3 ms·
Extensive discussion from 6 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=122106 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=122106 Scott Aaronson's reply: http://w
by ColinWright 13y ago
Extensive discussion from 6 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=122106 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=122106
Scott Aaronson's reply: http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=312 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=312
That was submitted[0] six years ago, but got no discussion at all.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=123584 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=123584
There have been many, many more occasions when this was submitted,
- dnautics 13y agoScott's quip "many PhD programs even see training students for industry as a fundamental part of their mission." Has long been true for chemistry and biology, and that has possibly staved off the phenomenon for a bit longer than it was for physics (original article, 1999), but it is certainly now true in these fields too. Of course, these are all anecdotes, by which I mean data strongly filtered through confirmation bias. So it's worth thinking about the bias here; we have tons of grad students and postdocs comiserating, and a select few professors. One of which says it's miserable and is trying to warn people in the future, and the other who has had a fabulously successful career saying everything's more or less fine.
- lutorm 13y agoIt is really a simple analysis: The number of tenured faculty is not increasing, so to have a long-term sustainable job market, each one can only graduate one PhD. The actual number over their career is probably more like 5-10. Every one except one of them will not get a tenured faculty job, that's just basic numbers.
- carlob 13y ago> The actual number over their career is probably more like 5-10 Where did you get that number? I think that number is actually closer to the number of PhD's in training at any given time. The number over a career is probably 10x that. Heck, I can name one professor who whas 25 PhD students at any given time.
- mturmon 13y agoTotally right. Polarizing/absolutist proclamations like the OP tend to start noisy, unhelpful discussions on HN. It's even worse when (as here) the OP concerns a general topic where most HN readers have anecdotal evidence, but only anecdotal evidence. This kind of outrageous statement can be kind of fun in a small group, at dinner or a bar, but not here (IMO).
- dang 13y agoDo you think the discussion in this thread is that bad? I don't—mainly because many people have been commenting from significant relevant experience. The replies to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7763777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7763777, for example, are really good.
- mturmon 13y agoNo, it's not truly bad, just very anecdotal, and I think we can do better. (But I didn't flag the article.) Also -- the peripheral concerns around this particular writer, who has written on a variety of red-button topics, can make things go downhill fast.
- geekam 13y agoOP here. I'd like to say that I did not know about the author's other controversial articles and many of which I find disturbing. I was on a journey to figure out whether PhD (esp. in other fields than your prior ones) makes sense, for myself and while doing so came across this article and HN seemed like a nice place to have a discussion. My apologies to not have searched HN prior to submitting this, to see if it will be a re-post. However, even if comments were anecdotal, it still helped me understand the gravity of the situation.
- dang 13y agoAnecdotes are just fine on Hacker News. They belong in conversation. People communicate in stories. Citing studies is fine too, but not required. This is a forum, not a journal.