4 ms·
What I find amazing about Wolfram Alpha is that _despite_ sitting down with a pad of paper, and a spare 30 minutes, I'm _still_ unable to get most of my _comple
by ghshephard 17y ago
What I find amazing about Wolfram Alpha is that _despite_ sitting down with a pad of paper, and a spare 30 minutes, I'm _still_ unable to get most of my _completely domain relevant_ queries answered by it.
For example - I want a graph of the price of gold versus the price of silver over time. This should be _precisely_ what Wolfram Alpha is good at. In the Demo they even show the ability of Wolfram Alpha to show the price of gold.
The following does not work:
Price of Gold versus Price of Silver
Price of Gold Divided by Price of Silver
Silver Futures Divided by Price of Silver
NYMEX:SI versus NYMEX:GC
NYMEX:SI NYMEX:GC
Graph Price of Gold
Graph Price of Gold Over Time
Now, switch to google, and type in
Price of Gold
and the first hit is: "http://goldprice.org/live-gold-price.html http://goldprice.org/live-gold-price.html
And 10 seconds later I have an overlayed Price of Gold/Silver Chart.
If Google is able to go Head-Head with Wolfram alpha, in the Wolfram Alpha _domain_ - then it's got a long time to go before it's a query engine of choice for people.
But - I admire them for their perseverance, and it will be interesting to see how it evolves over the next few years - the good news is that the barrier to entry is likely to be insanely high by the time they finally get it working...
- anigbrowl 17y agogold price history vs silver price history ...but absent your list of what didn't work, I'd probably have given up before guessing this. It is one of the very frustrating things about alpha, yes. I kind of agree with the suggestion below that it might be better to browse than search. It's truly aggravating to know that what you want is in their curated data set but not to have a clear unambiguous way to call it up.
- grandinj 17y agoMaybe that's because the answer to the question you're asking is NaN. What you actually mean is that you want a plot of the price of gold and the price of silver vs time. For which the query is: gold and silver price history Took me about 5 minutes of playing around.
- apotheon 17y ago. . . which still seems to be about 4:50 longer than it takes with Google.
- apotheon 17y ago> the good news is that the barrier to entry is likely to be insanely high by the time they finally get it working... . . . and the bad news is that the company is surely still going to try to claim copyright on results. Hell, by then it'll probably have graduated to trying to claim patents on results.