2 ms·
"I've often wondered whether similar issues occur in flatter open-allocation style organizations." You can stop wondering: Yes. Hierarchies emerge in almost a
by jerf 13y ago
"I've often wondered whether similar issues occur in flatter open-allocation style organizations."
You can stop wondering: Yes.
Hierarchies emerge in almost any non-trivial human endeavor. It's not hard to understand why, a simple model can demonstrate it. Imagine a group of 50 people in a club or something. Imagine each of the 50 people have a probability distribution of how likely they are to prefer to listen to somebody uniformly randomly initialized. Every time a person listens to somebody, and the outcome is good, they're slightly more likely to listen in the future, imagine that if it goes badly, they're slightly less. Iterate on the outcome of decisions; in short order, a hierarchy will emerge, in only slightly more time, it will become very strong. (Probably even if the outcome of decisions is random, but certainly if the outcome is not, and in practice while there is always a random component there is certainly a difference in people's abilities to make quality decisions. Oh, and BTW, the exact definition of "quality" is use hardly matters... "decisions with outcomes that superficially look good to the rest of the club but is actually to their detriment while making me look good" is a popular pathological variant, for instance. Think math here... regardless of the decision quality metric chosen, that metric will produce some hierarchy.)
Claiming you're going to eliminate informal hierarchies is essentially equivalent to claiming you're going to eliminate communication, or the eliminate consideration of the consequences of decisions made... in either case you're creating an organization that is pathologically disconnected from reality from the get-go.
You're far better off harnessing this process, guiding it, and understanding where it can go wrong and how it can go wrong, than trying to simply deny it. The solution to weeds is tending the garden, not declaring this whole plant idea fundamentally flawed and salting the earth.