4 ms·
It's not like they said "proprietary software is evil". They say "[issues] inevitably arise when proprietary software is installed on a user's computer." That's
by dTal 13y ago
It's not like they said "proprietary software is evil". They say "[issues] inevitably arise when proprietary software is installed on a user's computer." That's a very mild statement that's hard to argue with.
>not everything has or needs to be open source to treat its users ethically
The FSF's entire raison d'etre is to disagree with that statement, and they do so eloquently. If you have a different view, that's fine, but you need to engage with their arguments a bit more deeply than just contradicting the premise.
>some people do need to make a living from their software
People make a living selling all sorts of things. This has no bearing on the ethics of doing so.
>most people are completely fine with having the ability to install what they want
...which is typically the first thing to go in closed ecosystems.
>a single, ironically restricted set of freedoms
Freedom of the sort we're talking about here is zero-sum. Your freedom to swing your fist ends at my face. Would you call that "ironically restricted"? The FSF argues not unreasonably that your freedom to run private software ends at other people's computers.
- blueskin_ 13y agoIf I choose to run Windows as well as Linux, if I choose to install software I purchased, it doesn't harm RMS. In fact, it doesn't harm anyone as long as I'm aware of any potential direct personal impact, which goes for any software including open source.