3 ms·
Well since this is a short story, we probably need reviews so people know whether it's worth their time to read it. Here's mine: As far as 11th-grade high scho
by peterwwillis 13y ago
Well since this is a short story, we probably need reviews so people know whether it's worth their time to read it. Here's mine:
As far as 11th-grade high school english lit writing assignments go, this one is pretty good. I like how the author tells the reader technical things without ever trying to explain them, assuming that his readership is completely familiar with the subject matter. I also like how there's virtually no character development whatsoever, the ending is forced, and there's no conflict or strife in this idealized post-apocalyptic world. Anyone who would normally fight or kill for resources has apparently died, leaving only calm, rational citizens to share plentiful provisions.
My favorite part is how completely emotionally detached the protagonist is. His wife and baby boy dies, and he's basically alright about 5 minutes later. Each time he remembers them he seems to feel sad, then forget about them like an alzheimer patient. No shock, no panic, no guilt, no sorrow. Just a completely emotionally dead nerd who's more focused on his computers than his real relationships. It puts a realistic face on what could have been just another cypherpunk dystopian piece of drivel.
- angersock 13y agoWow, careful you don't cut yourself on that edge. He doesn't explain the details because it really doesn't matter a huge amount from a technical standpoint; either you're in the know (a fellow admin/hacker/dev) or you aren't, and in neither case does Tom Clancy or Neal Stephenson-like drooling over the tech matter. As for the complaint about emotional detachment, everyone handles these things differently. Especially in the case where something so close to you is gone, it can take a long time to process it. Grief and assimilation is handled differently. I'm sorry it wasn't a masturbatory journey into the grim future and anarchy of post-apocalypse--perhaps you'd enjoy the Dies the Fire series more.
- wtbob 13y agoYeah, my back's sore from all the geeky back-patting.
- a_bonobo 13y agoThis is the reason why I stopped reading Doctorow, it's all just 'geeky back-patting'. His stance on copyright is very black and white, and he uses his books to preach this black and white 'internet is best' world-view - Makers for example has the 100% good open blogger vs. the 100% evil traditional journalist, Down and out in the magic kingdom has post-scarcity financial system based on how much people like you on the internet.. It's all just preaching to the choir mixed with an obsession with Disney, and I learn nothing new from his writings. Edit: Why the downvote?
- fabulist 13y agoI think you guys may have missed something. The protagonists feels a lot of emotion, but they mourn in a sad and silent way. They spend the whole story trying to get over what happened to their family. Its far from clear that the Internet is best, or that anyone is doing the right thing. I'll give you that Doctorow's novels celebrate technology; birds are also going to fly, and fish are going to swim. And when a nerdy sysadmins write about nerdy sysadmins, the story will have a certain bend to it. Its cool that you guys didn't like it, maybe you could express that in a way that isn't pedantic.
- blueskin_ 13y agoExactly the point. Most people there lost someone. If I was in that situation, I'd be completely devastated inside, but I'd keep working, trying to make the best with what I can in the hopes that it creates a better world out of what's left. That's the point of what any of them were trying to do.