3 ms·
But why would a data provider ("ISP") do that? Do they want to have the ISP part of their business de-valued? Or at least not increase in value as fast? I real
by bediger4000 13y ago
But why would a data provider ("ISP") do that? Do they want to have the ISP part of their business de-valued? Or at least not increase in value as fast?
I realize that you can't say definitively that "Every new valuable service is going to increase customer data use" but that's pretty close. Web pages have gotten bigger (and more diffuse) with time. What we want from web services has changed over time, basically using more data as time increases.
If Comcast et al conditions customers to use less data, then all they're doing is putting brakes on change. They're trying to limit what new services can provide by making those services less acceptable.
So, a double whammy: monopoly rents increase, and there's less chance of a disruption to the incumbents in the marketplace.
- wmf 13y agoIf you're selling "unlimited" service for a fixed price, of course you want to encourage customers to use less. ISPs don't care about new services; they're already getting as much money as their customers are willing to pay so increased profit must come from reducing costs.
- bediger4000 13y agoI'd buy that, except that I already gave an example where a pattern of using broadband service below a data cap causes more trouble than 2x of 3x over the cap with another pattern. The only way that a data cap could possibly reduce costs is to actually reduce overall usage enough so that Comcast (or whichever ISP) can cut physical hardware and the personnel to service it. Preventing future increases by conditioning consumers seems like a bad bet if you want to reduce costs now.
- wmf 13y agoCaps are definitely a crude tool, but given that most usage is going to be during peak hours anyway, lower overall usage usually translates to lower peak usage. And yes, when I talk about reducing costs I really mean reducing the rate of increase of bandwidth demand relative to the rate of decrease of bandwidth cost due to Moore's Law.