3 ms·
No, DRM does not enable the service because it's not an essential part of it. The service could work without DRM all the same while being ethical and more user
by shmerl 13y ago
No, DRM does not enable the service because it's not an essential part of it. The service could work without DRM all the same while being ethical and more user friendly at the same time. DRM is like a sickness attached to an otherwise healthy product. It only becomes better when you remove it.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's like saying the subway turnstile isn't an essential part of the subway. It's only true if you define "essential" in a narrow technical way that ignores the realities of having to monetize the use of products and services.
- shmerl 13y ago> realities of having to monetize the use of products and services. Essential means technically and financially essential. I.e. without it the service can't work or can't bring profit. DRM is neither of that. Those who require DRM [publishers] have no technical or financial reasons to justify it. No valid ones at least (all reasons they usually voice are false, and their true reasons they usually don't voice).
- rayiner 13y agoThat makes no sense. What "true reasons" do publishers have for DRM that aren't fundamentally financial?
- shmerl 13y agoI can think of several: 1. Monopolistic lock-in. DRM is more than often used to control the market. It happened with Apple in the past, and was one of the key reasons that music publishers realized that being DRM-free is actually better for them. This reason also includes DRM derivatives like DMCA-1201 and the like. It's all about control (over the markets, over users and etc.). 2. Covering one's incompetence. DRM is used to justify failing sales (i.e. when execs are questioned about why the product performs poorly, they say "Pirates! But worry not - we put more DRM in place"). 3. Ignorance and / or stupidity (many execs have no clue and might believe that DRM actually provides some benefit). This type can be called DRM Lysenkoism. None of these reasons are valid, all of them are crooked and anti-user, but they are often present in various combinations.
- rayiner 13y ago> 1. Monopolistic lock-in. DRM is more than often used to control the market. How does this benefit the publisher? They already have a exclusive rights to whatever particular movie you're watching.
- shmerl 13y agoIt's not always the publisher. It can benefit some middle parties which implement DRM. Or for example mobile carriers which use DRM to prevent users from switching. Or whatever other monopolistic lock-in scenario. When publishers realize that monopoly falls to some other hands, they quickly become sober and find common sense. When monopoly remains theirs, they pretend that DRM is needed for other reasons.