4 ms·
I think part of the problem is that both you and the blogger are talking about hiring interchangeable bottom-level workers. I assume you're not talking about s
by Pxtl 13y ago
I think part of the problem is that both you and the blogger are talking about hiring interchangeable bottom-level workers. I assume you're not talking about skilled labour like electricians and millwrights. You're talking about unskilled workers. Highschool-educated guys.
The blogger mentioned secretaries. Not somebody who has credentials they've honed and invested in.
Even without an education, a professional needs to build success to make the difference between a "job" and a "profession". People who don't have any credentials like that are basically used as interchangeable parts in the job market - one CSR or one stock-room worker is replaceable with any other.
And likewise, they can (and should) treat their employer as just as interchangeable. Everybody needs customer service workers. Everybody needs guys who'll push a cart and lift stuff.
I used to do software for steel warehouses. I met brilliant electricians and accountants and whatnot, but I also dealt with the truckers and the gals who worked the desk with the truckers. And that's where the difference was.
It's hard to discuss this stuff without being really, really classist, because I don't think it's about "class" so much as the investment a person makes in their career. But I think that this "investment" is what makes this difference - is it a job or a career?
- fleitz 13y agoYeah it's the difference between living to work, and working to live.
- DanBC 13y ago> The blogger mentioned secretaries. Not somebody who has credentials they've honed and invested in. Have you ever worked with a good secretary? It sounds like you haven't.
- Pxtl 13y agoI've worked with great men and women in every field, secretaries included. But the blogger was talking about secretaries, so secretaries are obviously a pain-point for her. My point is just that you run into more sources of trouble in those jobs that have no barrier to entry - no investment needed for it.
- DanBC 13y ago"No barrier to entry" for secretaries? That's a failure of people hiring secretaries, not of secretaries. Take, for example, typing. Many people on HN will have fast typing speeds. But we also see that many people on HN want to wear headphones or have separate areas for work. There is talk of "flow". A secretary does not have these luxuries. They have to produce fast typing, with high accuracy, in combination with constant interruption. Good secretaries can type a letter while talking to someone. Have you ever tried shorthand? Take a look at Pittman Shorthand. Take a course. Tell me it's not a barrier to entry.
- Entrepreneur- 13y agoHi everyone! Thank you for your comments and suggestions. I am the author of the post Clarissa ran on her blog. To clarify, every single employee I have is university educated. My secretary had a Master's Degree (she was young so the role was a stepping stone into a very different position). Not sure if that changes anything, but thought I would point it out.
- majani 13y agoThat username wasn't taken before today? Colour me shocked!
- Entrepreneur- 13y agoIt was - I added a 'dash' ;)
- Noelkd 13y agoA space and a dash and it would have been perfect!
- mamoswined 13y ago"she was young so the role was a stepping stone into a very different position" In the old days the secretary position was a vocation in itself. Now I see two types of people: - someone who actually wants to do something else. They tend to at least not be stupid, but they aren't going to give a ton of time to honing their secretarial skills either and are going to leave as soon as they get the job they really want. - someone who frankly just isn't very bright. Secretarial work is unfortunately not very high status these days. People who are ambitious and intelligent don't generally chose to be secretaries.
- niels_olson 13y agoBut you can't swing a cat without hitting an executive assistant three years out of college and using it as a stepping stone. The value proposition of being the boss's calendar-keeper has been reversed.
- stcredzero 13y agoThe blogger mentioned secretaries. Not somebody who has credentials they've honed and invested in. Some secretaries are awesome, though.
- mediaman 13y agoIt's true, there can be many issues with lower level workers. But in skilled trades it is common to find people who have interesting quirks to their personality, despite being very good at their job technically. I see this often in skilled machinists, welders, machine maintenance people, etc. Some people may call the quirks "unprofessional" but it can come with the territory. Quirks are fine as long as they aren't destructive to others or to the common goal. Sometimes it does make it a challenge though because there just aren't that many people out there with the necessary skill and experience, especially in more specialized areas, so you wind up having to choose between someone with a fantastic attitude but limited skill and a very skilled tradesperson that takes a little more hands-on management (in the sense that you have to help them develop more empathy, to not quarrel, to communicate better with colleagues, etc). It's definitely a fine line. Somebody with great skill can still cause too much havoc within a team and make it an undesirable place to work. You have to take action on that, because ultimately it needs to be a happy place to work. And it's not a pay issue either, we've hired people well into the six figure range who at the end of the day just couldn't develop functional relationships with others.