4 ms·
If we have platforms A and B, and A is more aligned with your interests than B, then we have an advantage in having everyone on A rather than on B. You're pres
by StavrosK 13y ago
If we have platforms A and B, and A is more aligned with your interests than B, then we have an advantage in having everyone on A rather than on B.
You're presenting a false dichotomy: "Either Mozilla doesn't compromise anywhere, or they might as well go away". Things aren't black and white.
- magicalist 13y agoSure, but if the only thing to weigh is "will we lose users if we don't implement this feature?" and the only reason given why it's different this time is the assertion that this time it's different, I think you can understand the sentiment. Besides, I think the argument is more "Either Mozilla doesn't compromise where it's important not to, or they might as well go away", which is a true statement. Mozilla does need to continue to exist, and compromise is fundamental to the web (it's right there in their manifesto), but this was something that should have been fought tooth and nail. The protest of this mostly involved sternly written emails to W3C lists, when it should have been simply not implementing it and holding that ground until it was clear no alternatives were viable and imminent harm was actually demonstrated.
- shkkmo 13y agoIf Mozilla only fights 1 of 4 of the 'important' battles, that's still better than fighting 0 'important' battles.
- magicalist 13y agoIf Mozilla only fought one of every four important battles, I would seriously have to reassess my opinion of Mozilla.
- shkkmo 13y agoWell, yes. I was making the point that 1 of 4 is still useful. Obviously it is less useful than fighting 4 of 4 or 3 of 4.
- iopq 13y agoNot if platform A compromises until it becomes B, in which case you don't care anymore.
- bzbarsky 13y agoThat's true, but note that Mozilla's proposed EME implementation is quite different from the ones that have shipped so far in terms of how much power it grants the CDM, for example.