4 ms·
What If We Admitted to Children That Sex Is About Pleasure?
- Zelphyr 13y agoI was going to say that I'm going to read this every day until its time to talk to my kids about sex. Then I realized; that time is probably now.
- clockworkelf 13y agoWhy do children even need sex education? It just sexualizes them.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIt will be interesting to see how her son turns out. I would worry that he would start telling some friend about how sex was all about being fun without knowing that the person was being abused by a step parent. Or figure out that sometimes his penis wanted to have sex with people who really weren't in the same state of mind. It isn't just about understanding the mechanics, its understanding that sex is wired into your brain in a place that isn't entirely rational, and because of that, and because of the re-wiring that goes on during puberty, acting on incomplete information can get you into difficult situations.
- LyndsySimon 13y ago> acting on incomplete information can get you into difficult situations. Isn't that a strong argument to be open and honest when discussing it?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoYes, but you can't control how open and honest all conversations can be. In the article her son has clearly engaged with everyone like he engages with his mother, and that has been surprising to some folks, and it will be damaging to some folks if he keeps it up. What is worse is he won't understand the damage initially.
- LyndsySimon 13y agoNo, I can't control those conversations. I also don't see it as reasonable to limit my child's knowledge on a subject merely because someone else might make an opposing decision and take offense. Kids are going to be frank when talking about any topic amongst themselves. I would rather my child be overheard telling a peer about how babies are made and how STDs are passed, than have her believe that douching with Coca-Cola after sex will prevent pregnancy. I also strongly disagree that speaking truth in such discussions can ever be "damaging". Can you provide an example?
- LyndsySimon 13y agoSex is just like any other politically-charged topic. I'll answer any question my daughter has, but I also make sure she knows that other people don't treat it the same as we do, and that she probably shouldn't talk about it with people outside our family until she's a little older and aware of how other people perceive the world.
- wyager 13y agoThere are two things that can almost completely subvert the rational capabilities of your average human; sex, and children. The effect compounds when those two topics come up at the same time.
- ars 13y agoIf you tell kids something they want to try it. So tell them this if you are OK with them trying it, if not then don't.
- LyndsySimon 13y agoFollowing your premise, you should also not tell children that driving a car recklessly can harm them, or that firearms are dangerous if improperly handled, or that the stovetop can burn them, or that they should look ways before crossing the street... Seriously. Tell your children about the positive and negative consequences of actions, sex included. Obviously it's pleasurable. Obviously it's procreative. It's also emotionally dangerous to have sex with someone for whom you don't have a solid relationship, because human beings are wired so that the act of sex creates strongly emotional attachment to your partner. I see my job as a parent to prepare my children to be an adult. Adults make decisions about risky behaviors, and I want to do everything possible to make sure my children have the knowledge necessary to make good decisions when the time comes - no matter what the topic is.
- ars 13y agoYour comparisons are about telling kids certain things are bad, but the premise in this article is about telling kids it's good. It's not a valid comparison. You then compromised by saying to tell them the bad things, but that's not what the article says. And BTW telling them "emotionally dangerous" is impossible - they just won't get it. > I see my job as a parent to prepare my children to be an adult. Certainly, but there is no need to tell them about it early, as the kid in the article was. Wait until this is something they physically are able to do, then tell them honestly.
- mercer 13y agoI'd disagree. I, and others I've talked to, started being intensely curious about sex at the age of eight, well before I could reproduce. I'm very happy that my parents raised me in such a way that I felt comfortable asking about sex early on, and having them tell me about the good (and the bad) of sex.
- ChuckFrank 13y agoBut it's not just about pleasure. It's about love, and intimacy, and it's about maturity and self respect. It's about procreation and biology. I agree that we should stop talking about it just as mechanics. I never have. But it's about much more than pleasure, and kids are surprisingly mature enough to understand that if you give them the chance. The best piece of advice that I read was to encourage children to wait to have sex until the time that their bodies had finished growing. Then, when their bodies are full grown, they can have safe and protected sex. I think this is the discussion that we should be having - in schools, in churches, and at home.
- notdonspaulding 13y agoWhy should churches should base their position on adolescent sexuality on the time "that their bodies [have] finished growing"? What churches are you talking about and what's the tie between your views and theirs?
- mercer 13y agoI'm (honestly) curious how exactly you'd defined 'finished growing'. Because from my perspective that is anywhere between 'physically capable of having and enjoying sex' and 'hormonal balance and a mostly-developed mind'. Which could be anywhere between twelve and twenty-something. In my social circles many people started having sex around the age of fifteen, but some didn't have sex until their early twenties. I wasn't particularly interested in girls until my late teens, but I started exploring my sexuality at the age of eight.
- ChuckFrank 13y agoI think the self-empowerment component of the concept is potentially the most compelling part of the suggestion. Though like you say, it may vary tremendously between individuals. Still it's a good starting point for discussion - when do we stop growing?
- notdonspaulding 13y agoFrom the article: The mate explained that adults stupidly think that if you tell children the truth about sex, they’ll have sex earlier than they really should. He added that the evidence indicates otherwise. Evidence? Hopefully "the mate" had some data to back up his claims. Even so, surely the evidence must only apply to people who agree on what "the truth about sex" is, and how "early they really should" have sex.
- carsongross 13y ago“The first two facts which a healthy boy or girl feels about sex are these: first that it is beautiful and then that it is dangerous.” --GCK
- michaelsbradley 13y agoSex is about but pleasure, but also so much more. See John Paul II's Theology of the Body: http://www.ewtn.com/library/papaldoc/jp2tbind.htm http://www.ewtn.com/library/papaldoc/jp2tbind.htm Yes, this information should be lovingly and patiently shared with young persons, even (and especially) when it challenges us as adults and requires us to grow in maturity and understanding.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]