3 ms·
> My issue isn't with Stripe. It's with the language around net neutrality. Basically 1000+ entrepreneurs and VC's who generally bemoan all things government ar
by jessriedel 13y ago
> My issue isn't with Stripe. It's with the language around net neutrality. Basically 1000+ entrepreneurs and VC's who generally bemoan all things government are now asking that this area be protected from market forces. Very awkward.
Right. There's a good argument to be made that ISPs have local monopolies (due either to natural failings of utility markets, or to crony government intervention, depending on your political persuasion) and therefore government regulation is a necessary evil that can be accepted in this case even by people who are generally free-market oriented. But that distinction must be made clear by anyone who wants to salvage their free-market credentials. Likewise, they must acknowledge that net neutrality will unfortunately destroy benefits that would naturally accrue in a without government regulation: the ability for users who need it to pay a premium for fast or reliable service, a la first class mail. (You can try to carve out exceptions for this with even more complex regulation, but the serious downsides of this must too be acknowledged.)
- Terr_ 13y ago> the ability for users who need it to pay a premium for fast or reliable service, a la first class mail So in that analogy, did the postal service also begin to mishandle regular mail that was being sent to certain specific apartments and office suites, in order to force people to buy first-class?
- ejain 13y ago> the ability for users who need it to pay a premium for fast or reliable service, a la first class mail Net Neutrality does not prohibit an ISP from charging their customers more for a faster or more reliable Internet connection; it simply prohibits the ISP from accepting money from Dominos to speed up access to their website (or slow down or even block access to Pizza Hut's website).
- jessriedel 13y agoBut I only want to pay a premium for a fast connection to certain websites, and I don't want to have to renegotiate with Comcast every time I'd like to connect to a new website that is worth enhancing with a fast connection. Nor, in a perfect world, should it be illegal for a website to cover this fee if the website can derive unusual profits from it. If net neutrality applied to mail, then it would be illegal for Amazon to send me pre-paid first-class envelopes for returns. (This turns out not to be useful for mail, but the analogous case could be very useful for data.)
- pdonis 13y ago> But I only want to pay a premium for a fast connection to certain websites What the cable companies are trying to do isn't about you, the user, paying a premium for faster access; it's about you, the user, and the web service provider, both paying a premium to your ISP for faster access--even though the service provider is already paying a premium to their own ISP for faster access to the Internet as a whole. From the ISP's point of view, selling you faster access only to certain websites would probably be a lot harder, technically, than selling you faster access to the whole Internet, because the ISP would have to inspect every packet you send or receive to see whether it was part of a connection with a website you want faster access to. Plus, you would have to have the physical bandwidth present anyway, which means you could just as easily get faster access to the entire Internet. So I don't see how an ISP could sell you faster access to a limited set of sites any more cheaply than faster access to the Internet as a whole; in fact it seems to me that it would be more expensive to do the former. > Nor, in a perfect world, should it be illegal for a website to cover this fee if the website can derive unusual profits from it. Websites that can benefit from faster access already do this in the real world: they put their content on CDNs--or in extreme cases, like Google or Facebook, they build their own CDNs--and spend extra resources in other ways to give users faster access to their content. What I think you're missing in all this is that the cable ISPs do not (currently) own the entire Internet; they only own their own networks. That means they can only extract artificial scarcity rents from their own customers, not from the rest of the Internet. What they would like to do is to effectively own the entire Internet so they can extract artificial scarcity rents from everybody.
- perrylaj 13y agoI don't think your analogy really makes sense. Allowing companies to pick and choose which content to deliver to customers already paying for access to said content is more like the post office saying "I know you paid for this mail already, but since you are a popular source of mail we want you to pay more." I can't imagine Ebay or Stamps.com getting charged MORE from USPS because they have higher shipment volume. You're effectively arguing in favor of spending more money for the same service you are currently getting (as the service providers getting charged are going to transfer that burden to you the consumer and Comcast will not lower rates to you).
- pdonis 13y ago> they must acknowledge that net neutrality will unfortunately destroy benefits that would naturally accrue in a without government regulation: the ability for users who need it to pay a premium for fast or reliable service, a la first class mail. You must be joking. First class mail service has consistently gotten more and more expensive for poorer and poorer service, while private companies like FedEx and UPS have consistently gotten cheaper for better and better service. Are you maintaining that this would not have happened if the rule that only the US Postal Service could carry first class mail had been abolished? It seems to me that, if anything, abolishing that regulation would have given us cheaper FedEx and UPS sooner.
- jusben1369 13y agoSpot on thank you.