7 ms·
It is the wrong choice. It's the same BS I remember reading on slides from graphics card vendors excusing some other way of selling the user down the river. C
by barrkel 13y ago
It is the wrong choice.
It's the same BS I remember reading on slides from graphics card vendors excusing some other way of selling the user down the river.
Content can adapt to reach their customers. Bend here and the web itself is under threat.
Mozilla needs a social contract like Debian, since it seems clear they can't rely on leadership for backbone.
- TylerE 13y agoDid you seriously just equate closed source graphics drivers to slavery?
- valleyer 13y agoCan you explain how you came to that interpretation?
- TylerE 13y agoWhere do you think the phrase "sold down the river" came from - from slaves being sold to be sent down the Mississippi River to the slave markets in New Orleans.
- tragic 13y agoI do hope you never use the word 'sinister', which of course comes from the old belief that left-handed people are somehow the spawn of the devil. Or refer to someone getting "their pound of flesh", which is Shakespeare's quaint variant on the blood libel. Etc, etc.
- kylek 13y agoat least he didn't Godwin's Law[0] it? [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law
- joaren 13y agoNo, he used a figure of speech, which you chose to interpret in the least useful way possible.
- qnaal 13y ago#rekt
- mmanfrin 13y agoWhen someone says 'Goodbye' to you, do you lecture them on the religious origins of the word ('God be with ye')?
- beedogs 13y agoUh oh, we've got someone here who can't comprehend hyperbole.
- yourad_io 13y agoTIL "sells down the river"'s origins. http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/326500.html http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/326500.html Damn. Thanks for that, had no idea and have probably used it once or twice. Back into passive vocabulary you go. (Non-native english yada yada)
- Silhouette 13y agoBend here and the web itself is under threat. Don't bend here and Mozilla itself could be under threat. DRM exists, many major content providers have shown little interest in releasing their material without a mechanism for preventing casual copying (and you can hardly blame them), and accessing multimedia downloads is an increasingly important function of the Web. Denying that reality isn't going to achieve anything useful. As much as Mozilla might like to take a principled stand, the fact is that they aren't important enough to force this issue. If someone can't access content in Firefox, they don't not access the content, they just use another browser. The content provider still served their content, the user still watched it, and it was still DRM'd. The only practical difference is that Mozilla lost a user. You fight the battles you can win. There is no way Mozilla could win this one.
- IgorPartola 13y agoWhat's more important Mozilla or the web? This is a case where Mozilla thinks that by sticking around they can do more good than by killing this particular attack on the free web. Can we justify this completely? IMHO, no. Perhaps the whole existence of Mozilla was leading up to this point where it could commit ritualistic suicide and take this DRM proposal with it. Of course nobody at Mozilla will see it that way. Organizations are made of people and whatever the organization's mission is, the people are foremost concerned with one thing: self-preservation through preservation of the organization.
- msbarnett 13y ago> Perhaps the whole existence of Mozilla was leading up to this point where it could commit ritualistic suicide and take this DRM proposal with it. Except, if Mozilla had committed "ritualistic suicide" over EME, it wouldn't have taken EME with it. Users would move to every other browser with HTML5 DRM implemented, Mozilla would die accomplishing nothing. A world with entrenched HTML5 DRM & Mozilla strikes me as strictly preferable to a world without Mozilla in which HTML5 DRM is just as entrenched.
- Xenmen 13y ago
- rbanffy 13y ago> It is the wrong choice. WHat would the web gain if Mozilla lost most of its user base? Could we trust Apple, Microsoft and Google to have a moral backbone?
- wyager 13y agoSo you're saying that keeping their userbase and losing their principles is better than losing their userbase and keeping their principles? Why do we care if users go to Apple/Google/etc. if Mozilla is no better than those companies anyway?
- Navarr 13y agoI, at least, am saying that keeping their userbase is better than becoming irrelevant.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- higherpurpose 13y agoJust because Mozilla says they will lose users if they don't do this, doesn't make it true. They've shown no evidence of trends that this is happening. They are simply adopting DRM out of fear. Also chasing popularity is like chasing money. It shouldn't be the goal. Those things follow after doing the right thing, and I believe for an organization with the kind of community and userbase Firefox has around it, not implementing DRM would've been the "right" thing to do.
- vehementi 13y agoIndeed... this is just throwing in the towel completely without putting up a fight. Here are various other ways: - do the work to implement the DRM thing but keep it disabled ready to hot patch in once evidence shows that they'll be fucked without it - display "this is bullshit DRM content you shouldn't support, read more HERE, and click HERE if you really don't care and will use another browser to view this anyway" in place of the DRM content initially etc. Immediately giving in is hardly "dragged kicking and screaming".