3 ms·
DRM is never great. Show me one user who actually appreciates DRM itself. What you meant above is that users like the service. They could like it even more if i
by shmerl 13y ago
DRM is never great. Show me one user who actually appreciates DRM itself. What you meant above is that users like the service. They could like it even more if it hadn't DRM garbage attached to it. I.e. DRM has nothing to do with what users like - it always degrades the quality of the service and the digital goods it delivers.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's like saying nobody likes the turnstile on the subway. Of course not, but it enables the service to exist in the form it does. I'd much rather go through the turnstile, as awkward as it can be if you've got a suitcase, etc, than be forced to watch advertisements during my subway ride...
- shmerl 13y agoNo, DRM does not enable the service because it's not an essential part of it. The service could work without DRM all the same while being ethical and more user friendly at the same time. DRM is like a sickness attached to an otherwise healthy product. It only becomes better when you remove it.
- rayiner 13y agoThat's like saying the subway turnstile isn't an essential part of the subway. It's only true if you define "essential" in a narrow technical way that ignores the realities of having to monetize the use of products and services.
- shmerl 13y ago> realities of having to monetize the use of products and services. Essential means technically and financially essential. I.e. without it the service can't work or can't bring profit. DRM is neither of that. Those who require DRM [publishers] have no technical or financial reasons to justify it. No valid ones at least (all reasons they usually voice are false, and their true reasons they usually don't voice).
- rayiner 13y agoThat makes no sense. What "true reasons" do publishers have for DRM that aren't fundamentally financial?
- shmerl 13y agoI can think of several: 1. Monopolistic lock-in. DRM is more than often used to control the market. It happened with Apple in the past, and was one of the key reasons that music publishers realized that being DRM-free is actually better for them. This reason also includes DRM derivatives like DMCA-1201 and the like. It's all about control (over the markets, over users and etc.). 2. Covering one's incompetence. DRM is used to justify failing sales (i.e. when execs are questioned about why the product performs poorly, they say "Pirates! But worry not - we put more DRM in place"). 3. Ignorance and / or stupidity (many execs have no clue and might believe that DRM actually provides some benefit). This type can be called DRM Lysenkoism. None of these reasons are valid, all of them are crooked and anti-user, but they are often present in various combinations.
- rayiner 13y ago> 1. Monopolistic lock-in. DRM is more than often used to control the market. How does this benefit the publisher? They already have a exclusive rights to whatever particular movie you're watching.
- shmerl 13y agoIt's not always the publisher. It can benefit some middle parties which implement DRM. Or for example mobile carriers which use DRM to prevent users from switching. Or whatever other monopolistic lock-in scenario. When publishers realize that monopoly falls to some other hands, they quickly become sober and find common sense. When monopoly remains theirs, they pretend that DRM is needed for other reasons.
- chimeracoder 13y ago> I'd much rather go through the turnstile, as awkward as it can be if you've got a suitcase, etc, than be forced to watch advertisements during my subway ride... That's quite a false dichotomy, since the service clearly can exist independently of DRM (both technically and economically). Furthermore, this dichotomy doesn't work either in your analogy (there are ads on the subway, and yet I still have to pay) or in the real case we're talking about (Hulu+ is paid service locked down by DRM, and it still shows advertisements).
- rayiner 13y agoI don't think Netflix, Amazon Video, etc, which don't show advertisements, could exist economically without DRM.
- shmerl 13y agoAmazon sells music perfectly without any DRM. It doesn't just exist - it brings them tons of profit. GOG sells games without DRM - and having growing profits. And etc. and etc. Your point disproved.
- rayiner 13y agoYou're assuming that market mechanics for music and movies is the same.
- shmerl 13y agoI assume that DRM has no effect on piracy (it doesn't) and it always degrades usability (it does). Which means scraping it off always has no financial impact except for improving usability of the service and reducing costs of using DRM itself. Better usability + more user friendliness = more satisfied users + more new users = more profit.
- rayiner 13y agoI don't think it's a reasonable assumption to make that DRM has no effect on piracy. It won't stop sophisticated pirates, but I do think it stops people from releasing an easy-to-use app that lets your grandma store Netflix movies locally.
- kaybe 13y agoWhat is happening here with the reply links? Apparently you two can still post but nobody else can (at least I cannot). Is that the new policy from a while ago?
- shmerl 13y agoYou can answer, but first you might need to click the "link" link. I'm not sure why it's needed sometimes. May be when discussion happens too rapidly, the site assumes it can be some spam bot or whatever. So it puts some roadblocks.
- mikeash 13y agoSome places don't use turnstiles. Instead, you voluntarily validate your ticket with a machine. To ensure compliance, random checks are performed, with a large penalty if you don't have a valid ticket. It's a pretty nice system. Similarly, some places don't use DRM. I don't think it's made it into the video space yet, but legitimate DRM-free music is common. It seems to work pretty well. To say that DRM enables the service to exist only works if there's no other, better way. But there is, and the only reason we don't get to have it is because of customer-hostile policies from media companies.
- tkfu 13y agoThe turnstile is actually a great analogy for DRM, including all of its flaws. And the turnstile isn't what allows subway service to exist. A turnstile isn't very hard to jump over. If the turnstile is the only enforcement mechanism, anyone who wants a free subway ride just has to vault over (or perhaps also glance around to see if there are cops nearby, google whether there are monitored cameras, or pull a hoodie over their face). There's an alternative, though: most places in Europe, there are no turnstiles, and nothing preventing you from getting on public transit without paying. It's a "trust but verify" system: you are required to validate your ticket before you get on the train, and occasionally someone comes around the train to check if you have a valid ticket, and issues a fine if you don't have one. With this method, the users aren't inconvenienced, enforcement costs are reduced, and everyone's happy. With the turnstile, you get massive queues at busy stations during rush hour, and by making this one mechanical device your sole point of enforcement, you've actually made it more likely that people who don't want to pay will cheat the system.
- rayiner 13y agoMany of those countries also have criminal penalties for fare evasion.
- dllthomas 13y agoAs it happens, a lot of subways don't have turnstiles or ads, but instead periodically check for tickets after you're on board. I don't think that's terribly relevant here, though.
- quasque 13y agoIf you're watching streamed video, the DRM is completely transparent. I don't see how that is a degradation in service. The only way it would be an issue is if you're trying to rip the stream. But if you've paid the provider for streaming only, rather than to download and keep a copy, then that's also not really degrading the quality of service. Similarly, the prohibition on bringing a video camera in to record cinema screenings does not reduce the quality of the cinema experience. In general, I don't really see a problem with DRM that is temporally bound to the moment of consumption.
- shmerl 13y ago> If you're watching streamed video, the DRM is completely transparent. I don't see how that is a degradation in service. It is crippling usability in several ways: 1. DRM is usually not portable (or not ported at least). I.e. most probably it's tied to certain devices / operating systems / applications and etc. For the end user it translates to "you can't watch it on the device / operating system / application of your choice". 2. DRM prevents backups. If the service goes bust or you lose connectivity - you have no access to your data. 3. DRM poses a security / privacy threat. Being transparent doesn't make it any better - it only makes it worse (think of a hidden camera). All those are clearly examples of degraded usability no matter how "transparent" some DRM is.
- quasque 13y agoRegarding your first point, hasn't this always been the case even before DRM? For example, one cannot directly interpret the magnetic fluctuations encoded onto a cassette tape - a tape player is needed to transduce the signal. DRM just takes this a step further by introducing cryptography and obfuscation into the decoding process. I don't think backups are relevant to DRM-laden streaming video, given that it's someone else's data that you happen to be observing. I'm not sure what you mean by a security and privacy threat. Surely it is no more of a threat than visiting potentially untrusted websites, or using closed-source or unverified open-source binaries, in the first place?
- shmerl 13y ago