3 ms·
So it's better to let them spend a bunch of time learning something that's potentially outdated? I think it depends entirely on the material and how long it's
by davidw 13y ago
So it's better to let them spend a bunch of time learning something that's potentially outdated?
I think it depends entirely on the material and how long it's likely to be valid for. Basic principles of human nature, for instance, are likely to not change a bunch from one day to the next (although research might reveal new views on them). How to install mod_perl on Apache in order to create actual dynamic web sites... Perhaps that's best left to the late 90ies.
- grayclhn 13y agoI think that it's implicit that you're supposed to keep the articles up to date.
- jamesbritt 13y agoI think that it's implicit that you're supposed to keep the articles up to date. OK, but then why not then update the date of the article? Every so often I find myself reading something and start to wonder if it's still current. It's frustrating to not then find that date the article was written or last updated. Basically, I don't see a downside for including a date, but there are assorted pitfalls for the reader if omitted.
- grayclhn 13y agoThe downside addressed by the parent is that an article dated "2012" will be discounted by many potential readers, even if all of the information is still current. For something where specific versions or dates matter, nothing about the article suggests that you not address it in the "post." If a configuration file changed in April, 2013 then you should write about how it changed and how to deal with the different versions. And if you're writing about something specific to Python 3, you should be specific about that restriction. But I don't see how dating the article as "August 17th, 2013" is going to effectively communicate either of those nuances. The article date is at best an imperfect proxy for whether the information is current. And the OP and parent are claiming that prominently displaying the date (and other "blogging artifacts") cause potential readers to discount the information more than they should. I don't know whether the argument is universally true, but it's plausible.
- rthomas6 13y agoI think it depends on how generally the [whatever] is written. I'm working through SICP right now and learning all kinds of concepts 100% relevant to today, because the textbook was written to convey general ideas instead of their specific implementation. And that book was written in the '80s, which is practically forever ago in the CS world.