4 ms·
Why didn't you challenge the takedown notice as being fraudulent? As far as I know, DMCA does not prohibit linking to web pages; it's only about hosting someone
by greenyoda 13y ago
Why didn't you challenge the takedown notice as being fraudulent? As far as I know, DMCA does not prohibit linking to web pages; it's only about hosting someone else's copyrighted content on your site (or maybe posting links to pirated content).
- ronnier 13y agoI just don't have time to deal with it. Removing it was the quickest way possible for me to resolve the issue and not have my account closed.
- simon_vetter 13y agoand, if they're abusing the DMCA like others have said, you're giving in to FUD, which is exactly what they want.
- WildUtah 13y agoChallenging a DMCA takedown requires you to accept that your whole site will be taken down for ten days while you wait to have a right to challenge the takedown. Businesses or projects that have to keep functioning have to comply with any takedown regardless of its validity because they can't just go out of business for ten days in order to challenge it.
- greenyoda 13y agoWouldn't temporarily removing the disputed item pending the resolution of the challenge prevent your entire site from being taken down?
- duskwuff 13y agoYou don't even need to formally challenge it. Any DMCA takedown request requesting that a link be removed is malformed, becuase it does not identify a copyrighted work that is being infringed. You can safely ignore such a request, or bounce it back requesting that the sender specify what copyrighted work is in question.
- mnw21cam 13y agoYes, but the person receiving the DMCA request was the hosting service, which had no intention of being sane. DMCA takedown notices cannot be ignored.