8 ms·
It's worth noting that Twitch partially became popular because it wasn't YouTube, and gamers could stream without content restrictions (e.g. copyright and regio
by minimaxir 13y ago
It's worth noting that Twitch partially became popular because it wasn't YouTube, and gamers could stream without content restrictions (e.g. copyright and region)
Miraculously, this could end up making YouTube comments even worse.
- jds375 13y agoWhile I do see this being an excellent acquisition for YouTube if true, I do agree. I don't see how YouTube could reconcile it's copyright stance with how Twitch fundamentally works.
- mikeleeorg 13y agoIF this is true, I would think a lot of due diligence and legal counsel was discussed before moving forward. Especially with a deal this size. And if that's the case, perhaps YouTube would be adopting Twitch's less restrictive copyright policies. Because otherwise, what else would YouTube get out of Twitch?
- Afforess 13y agoHa. Your naiveté is cute. This deal is all about buying out the competition. It's not about streaming. Youtube could have streaming if they wanted to, without the 1B.
- pas 13y agoYoutube has streaming. Also probably a bit different target audience and market. Plus, it's likely that they'll just make the sadfucked G+ a requirement and be done with it, no mucking with what works.
- free2rhyme214 13y agoExactly. It's about owning the market and removing a potential competitor who saps money from YouTube. It's a smart move for Google.
- azakai 13y agoAnd a bad move for the users.
- kevinwang 13y agoYoutube actually already has streaming, to further prove your point.
- chongli 13y agoIf people aren't able to continue streaming their favourite game on Twitch after the acquisition, they will go somewhere else and Youtube will have gained nothing from the deal. It makes absolutely zero sense to buy out a competitor just to drive all their users to a different competitor.
- alandarev 13y agoMicrosoft did this all the time to protect it's Office, and it worked. I do not think this is meaningless, not very efficient, but gigants can sacrifice efficiency if it helps save their primary revenue.
- mikeleeorg 13y agoI was thinking more of the market and audience of Twitch. Technology is not a barrier for Google/YouTube. And they could certainly vie for the Twitch audience with a similar product. But Twitch definitely has a head start. So whether it be for removing a competitor and/or entering a new market, my point is I think a company like Google would have considered copyright issues before doing something like this.
- Ygg2 13y agoMaybe. And maybe RIAA and MPAA would change their stance on DRM and abolish DMCA. And maybe Elephants will sprout rocket jets and fly into the dark side of Pluto.
- mihai_ionic 13y agoIt also doesn't fit their app store policy at all, particularly in light of the recent takedowns aimed at guides or utilities for PC games in absence of any copyright claims.
- thomasfortes 13y agoThis could backfire hard, if youtube try to enforce same restrictions to streamers as they enforce to youtube videos, a lot of famous streamers would just jump out to another alternatives like azubu for example.
- xbadxapple 13y agoAgreed. I'm interested to how they will implement copyright issues too. What I'm also worried about is design changes. YouTube had some poor decisions in this domain and if Twitch experiences stuff like this, it may turn to a rather unpleasant platform.
- ughee 13y agoAre you suggesting that thus far that Twitch somehow was exempt from copyright claims?!
- minimaxir 13y agoIt's much, much harder to exert copyright on live content, in contrast to YouTube's ContentID system. Twitch has taken down streams of unreleased games (which is fair because Twitch makes this rule very explicit), but that's still on an ad hoc basis.
- ughee 13y agoDon't see a YouTube ownership changing that, I assume it'll still be about live streaming.
- chilldream 13y agoLarge companies tend to err on the side of taking down more than they legally "have to". I know of YouTube videos that were taken down because of copyright claims that were outright false (that is, the entity making the claim didn't even have any rights to the material that was allegedly being infringed). There's a lot of room to be more lenient than YT and still on the right side of the law.
- azth 13y agoWell, looks like it's time to start another competitor :)
- pooper 13y agoOn a back of the napkin calculation, how much outgoing throughput would one need to be able to stream to ten clients directly on say 720p (~30 frames per second)? I was wondering if it would be possible to create a set up where people can stream from home without any third party in between. Is that even possible for larger audiences?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoA decent quality 1080p stream is around 2Mbps minimum. Your pipe needs to be able to sustain that times the number of clients.
- pooper 13y agoMy thought was to piggyback off of web rtc and other free software projects already available just to learn more about it. I'll be pretty happy to just get it working so two clients can watch a stream. I was already looking to learn something this summer so this should be a nice place to start. Thanks!
- keypusher 13y agoTwitch currently accounts for ~1.5% of all U.S. bandwidth.
- pooper 13y agoSlightly off topic but If I remember right, about a question of viability someone at Justin.tv (I guess now twitch) said (this is about four years ago) that playing like a thirty second ad clip can more than cover their operational cost of streaming for an hour. I guess what I wanted to hear from that was that streaming is cheap. Scale probably matters a lot though.
- 13y ago
- InclinedPlane 13y agoTo clarify, it's not as though Twitch is a magical world free from copyright restrictions. However, youtube's copyright enforcement system is extremely aggressive, overzealous, and a hassle for content creators to deal with. Youtube had a huge flood of takedowns for let's play videos due to mostly bureaucratic reasons rather than actual, legitimate copyright violations, for example. And that is what people are avoiding.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- icehawk219 13y agoI think it's important to take notice that Twitch's recent problems (the buffering problem, chat problems, the delay in general) are problems with their ability to cater to the big tournaments which causes me to really not be all that surprised if this turns out to be true. The ways they've handled the tournaments have really disillusioned many streamers. I don't know if there's any better way for them to have dealt with the scaling problems they faced as I can only imagine the work that must go into supporting a live stream, with real time chat, that has 100k+ viewers (and for some of the bigger tournaments that's a small number). Something like a 30s+ delay in the stream makes it very difficult to have real interactions between the streamer and the viewers which is particularly bad for smaller streams. For the big guys it doesn't matter as much since their interaction is less back-and-forth and more broadcaster in style and there's absolutely no interaction with the tournaments. The point is that if this is true it really doesn't surprise me at all. And whether or not it is I think there's definitely an opening for some serious competition to Twitch by making a service that is essentially an exact copy but from a business focus standpoint caters more towards the small-to-medium sized streamer and their audience.
- kevingadd 13y agoBuffering and delays got worse with the launch of PS4 streaming, they're not just due to tournaments. It is true that tournaments are a 'worst case' for them.
- onewaystreet 13y agoMany of the popular streamers on Twitch are homegrown. Their success can be directly attributed to the Twitch ecosystem. They would likely take a big hit if they switched platforms.
- scawe 13y agoPretty sure the delay in general is due to them moving to a new system about a year or so ago.
- baldfat 13y agoIt was to fix stuttering. Specifically in Europe.
- einrealist 13y agoI agree. I hope, YouTube does not change much on the surface. Streamers and viewers are like deer in the night. A flash like integration into Google Accounts would most likely scare them away. I'm sceptical.
- onewaystreet 13y agoYouTube recently launched a new streaming platform. I don't think it has those restrictions anymore. Their problem has been that they haven't been able to compete with Twitch's community.
- lclarkmichalek 13y agoCommunity is a strong word for that shit hole GreyFaceGreyFace
- leccine 13y agoFirst of all, you need Google+ in order to use Youtube (very hard without it) while people just want to watch streams, they don't care about failed social networks. This is why twitch was great.
- Cthulhu_ 13y agoIIRC (but correct me if I'm wrong), Youtube works just fine without a login; 18+ content, rating and commenting won't work though.
- k00pa 13y agoWell its possible, but its certainly not easy. It asks you to merge your G+ account all the time and is generally just annoying. I ended up creating 3 pages in g+ for my channel that I don't even use, when trying to avoid G+ Youtube integration. Then I just gave up and merged them.
- shanelja 13y agoI agree. I play an MMORPG called Runescape which has millions of players, I've been playing it since I was 12 and now I'm 21. I stream on Twitch once every few days and frequently have 1,000+ people watching me, subscribing, following and most importably putting eyeballs on Twitch's adverts (which is one of the largest concurrent none-featured community.) If this happens I lose my anonymity (because Google+) which protects my account details from being stolen. If this happens I lose the ability to stream while playing music in the background, my followers even have the ability to request songs during the stream using an automated service, where does this leave me with regards to copyright then? Even worse than this though is that if this happens, Google will in some way fundamentally change a service which I and my followers love to use - a service which they don't understand. I speak for myself as a well known member of this community: If Google buys Twitch, Twitch will die. This video basically (and very explosively) explains the current thinking of Twitch users: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loeFYdbvrZM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loeFYdbvrZM (turn down your sound)
- asdkl234890 13y agoYouTube is a Juggernaut. But Twitch is not, and most of its audience is very young and focused on technology, manly video games. They will move fast. Create the next Twitch now. Wait for YouTube to force content restrictions on the old Twitch. Profit.
- mattstreet 13y agoAnd then when you're big, sell out like everyone else.
- GhotiFish 13y agoit's the CIIIIIIIRRRCLE OF LIIIIIIIIIFE
- dpacmittal 13y agoThey could keep twitch independently running.