3 ms·
Espionage vs. Surveillance
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoHaving "transparent" bulk surveillance over large civilian populations of billions sounds like an oxymoron. It's sort of contradictory to the goals of it.
- higherpurpose 13y agoYes, it still sounds "wrong" to me. Maybe the problem is in the way he's trying to explain it. He's clear about the espionage part and what the NSA should do, but not as clear about what the FBI/police should do. If it's going to do "surveillance" through warrants and such - then what's different about this model from what we have today? How do you do mass surveillance with "probable cause"? The two just don't mix. Yes, I know NSA is trying to do that anyway with the so called "FISA warrants", but those also sound wrong and unconstitutional to me. A warrant isn't a warrant if they have surveillance power over everyone.
- greatsuccess 13y agoIm really not feeling Bruce's direction here. He seems to be heading toward a copout on the mass surveillance issue. The question isnt really transparency, its the question of whether mass surveillance represents a violation of human rights. If 10 years from now I look out my window and see the drones circling, just because I can see them doesnt make me feel better. Also we should be asking ourselves, if NSA is surveilling entrie populations outside the US, what happens if some other state actor decides that is an act of war? Who could blame them?
- Zigurd 13y agoSchneier is describing the probable outcome, one way or another. Mass indiscriminate surveillance is going to end because future systems will be designed to treat monitoring as an attack. Only trivial information will live in the clear. Transparency will come because secret courts and their secret warrants will only acquire cyphertext. Even metadata will become obscured in a fog of junk and misdirection.