3 ms·
There is an easy econ 101 answer response. If you're really trying to help the poor at the (presumably managable) expense of everyone else, then subsidize the
by jessriedel 13y ago
There is an easy econ 101 answer response. If you're really trying to help the poor at the (presumably managable) expense of everyone else, then subsidize the subscriptions of the poor households by explicitly taxing. This dramatically reduces market distortions and makes clear exactly what's happening. Putting up rules that require the rich to indirectly subsidize the poor in the way being described (making the tax invisible) predictably leads to an awful situation.
People often reply "this isn't politically feasible", but that's giving up the game. If the opaque, inefficient, and difficult-to-measure strategy is politically feasible but the transparent one is not, that's a good sign it's a bad choice.
- cam_l 13y agoYep. Though subsidising subscriptions is a pretty non transparent way of tendering for access. If you are in the business of creating lots of little monopolies to achieve universal access, wouldn't it be more transparent to just create one big monopoly? We tried this in oz. A gov. built backbone to be sold off (the naturally competitive part), with a gov. built and maintained 'fibre to the home' access (the natural monopoly part). Fox / News waged a months long campaign to have them booted out of office, in which they explicitly and repeatedly called the gov. nazi's, and outrageously lied about the associated costs for both the gov. and opposition broadband systems. Now we have a system which locks in contracts for the backbone, and rents copper infrastructure for the next 50 years for access. If you want fibre access, you have to pay for it to be hooked up at a prohibitively large cost. We know we can deliver access to everyone in oz through gov. for close to the price of delivering access to a privileged few through market monopolies. At a certain point, you have to realise this isn't about bad political choice, but a deliberate and sustained attempt to lock in privilege for the wealthy at the expense of everyone else. This is the real market distortion.
- brucefancher 13y agoGovernment can barely deliver the mail and you're going to offer broadband competitively?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rwl 13y ago> If you're really trying to help the poor at the (presumably managable) expense of everyone else, then subsidize the subscriptions of the poor households by explicitly taxing. Isn't this exactly what local governments are doing? It's just that the tax falls on the (shareholders of) broadband companies, who are presumably not, for the most part, local residents. The reason this is more politically feasible is not that it isn't a tax, but that the tax is not being levied on voters. Or does the name matter that much?
- nardi 13y agoThe problem is that taxing entrants into the cable market creates a very high barrier to entry. The tax is not being levied directly on voters, but indirectly, by creating a monopoly that provides poor service, when they could instead have competition providing great service.
- rwl 13y ago> The tax is not being levied directly on voters, but indirectly, by creating a monopoly that provides poor service, when they could instead have competition providing great service. But isn't the point here precisely that without the tax or other barriers to entry, "they" would not have great service? Some might -- but it seems likely that far fewer would get it than with build-out requirements and so on in place. I think the government has an obligation to avoid leaving those people behind in this case.
- jessriedel 13y agoWell, yes and no. An explicit tax on the company by the local government would still be better than a build-out requirement, since this would at least be transparent. But even if you want to transfer money from someone to the poor, and (perhaps unethically) you want to take it from someone who's not a voter, it still makes no sense to pick on this particular company. Why not tax any of the other non-voting companies that service a locality? Say, the tax on coca-cola?
- rwl 13y ago
- sergiosgc 13y agoExplicitly taxing and subsidizing involves the kind of economy planning you don't want in a free market. Plus, it's a permanent fix. It's much easier for the government to build the fiber infrastructure, lease it to operators in the short term, possibly sell it or spin it off in the medium term. Just give the free market a bump to move it out of a local maximum.