordable: the maintainers of the copper had to allow other forms to connect to customers.
- yaddayadda 13y agoUtah already has something like this called UTOPIA (http://www.utopianet.org/about-utopia/ http://www.utopianet.org/about-utopia/). The participating cities run fiber optic lines. The city pays for the fiber optic lines (lots and lots and lots of political controversy about this!) then subscribers can pick and choose what services and from which providers they want. I'm in a participating city and love it! Unfortunately politics, both the governmental and the organizational types, are constantly threatening the viability of UTOPIA (http://www.utopianet.org/press/ http://www.utopianet.org/press/). >UTOPIA (Utah Telecommunication Open Infrastructure Agency) is not an Internet service provider. UTOPIA operates on an open access model, which means we own and manage the infrastructure, but lease the lines to private Internet Service Providers, who then deliver services to subscribers. This allows you to choose the provider that best meets your needs. edit: added press link
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThat is pretty awesome, I've sent them email to see if we can use some of the work they have done in this space.
- dvanduzer 13y agoMy work email archive from a decade ago is hard to search, but when I sent a similar email, I got back a reference to a study of broadband in Japan (?) about early adopters in fiber-to-the-curb communities... They essentially found that when you installed a network like this in a neighborhood, the economic growth in that neighborhood almost immediately changed trajectory (upward) relative to similar communities without these networks.
- yaddayadda 13y agoWhen I bought my house, one of my absolute requirements was that the house be in a UTOPIA city. If I were a business owner, I would have the same requirement.
- femto 13y agoThat sounds like a similar model to Australia's endangered National Broadband Network. The government owned NBNCo lays the fibres to customers' homes, then ISPs lease bandwidth to service their customers. It seems to be facing the same issues that you describe, with some politicians being unable to stomach publicly owned infrastructure.
- smegel 13y agoCome to Australia and revel in the NBN. Oh wait...
- elithrar 13y ago> by creating a public policy around municipally owned Layer 1 infrastructure between customers in their cities and a city exchange building. Conceptually it would be no different than the city owning the sewers and outsourcing the water treatment plant to a contractor (or two). Creating a new "ISP" would involve installing equipment in the City Exchange(s), providing compatible customer premises equipment to subscribers, and then patching their 'port' at the City Exchange to the ISP's gear. This is precisely what we're attempting to do in Australia with the National Broadband Network—with the delays, technical changes and cost estimating issues you'd expect from a project that's survived across two federal governments. NBNCo installs the fibre, the termination devices, the optical splitters, and brings it back to a POI where ISPs then bring in their own transit or purchase backhaul capacity from NBNCo (as needed). It also, in my view, makes the critical process of engaging local councils, utilities, and ripping up roads, footpaths and driveways much more 'palatable' to the average householder, because it's seen as a public infrastructure project and not as a private organisation expanding their 'own' reach (even if it would achieve the same end goal).
- dwd 13y ago"Survived" is not a good description for gutting its potential capacity by 90% by switching from FTTP to FTTN. Looks like it will also cost more in the end once you factor in the lease costs for Testra's existing network. Guess that doesn't appear in this governments' books and they can kick the can (pun intended) down the road.
- Angostura 13y agoSorry to be dense, but it is not quite clear to me how ownership of the last mile affords such leverage. It would seem that if you need to buy bandwidth for end users, you would be negotiating transit like anyone else - I'm clearly missing something.
- A1kmm 13y agoPay us $x to connect our network to Y network to your Z network, our our millions of Y users won't have access to customers on your Z network, and that will make the Z network look bad to your customers. Of course, it goes the other way - Y looks bad because they can't get to Z's customers - but I suspect the commercial customers on Z might be more likely to ditch Z rather than the end users (who probably don't understand the situation) ditching Y.
- pdonis 13y ago> It would seem that if you need to buy bandwidth for end users, you would be negotiating transit like anyone else It would sure seem that way, but the recent Comcast-Netflix deal shows that it isn't necessarily that way; big ISPs can exert enough pressure on content distributors to get the distributors to effectively pay the transit costs.
- vidarh 13y agoInternet peering has been a giant game of chicken ever since commercial connections were allowed.
- blueskin_ 13y agoThis is close to what Britain has. The last mile infrastructure is owned by BT, who used to be a US-style monopoly, and now they have to give access to their infrastructure to the other ISPs. Unfortunately, quality is restricted by the fees BT charge being too high, and their general woeful underinvestment into much of their network. Having the last mile infrastructure be nationally owned would be a far better idea.
- mtourne 13y agoExactly what happened in France circa 2000. France Telecom the national operator was forced to maintain the last mile and open to other ISP at the city exchange. This has allowed newcomers like Free (Free ISP), to disrupt the high speed internet market both in costs and speeds. It seems that telecom is one area where laissez-faire leads to less competition, and worse offers for potential customers.
- vidarh 13y agoThis is the case in most EU countries, due to EU regulation of the telecoms sector. Ironically, it is a result of deregulation of the sector, from a situation where most EU countries previously had a single government-owned operator. As part of the de-regulation, to ensure the former public telcos did not get a stranglehold, a long range of rules were put in place to guarantee competitors access to the existing subscriber base.
- feld 13y agoMadison, WI sort of has this. It's called the MUFN network. http://www.mufn.org http://www.mufn.org The different ISPs etc in the city can sign contracts with the city and get access to the MUFN fiber network. The city owns the main fiber network and does repair/maintenance. The city can take ownership of any lateral you build where the conduit is 3" or more if they desire. Also, they can take it if they decide to use it to hook up traffic signals, etc. It's much more complicated than I've detailed but it's really a partnership with the city and ultimately they can take ownership of any fiber you build off it if it would benefit the city as a whole, while still allowing you access of course.