3 ms·
The HTML working group at W3C has clearly rejected Google/Microsoft/Netflix proposal on both technical and ideological grounds, but the decision has been overri
by pornel 13y ago
The HTML working group at W3C has clearly rejected Google/Microsoft/Netflix proposal on both technical and ideological grounds, but the decision has been overridden by group's Chair, and further objections have been bypassed by forming a new, pro-DRM working group out of public view.
The EME spec draft has been published almost unchanged, even though it has known significant flaws, e.g. most of the spec is non-normative and it's been acknowledged (without a fix) that the key diagram is factually incorrect (shows that the browser is trusted).
It seems like corporate interests within W3C are much stronger than W3C's integrity.
I suspect it even goes farther than Google and Netflix using their market share and influence to pass the spec — they've probably been blackmailed by MPAA & co. that would pull the plug on Netflix and Google Play if they didn't do what they've been told to.
- throwaway2048 13y agoThe W3C and major tech corporations aren't separate entities, the people sitting on the W3C boards WORK for these companies. Don't fall for the smokescreen.
- wfjackson 13y ago>I suspect it even goes farther than Google and Netflix using their market share and influence to pass the spec — they've probably been blackmailed by MPAA & co. that would pull the plug on Netflix and Google Play if they didn't do what they've been told to Add to that Youtube being able to now use EME to stop downloader extensions and get more streaming deals and it helps explains why Google pushed Netflix support on Chromebooks as one of the first real world implementations of EME.
- guelo 13y agoThe W3C doesn't really have any power as was demonstrated by the failure of XHTML and the ultimate triumph of WHATWG. The history of the web has shown since the <blink> days that those who write the code to the popular browsers set the standards. The last 10 years have been a miracle of openness after Mozilla wrestled the web away from Microsoft, but now they are becoming powerless in the face of a Google-Apple-Microsoft industry alliance. Mozilla's desperate attempt to to stay relevant by distributing a closed source blob will fail. The closed source future will be increasingly anti-user. Personally I blame Larry Page, the old idealistic Google would have allied with Mozilla and could have stopped this.
- yuhong 13y agoPersonally I blame Larry Page, the old idealistic Google would have allied with Mozilla and could have stopped this. Huh? I think it is more complex than that.
- shkkmo 13y agoObviously it's complex. Larry Page still failed to do a single thing to stop it (that I know of) and he is probably the single person with the most power to oppose this.
- yuhong 13y agoEME is not on the top of my list though, though this claim reminds me of this incident: http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=3106555&cid=41288357 http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=3106555&cid=41288357
- Pacabel 13y agoBlaming Mozilla's decreasing influence on a vague and alleged "Google-Apple-Microsoft industry alliance" isn't really accurate. While the corporate players involved may just happen to have interests that might align somewhat in this case, Mozilla has made its fair share of mistakes that have driven people away from Firefox. A browser with fewer users results in less influence for its creator and users, obviously. Phoenix, Firebird and Firefox before version 4 were generally excellent releases. This was back when Mozilla innovated and put out offerings that benefited users. These versions truly made people better off, and much of Firefox's rapid adoption was due to direct word-of-mouth recommendation. Then around Firefox 4, they decided to imitate Chrome, rather than leading the way. The release schedule changes caused broken add-ons for a very long time. This drove people away. They've also repeatedly made harmful UI changes, to the point where Firefox today is almost visually identical to Chrome. This has driven more people away. Meanwhile, there has only been minimal progress when it comes to improving the performance of Firefox, and reducing its memory usage. This, too, has driven more people away to browsers that manage to perform better, with fewer resources. (Spare us the are-we-fast-yet-style benchmarks that just don't seem to match the actual browsing experience.) Nobody but Mozilla themselves made Mozilla act in such a manner. Nobody but Mozilla themselves are responsible for driving away so many Firefox users. And so here we are today, with Firefox at perhaps 15% to 20% of the browser market, if even that. This is a far cry from their peak, when they were above 30%. They no longer offer an appealing product, which causes a decrease in the number of people using it, which directly results in the unfortunate lack of influence that we're seeing in this case.