3 ms·
From the article: With his earnest hope that we can all live to 90 by eating better and his toe-curling philosophizing about rights, Mackey manages to bracket s
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
From the article: With his earnest hope that we can all live to 90 by eating better and his toe-curling philosophizing about rights, Mackey manages to bracket some of the most extreme views on health care, and show both sides just how unappealing and impractical they are.
Many studies with good controls have failed to show that variations in medical care have any effect on health. On the other hand, lifestyle factors (food, exercise, smoking) have very large measurable effects. You might not like Mackey's philosophy, but his facts are solid.
See Robin Hanson's review (and cited sources) for some hard numbers:
http://www.cato-unbound.org/2007/09/10/robin-hanson/cut-medicine-in-half/ http://www.cato-unbound.org/2007/09/10/robin-hanson/cut-medi...
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoThe author doesn't seem to disagree (with you or Mackey) on this point, he just thinks it's impractical to expect human nature to change. I think it's been widely accepted for a while that in first world countries we are literally killing ourselves with food, stress, cigarettes etc. On the other hand, I thought people living longer was one of the problems facing society/medicine since even the healthiest of old people need more care than, to be blunt, the dead.
- justindz 17y agoThe trap I've heard described is that people are living longer thanks to "hardcore" medicine like heart bypass and other things which prolong but do not always improve the quality of life, along with greater general food security, yada yada. However, they are not living as long as they necessarily could in a theoretically perfect environment AND they are not living to greater ages with the same general level of health they could with better behavior. The last bit is what creates the actuarial and cost problems--people living longer but needing more attention and intervention throughout their life. So, and I think you agree here, the optimum situation would be to improve general lifestyle habits and have people live older, more productive lives on average without generating excess costs relative to what we see today. If that's possible, it's a good goal. And since it can be improved incrementally in both directions (quality up, cost down) without a 100% see-saw effect, it seems like an attainable goal.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoAlso, I was suprised, given the source, to find this recommendation in your link, apparently one of the best ways to improve health by paradoxically spending less: "nationalizing the industry and using agency budgets to limit spending."
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThat's not a proposal to improve health, it's a proposal to spend less money on medicine. A more complete quote: I thus claim: we could cut U.S. medical spending in half without substantial net health costs. This would give us the equivalent of an 8% pay raise. How should we cut medical spending? ...cut ... our government and corporate subsidies for medicine... give medicine far less prestige than we now do...taxing medicine, limiting it by law, or nationalizing the industry and using agency budgets to limit spending. He then acknowledges that most of his ideas are not politically feasible.
- Afton 17y agoThat article is worth posting to HN. Please do so. It seems just obvious to me that a frank discussion about the economics of health care would be a prerequisite for health-care reform.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoPosted. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=775284 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=775284