4 ms·
There is a long history of trying out different ways to teach physics to undergraduates. In my undergraduate college the faculty experimented with starting with
by leephillips 13y ago
There is a long history of trying out different ways to teach physics to undergraduates. In my undergraduate college the faculty experimented with starting with quantum mechanics and ending up with classical physics; introductory calculus was sometimes taught using nonstandard analysis. My thesis advisor in graduate school wrote an intro physics text that included simulations from the beginning, in the `80s. He even wrote a special version of Basic that used vectors to make it easier for students. In Germany it's popular to teach mechanics using momentum currents instead of the force concept.
I agree that introducing numerics early is risky: it's easy to get what looks like a smooth, convergent solution from a naive calculation that happens to be wrong.
- judk 13y agoRichard Feynman taught simulation (of planetary orbits) in his famous first-year lectures (which became the famous text book) with a page long table of computed values, and remarked that this was a powerful new technique that was going to dominate physics as computers increased in power.
- leephillips 13y agoThis might have been what inspired my advisor, who's thesis advisor was Feynman (making Feynman my grand-advisor).