4 ms·
What is your point? > few 150 pound blobs of jelly can survive getting flung across the street. Which is why I put more effort into riding safely and defensiv
by shkkmo 13y ago
What is your point?
> few 150 pound blobs of jelly can survive getting flung across the street.
Which is why I put more effort into riding safely and defensively than I do in riding predictably. This is why (depending on traffics, shoulder, lighting, pedestrian visibility and driveways) there are many situations where I will go onto the sidewalk with my bike. (The main reason I do this is to use walk signals rather than risking following traffic laws and using the left turn lane.)
> a biker who runs a red light through the intersection.
They did not follow the idaho stop law. I think you are arguing against a strawman.
> When a bicyclist flaunts the basic rules of traffic, rules meant to keep people safe in a world of multi-ton vehicles, they force drivers into situations that often end badly only for the person without the airbags.
Which is why we should establish rules of the road for bicyclists that make sense, and will be easily followed by the majority of bicyclists. Then we enforce those rules against the 5% of arrogant jerks.
> When you're driving a car, predictability and muscle memory are pretty much the only thing that keeps you alive and anything out of the ordinary is a danger that you must prepare for and avoid.
Predictability helps, but:
Paying attention to your surroundings and not relying too heavily on predictability is how you avoid accidents and hurting people. This is true with or without bicyclists on the road.
Solely relying on muscle memory and predicability means you are a very BAD driver.
- dredmorbius 13y agoWhich is why I put more effort into riding safely and defensively than I do in riding predictably. These aren't mutually exclusive. Nor is situational awareness, which you mention. I'll hog the lane if not doing so increases risks or increases the likelihood I'll have to respond unpredictably to sudden events (doors opening, pedestrians, vehicles entering or leaving the lane). I do agree generally that a slightly laxer set of regulations for bikes may well apply. My experience with urban cyclists suggests that the line is rather short of where many of them place it.
- shkkmo 13y ago> My experience with urban cyclists suggests that the line is rather short of where many of them place it. I have a suspicion that this is the case of a few bad apples and selection bias. I don't think the majority push the rules much past what is described in the article. > I do agree generally that a slightly laxer set of regulations for bikes may well apply What do you think of the specific rules proposed in the article?
- dredmorbius 13y agoWhile I agree it's not the majority, as with the case of drivers and h-bombs, just a few can ruin your whole day.
- akiselev 13y agoWhat's the strawman? Collision(Car + Bicyclist) = Dead or hurt bicyclist almost every single time. Is that in contention? Idaho can have it's Idaho stop, but in my big congested city I believe it's better and safer for everyone to keep green lights clear of any and all orthogonal traffic, especially when the odds of survival are so one sided and the gains so inconsequential. > Paying attention to your surroundings and not relying too heavily on predictability is how you avoid accidents and hurting people. This is true with or without bicyclists on the road. > Solely relying on muscle memory and predicability means you are a very BAD driver. I can't even... what are you saying? Paying attention to your surroundings is how you predict (which is why the predictability of other animate actors is important) and muscle memory is how you get better at dealing with all situations, mundane or extreme, through practice and experience.
- shkkmo 13y ago> What's the strawman? I said: >They did not follow the idaho stop law. The straw man is equating someone who runs a red without stopping or checking for traffic with someone who follows the idaho stop law. > Paying attention to your surroundings is how you predict Huh? Making assumptions based on past experience is how you predict. If you are relying on your assumptions about what people are doing and not carefully watching what they are doing is a danger. Obviously, all three (attention, prediction, and muscle memory) contribute to safe driving. However, I would rather have a driving that is watching what I am doing than a driving that thinks he can predict what I am doing. That is why I objected to this line "When you're driving a car, predictability and muscle memory are pretty much the only thing that keeps you alive". >>> Solely relying on muscle memory and predicability means you are a very BAD driver. This is how I see most drivers operate. This is why there are certain areas where as pedestrian I have to yield to traffic even though I have the right of way. Very few drivers pay proper attention to their surroundings.