7 ms·
Investors must recognize what ‘this time it’s different’ really means
- lotsofmangos 13y agoRates are at a 300 year low apparently so I'd guess they are going to rise. Now, I have nothing to do with trading and don't own any property, so presumably I'm the shoeshine boy.
- Lost_BiomedE 13y agoIf you see the USD under 70, be prepared for this time is different, for real. Banks have huge reserves right now, about 6x historical norm, and are making money in the market due to the low rate they get. When rates rise, that avenue is not as lucrative. They will lend. Each dollar lent has a 10x multiplier on it. They could introduce up to 120% GDP into the money supply. Just one thing to watch these days.
- amykyta 13y agoI am not sure what you're talking about. What is the level of 70 for USD? Also, through what mechanism do you think rate will rise (real or nominal)? It'll have to be with a nudge from the FOMC which implements the monetary policy by buying/selling treasuries from/to the banks. As rates rise, some of those reserves banks have now will get absorbed by the FOMC. Additionally, just because banks have money to lend doesn't mean they're going to throw caution and credit concerns to the wind and start lending again.
- Lost_BiomedE 13y ago- What is the level of 70 for USD? US Dollar index: http://www.fxstreet.com/rates-charts/usdollar-index/ http://www.fxstreet.com/rates-charts/usdollar-index/ - Also, through what mechanism do you think rate will rise (real or nominal)? It'll have to be with a nudge from the FOMC which implements the monetary policy by buying/selling treasuries from/to the banks. Yes, the Fed will ultimately raise rates, just as Bullard has signaled: "...he repeated his own expectation that rates will likely need to rise by the end of the first quarter of next year, as inflation recovers to its desired target. That is several months ahead of the summer rate rise many investors now expect." http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/05/16/us-usa-fed-bullard-idUSBREA4F0I520140516 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/05/16/us-usa-fed-bullard... - Additionally, just because banks have money to lend doesn't mean they're going to throw caution and credit concerns to the wind and start lending again. Watch them throw caution and credit concerns to the wind. You will have plenty of time to see that they are doing this before taking an action. I do not have any doubts based on how they have behaved in the past, are behaving now, and how they are encouraged to do so.
- fauigerzigerk 13y ago>Watch them throw caution and credit concerns to the wind Banks are under very close scrutiny right now and will be for many years to come. I doubt very much that the next bubble will get inflated exactly where the last one popped.
- Lost_BiomedE 13y agoOne of the big reasons we have funneled money to the banks was to get them to lend. When they start, it will be welcomed with open arms.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoIt would be welcomed if they lend to businesses that invest. But if consumer debt starts rising significantly you can be quite sure that it won't be long until regulators intervene. The question is how you get businesses to invest when there is no one who can buy more stuff. This is going to be a slow economy for a very long time.
- dredmorbius 13y agoIf you're looking at the economy and financial returns, there are a number of factors other than strictly cyclical characteristics of stock market and financial vehicle returns to consider. Pardon the self-link spam, but this is a topic of some interest to me: There's the Shift Index by Deloitte's Center for the Edge, which shows a long-term secular decline in return on invested capital (ROIC) from 1965 to 2009 by 75%. It's fallen from 6.2% to 1.3%, and is on track to negative returns in a little over a decade. http://redd.it/1y3z3n http://redd.it/1y3z3n There's the relationship of GDP growth to the price of oil (WTI), as portrayed in this FRED graphic from 1945 - 2012: http://i.imgur.com/hfBRw9f.png http://i.imgur.com/hfBRw9f.png Prior to 1974, WTI tracked a very predictable 2.5% price trend. This was the period during which the TRC, Texas Railroad Commission, effectively set the price for oil through extraction (production) quotas. In March of 1971, the TRC lifted those quotas, effectively removing any limits on extraction rates. US oil extraction had peaked. 1971 is the watershed. Oil prices never resume their previous level of stability, and GDP cycles become more random and volatile. Afterward, oil prices are often higher (much of the 1970s and 2000s), sometimes lower (1984 - 1999), but always volatile. The regularity of GDP cyclical trends is lost. http://redd.it/1tz6y2 http://redd.it/1tz6y2 Though there have been financial panics before, the period from 1929 - 2007 is exceptionally notable for its lack of any widespread panics. There were a few edgy times -- going off Bretton-Woods in 1971, the 1987 stock market crash, the Asian currency crises of the 1990s, but central banks held the show together until 2008 and the fall of Lehman Brothers. Observers such as Michael Lewis, particularly in The Big Short, have commented on the financial restructuring that's sustained paper profits while real wealth growth is questionable. The YC and HN crowd might want to look at where all that magic money making Rails coders so much more valuable than janitors comes from, and how long the music will play.
- amykyta 13y agoI think you mean Michael Lewis. As for the price of oil and GDP cycles. I am not sure I understand your point. Can you please elaborate? First world economies are more based around services than industrial production at this point, so while oil is still a hugely important commodity, there have clearly been structural changes in what comprises world GDP.
- amykyta 13y agoPeople don't seem to be reading the actual story posted so let me TLDR it: Barry Ritholtz has been around and has seen a cycle or two. The economic drivers change but fear and greed still drives the 'melt-ups' and 'melt-downs'. Analyze the market (and what the proper valuation is) in the context of where the economy is now and where it's coming from. Don't dogmatically avoid tech stocks because their valuation multiples are higher than you've been targeting for the last 30 years. Don't buy things just because everyone else is doing it and is making quick paper profits from it. The old saying of "Bulls make money, bears make money, pigs get slaughtered." is relevant.
- jqm 13y agoPredicting the economy is like predicting the weather. Sure, you can get the short term right very often, but longer term the number of factors and the relationships between them becomes very complex. I would guess "this time it really is different" with supporting reasons has been sung plenty of times before. I'm not convinced. War, plague, drought, social unrest... these things come along and their effects are far reaching. To say nothing of financial disasters (maybe those who control the levers have the machine figured out... then again, maybe not. I don't know). In the long long term yes... I would guess technology is going to be important and there will be profits. Shorter- long term.... it does seem a bit frothy right now. Short-Short term? Ride the trend until it ends. Pullbacks happen. Sometimes they are bigger, sometimes smaller. They serve an important function. To separate what is important and deserving of capital from that which isn't. Just don't believe they won't happen because yes... they will. That is never different.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI'd actually argue almost entirely the opposite. Near-term economic forecasting is difficult (though there may be some accuracy in the very near term). Long-term, you can accurately forecast economic trends based on overall resource availability. See the Limits to Growth baseline model.
- jqm 13y agoResource availability is a very important component to economic growth. But I might point out... they had more resources than we do now in the 1700's. So there are other components. Technology being one of them. Can anyone predict what we will be able to do in 50 or 100 or 200 years? Or what else might happen between now and then?
- dredmorbius 13y agoGregory Clarke's an economic historian at UC Davis. Among his online lectures is an interesting bit on why the Industrial Revolution was delayed 100,000 years: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aalpFYIdqEo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aalpFYIdqEo Among factors you might want to consider: Britain is built on coal. It was washing up on the beaches (the early name for it was "seacoal"). Coal, oil, and gas were known to the ancients. What they lacked was a decent means to haul it any distance. Easier to grow your own hydrocarbons locally than dig them out of some smelly pit a few hundred, or thousand, miles away. So unless you happened to sit right next to a coal pit, tar seep, oil well, or gas jet, you burned wood. England turned to coal as it was burning through its forests. We've been prospecting for other resources. We've got a pretty good idea of what there is, and an even better idea of what there isn't. Joseph Tainter writes on collapse and complexity. Among his points: societies don't adopt complexity unless there's a compelling need (and benefit). It's better to survive at a simple level, much of the time. You'll even see this today in IT. And by your own statement: we've fewer resources now than humanity had in the 1700s, by virtue of burning our way through them.
- zhte415 13y agoFor anyone that hasn't read it, I highly recommend 'Irrational Exuberance' by Robert Schiller, a professor at Yale which covers the theme 'This time its different' in depth, in a long term context covering around 200 years of economic data, in particular regarding herding of investors and thought (as sheep herd, then scatter, then herd). One of the interesting observations of the book is that there has been a recession every 10 years for as far back as the data covers (100+ years) +-2 years of the end of each decade. A link to the site, with data sets the book covers freely downloadable: http://irrationalexuberance.com/ http://irrationalexuberance.com/
- vishnugupta 13y agoAnd as an addendum, I highly recommend "Thinking, Fast and Slow" by Daniel Kahneman. A huge take away for me from that book was that humans are very bad at predicting far into the future, especially when it comes to phenomenon that involve multiple feedback loops. Finance is a prime example of such a phenomenon where changes in policy, regulation, productivity and a host of other factors that influence financial markets, have their impact only several years down the road. Human mind is such that it impulsively reacts only to recent memory and uses it to extrapolate it to future. It is a fascinating read, one that got me hooked into the subject matter of human psychology and behavioral economics.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoI wish this book were required reading for politicians: This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly by Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff http://www.reinhartandrogoff.com/ http://www.reinhartandrogoff.com/ They take a MASSIVE dataset - 8 centuries of data across hundreds of governments - and find the same patterns repeating. Policy makers of different stripes make the same mistakes leading to the same crises, and - when the emergency comes - they try the same failed solutions their forebears tried, often with the indignant claim that "this time it's different!" Often, the solutions the policy makers are so apt to try just happen to be short-term band-aids, or kick-the-can-down-the-road ways to postpone the hard stuff, or ways to save face and let the next guy be caught holding the bag.
- potatosareok 13y agoSo I was thinking of picking up this book on your recommendation. However, the names seemed vaguely familiar to me already, which reminded me of the scandal where some grad student reran numbers from one of their papers, and found that Reinhart and Rogoff had made basic coding errors in Excel (I think Excel?) running the data (as well as cherrypicking data to some extent). When the data was processed correctly, it actually showed the opposite of what Reinhart and Rogoff had argued for. Since I obviously don't have time to fact check all the numbers in their book, and they have a demonstrated history of biased results, I think in the end I'll pass on the book. Just my 2 cents.
- NoPiece 13y agoIt is not true that the revised data showed the opposite of what Reinhard and Rogoff argues for. It just showed it to a much lesser degree. The New Yorker wrote a fair but critical analysis: http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/johncassidy/2013/04/the-rogoff-and-reinhart-controversy-a-summing-up.html http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/johncassidy/2013/04/th...
- BSousa 13y agoWas this the same data that was used by IMF and the rest to justify the push the austerity measures on the troubled economies in Europe? I remember there was a big backlash at the time when the numbers came to light but nothing changed anyway (maybe the save face issue above)